Worked example · RE · Year 11
LNF: Literacy → Writing → Planning and organising for different purposes, audiences and context
A secure Year 11 plan and model paragraphs, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. Pupils may reach a different judgement; what matters is that the plan builds to it. The key idea: “always” is the word to attack. Most religious teaching strongly encourages forgiveness, but several traditions say it may depend on repentance, justice or safety.
(a) “always”. To agree completely you would have to show there are no exceptions at all, but Judaism links forgiveness to the wrongdoer’s repentance and Islam allows justice instead.
(b) Forgiveness means choosing to let go of anger and the wish for revenge against someone who has wronged you, without saying that what they did was right.
The pupil identifies the qualifier that decides the argument and writes a precise definition to anchor the introduction. Evidences criterion 3.
| Agree | Strength | Disagree | Strength |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jesus said forgive “seventy-seven times” and forgave from the cross (Christianity) | 3 | Teshuvah: the wrongdoer must first make amends and ask (Judaism) | 3 |
| Lord’s Prayer links God forgiving us to us forgiving others | 3 | Surah 42:40 allows justice; pardoning is praised but is a choice (Tariq) | 2 |
| Allah is Al-Ghafur; Surah 24:22 “Would you not like that Allah should forgive you?” | 2 | Humanist: forgiveness should never be forced and should not put anyone at risk (Owen) | 3 |
Non-religious view: Owen’s humanist point that forcing forgiveness can harm the victim.
Evidence from four viewpoints is sorted and weighed before writing, so the plan can put the strongest points where they matter most. Evidences criterion 1.
Judgement: Religious believers should almost always try to forgive, but “always” goes too far, because many traditions link forgiveness to repentance, justice and safety.
| Paragraph | Main point and evidence | Link |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Define forgiveness; most believers agree it matters; line: “almost always, but not always”. | “The strongest support comes from …” |
| 2 | Christianity: seventy-seven times, Luke 23:34, Lord’s Prayer. Islam: Al-Ghafur, 24:22. | “However, not every tradition sees it as unconditional.” |
| 3 | Judaism: teshuvah. Islam: 42:40 allows justice. Humanist: never forced. | “So which side is stronger?” |
| 4 | Weigh: both sides value forgiveness; the disagreement is about conditions. | “Therefore …” |
| 5 | Judgement: aim to forgive, but not as a rule without exceptions. | (none) |
The judgement is decided first, each paragraph has one job, and linking sentences are planned so the answer reads as one argument. Evidences criteria 1 and 2.
Convincing argument: E. However, others would argue: C. On balance: J. Weakened by: E. Having considered both sides: J. In contrast, a humanist: C.
Introduction. Forgiveness means letting go of anger and the wish for revenge against someone who has wronged you, without saying that what they did was right. Almost all religious believers agree that forgiveness is important. The real question is whether it is a duty in every single case. I will argue that believers should almost always try to forgive, but that “always” goes too far.
Against. However, not every tradition sees forgiveness as unconditional. In Judaism, teshuvah teaches that the wrongdoer must first make amends and ask for forgiveness, so forgiveness responds to repentance. Similarly, Surah 42:40 allows a victim to seek justice, although it praises those who pardon. In contrast, a humanist such as Owen would say that forgiveness should never be forced, because pressure can harm the victim further. This is a convincing argument because it puts the well-being of the person who was hurt first.
Conclusion. Having considered both sides, I conclude that the statement is largely true but too absolute. Christian teaching comes closest to “always”, yet even Christians separate forgiveness from justice. Therefore believers should aim to forgive, but not as a rule without exceptions.
About 190 words. The introduction defines the key term and signals the line of argument; the paragraph against uses three viewpoints, including a non-religious one, with a reference and evaluation phrases; the conclusion matches the plan and is precise. The tone stays mature and respectful. Evidences criteria 2, 3 and 4.