Worked example · Dance · Year 11

Planning an extended answer on an unseen dance: Rhwyd

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Planning and organising for different purposes, audiences and context

What this is

A secure Year 11 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key. The command word is evaluate: judge how effective, not just describe. The two focuses are choreographic devices and the physical setting. Paragraph A describes, B explains, C evaluates. The key things to look for in Step 5: an opening that states the implied meaning, one idea per paragraph, a time or detail from the pack as evidence, a judgement in every paragraph, linking words between paragraphs, and a conclusion that weighs a strength against a limit. Practises GCSE Dance Unit 3: Dance Appreciation, content 3.1.1 to 3.1.3, on an unseen work.

Step 1: unpick the question

(a) Evaluate. It asks me to judge how well the choices work and to reach a conclusion, weighing strengths against weaknesses. “Describe” only asks what happens.

(b) Choreographic devices: the hauling motif in unison and canon, retrograde, repetition, the lift. Physical setting: the net, the lighting (blue-green, strobe, amber), the costume (knitted jumpers, the yellow oilskin).

(c) Rhwyd suggests that a community is like a net: when one person is lost, the others take the strain and mend what is broken.

Every part of the question is accounted for before any writing starts, so nothing the examiner asks for is missed. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 2: compare three paragraphs

PupilDescribe, explain or evaluate?Well done, and missing
ADescribesFollows the order of the work, and uses unison correctly. It is a list joined by “then”, with no meaning, no judgement and only one dance term.
BExplainsNames a device, gives evidence and links it to a meaning. It is short, has no time, and never says how effective the choice is.
CEvaluatesOne clear idea, followed through the whole work, with a judgement and a reason. It could add times, such as 03:30, to make the evidence exact.
Point“The hauling motif is the most effective device in the work because it changes as the community changes.”
EvidenceUnison in two tight lines; breaks into canon in the storm; returns in unison with a gap in the line.
Explanation“look like one crew pulling together”; “shows the crew losing control”
Judgement“This is highly effective, as the audience recognises the movement … so the loss is shown without any words.”
Linking wordsbecause, so, When, which, but, as, so

Sees that the difference between the paragraphs is organisation and purpose, not length: C is built as point, evidence, explanation, judgement. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 3: plan

ParagraphPointEvidence and timeHow effective, and why
IntroductionCommunity as a net: loss, strain, mending. Effective overall, mainly through the motif and the net; storm less clear.
1. DeviceRetrograde shows recoverySection 3, 07:00 to 12:00: throw, turn, pull, pull, rising low to highHighly: audience recognises the motif, so recovery feels earned
2. DeviceThe lift shows the community carrying its lossSection 2: yellow oilskin lifted, carried off through the net; 15 s silenceStrong: the silence makes the loss final
3. SettingThe net is the communityBlue-green light; drops at 03:30; hung back with the oilskin tied inVery: makes the meaning visible
4. LimitThe strobe hides the canon20 s strobe in section 2Less successful: meaning only seen in flashes
ConclusionHighly effective; strobe is a weakness, but the gap in the final line shows the loss without words.

Order: I kept the limit until just before the conclusion, so the argument builds up the strengths first and the weakness is weighed against them at the end.

One idea per paragraph, each with evidence and a judgement already decided, so the writing time is spent on expression, not on thinking of points. The order is a deliberate choice. Evidences criteria 3 and 4.

Step 4: linking sentences

Paragraph 2This idea is reinforced by the lift in the storm.
Paragraph 3Similarly, the physical setting makes the implied meaning visible.
Paragraph 4However, the 20-second strobe is less successful.
ConclusionOverall, Rhwyd is highly effective.

Four different linking phrases from four different groups: adding, adding, contrasting and concluding. Each sentence tells the reader how the new paragraph relates to the last. Evidences criterion 4.

Step 5: the extended answer

Rhwyd suggests that a community is like a net: when one member is lost, the others take the strain and slowly mend what is broken. The choreographer communicates this effectively through the way she develops the hauling motif and uses the net itself, although the storm is less clear than the rest of the work.

The most effective device is the retrograde of the hauling motif in section 3. The dancers perform throw, turn, pull, pull while rising from low to high level, so the movement that was broken in the storm is rebuilt backwards, as if the community is recovering step by step. This is highly effective because the audience recognises the motif from the opening, so the recovery feels earned.

This idea is reinforced by the lift in the storm. The five dancers carry the dancer in the yellow oilskin high above them and offstage through the net, which suggests the community carrying its loss together. As a result, the collapse and the 15 seconds of silence that follow feel heavy and final.

Similarly, the physical setting makes the implied meaning visible. At the start the net hangs upstage in blue-green light, rippling like the sea, but when it drops at 03:30 the community is torn down. In section 3 the dancers mend it and hang it back with the oilskin tied in, so the lost fisherman becomes part of the net for ever.

However, the 20-second strobe is less successful. It makes the dancers hard to follow, so the canon that shows the crew losing control is only seen in flashes.

Overall, Rhwyd is highly effective. Although the strobe weakens the storm, the motif and the net carry the meaning so clearly that the gap in the final line shows the loss without a word.

298 words in six paragraphs that follow the plan. The introduction states the implied meaning and the overall view; each body paragraph has one idea, evidence from the pack, the meaning it suggests and a judgement; the conclusion weighs the strobe against the strengths. Dance terms: motif, retrograde, level, lift, canon, physical setting, implied meaning. Linking: although, so, as if, because, This idea is reinforced by, which suggests, As a result, Similarly, but, However, Overall. Evidences criteria 2, 3, 4 and 5.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure