Worked example · Science · Year 8
LNF: Numeracy → Learning that statistics represent data and that probability models chance helps us make informed inferences and decisions → Representing data
A secure Year 8 response, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key. Scales: 1 minute per big square across; 40 °C to 90 °C, 5 °C per big square up, so each small square is 1 °C. Sample A is flat at 69 °C for about 4 minutes and is pure. Sample B has no flat part and freezes slowly between about 65 °C and 61 °C, so it is a mixture.
| Data | Best graph | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Temperature of sample A every minute | Line graph | Time and temperature are both numbers that change smoothly, so the points can be joined. |
| Melting points of 4 fatty acids | Bar chart | The fatty acids are separate categories (names), not numbers, so there is nothing between them to join. |
| Mass and time to go solid | Line graph | Mass and time are both numbers that can take any value. |
Each choice is justified by the type of data, not by which graph looks nicer. Evidences criterion 1.
(a) 12 minutes across 12 big squares: 1 minute per big square.
(b) Ffion’s scale is better. First, the data only go from 47 °C to 85 °C, so Gethin’s scale would squash the line into the top half of the grid and waste the space from 0 to 40 °C. Second, Ffion’s scale makes each small square worth 1 °C, so every reading can be plotted exactly. On Ffion’s scale, each small square is 5 ÷ 5 = 1 °C.
The pupil checks that the scale fits all the data, goes up in equal steps and uses most of the grid. Evidences criterion 2.
Each point is plotted to the nearest small square and joined with a smooth line. The axes are numbered in equal steps, labelled with units, and the graph has a title and a key. The dashed line at 69 °C shows how the reading in Step 6 was taken. Evidences criteria 3 and 4.
(a) 69 °C.
(b) About 4 minutes, from about 3.5 minutes to about 7.5 minutes. (The readings at 4, 5, 6 and 7 minutes are all 69 °C. Answers from 3 to 4 minutes are fine.)
(c) 85 − 70 = 15 °C in 3 minutes. 15 ÷ 3 = 5 °C per minute.
(d) Sample B has no flat part. After 3 minutes it keeps falling, but slowly, from 65 °C at 4 minutes to 61 °C at 8 minutes, then falls faster again. Its line is below sample A’s from 1 minute onwards.
(e) Sample A was pure. Its graph is flat at one temperature, 69 °C, while it freezes, which matches the melting point of stearic acid in section 3. Sample B freezes over a range of temperatures that is lower, which is what happens with a mixture.
(f) The line is still falling but getting less steep (5, 4 and then 3 °C in the last 3 minutes), so about 48 °C. Any answer from 47 °C to 49 °C is sensible.
Every answer quotes values read from the graph, and the shape is described with numbers. Evidences criterion 5.