Worked example · Geography · Year 9

Posting volcano updates for an Icelandic town

DCF: Interacting and collaborating → Communication

What this is

A secure Year 9 response, annotated against the success criteria. It is also your answer key. Step 1: Mid-Atlantic; constructive (or divergent); North American and Eurasian (either order); apart; magma. Step 2: post claims 1, 4 and 7; do not post claims 2, 3, 5 and 6. Step 4: 1 so, 2 because, 3 Although, 4 until, 5 unless, 6 Therefore, 7 As a result (6 and 7 may be swapped). Character counts are for the model posts below; a pupil’s count may be 2 or 3 out, which is fine if the post is clearly within the limit.

Step 1: the science behind the warnings

Iceland lies on the Mid-Atlantic Ridge. This is a constructive plate boundary, where the North American plate and the Eurasian plate are moving apart. As they do, magma rises from the mantle to fill the gap.

Sign or hazardReportWhat it tells scientists, or why it is dangerous
Earthquake swarmAMagma is moving underground and cracking the rock as it forces its way through, so an eruption is possible.
Ground upliftBMagma is collecting below the surface (about 4 km down) and pushing the ground up by 5 cm.
Sulfur dioxide gasD and FIt is released from the magma and carried by the wind. It irritates eyes, throat and lungs, especially for people with asthma.

Every gap is correct, and each sign is linked to what is happening to the magma, not just named. The gas answer says who is most at risk. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 2: check before you post

Post or not?Report letter or reason
1PostF (08:00).
2Do not postOnly in the rumour. No official report mentions a second crack.
3Do not postNot in any official report. We are not the source for airport news, so we would point people to the airport’s own updates.
4PostE (03:30).
5Do not postWrong. Report F says 900 m.
6Do not postPersonal data: her address, age and health. Pass it privately to 112 or the emergency coordinator so someone can collect her.
7PostF (08:00).

(b) The 05:10 post was written from an old note instead of the latest official report. Report E at 03:30 had already closed the north road. Deleting it quietly would not reach the 300 people who shared it, and anyone who saw it could still drive north towards the lava. We should reply to it and post a correction saying clearly what was wrong, so people know, and so they keep trusting the account.

Every “Post” has a source and a time, and every “Do not post” has a reason. The pupil sees that a missing person still needs help, but through a private channel, not a public post. Evidences criteria 2 and 3.

Step 3: channel and audience

ChannelAudienceWording
aText alert, then website and social mediaEveryone in the area, including touristsShort commands in plain English. Name the road exactly as on the signs.
bWebsiteResidents, parents in Wales, the newsFull sentences that link cause and effect. Name the source and the time.
cSocial media reply to the 05:10 post, and a note on the websiteEveryone who saw or shared itSay “correction” and say sorry. Give the right information first, in capitals for the key word.
dSocial mediaPeople sharing the rumourCalm and factual. Say what the Met Office has reported; do not repeat the rumour in detail or blame the poster.
eNone of ours: the school tells parents directlyParents of the groupThe town has no official report about the group, and must not post about named children. The teachers use the school’s own messages to parents.

The urgent message goes where everyone will see it at once; the explanation goes where there is space. The pupil spots that message e is not ours to post, which protects children’s data and avoids sharing something unconfirmed. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 4: choose the connective

ConnectiveJob
1soEffect: magma rising is the result of the plates moving apart.
2becauseCause: magma collecting is the reason the ground rose.
3AlthoughContrast: slow sounds safe, but it still destroys buildings.
4untilTime: stay in up to the moment you can leave.
5unlessCondition: the lava reaches the houses if it does not slow down.
6ThereforeEffect: the advice follows from the fact about the lungs.
7As a resultEffect: the warning was the result of the earthquakes.

(b) “And” only adds one fact to another. It does not tell the reader that magma collecting is the reason the ground rose, so the cause is lost.

Every connective fits both the meaning and the grammar: “Therefore” and “As a result” start a new sentence and are followed by a comma. Each job is explained, not just labelled. Evidences criterion 4.

Step 5: the rewritten draft

A volcanic eruption has started 3 km north-east of Eldvík. Lava is flowing towards the town, and at 08:00 it was 900 m from the nearest houses. Everyone must leave now. The north road is closed because lava has crossed it, so leave by the coast road east. Sulfur dioxide levels in the town are high, so keep windows closed until you leave. Anyone who needs help to leave should call 112.

(b) I took out Mrs Jónsdóttir’s name, address, age, health and phone number, because that is personal data; it should go privately to 112. I changed 500 m to 900 m, because report F says 900 m. I took out the harbour crack, because it is only a rumour. I also cut “dont panic its fine probably”, because it contradicts the order to leave.

One run-on sentence becomes 6 clear sentences with capital letters and full stops. “And” is replaced by connectives that show cause and effect, and every fact now matches an official report. Evidences criteria 2, 3 and 5.

Step 6: the website update

Volcanic eruption near Eldvík: leave by the coast road east
Updated Wednesday 08:30. Sources: Icelandic Met Office and the Eldvík emergency coordinator.

A volcanic eruption began at 02:50, 3 km north-east of Eldvík. Iceland sits on the Mid-Atlantic Ridge, where the North American and Eurasian plates are moving apart. As they separate, magma rises to fill the gap. Magma has been forcing its way through the rock, so more than 600 earthquakes have been recorded since Monday. The ground rose by 5 cm because magma was collecting about 4 km below the surface. Then the magma reached the surface through a crack 2 km long. As a result, lava is flowing south-west towards the town.

At 08:00 the lava was 900 m from the nearest houses. Although it is moving slowly, at about 100 m per hour, it destroys everything in its path. Lava has crossed the north road; therefore, it is closed.

Leave now by the coast road east and go to Sandvellir sports hall. Unless you can leave straight away, stay indoors with the windows closed, because sulfur dioxide levels are high. Call 112 for help.

Correction: at 05:10 we posted that the north road was open. This was wrong.

Connectives used: 6 different (so, because, as a result, although, therefore, unless). 180 words.

The update follows the plan: headline, time and sources, then what and why, what it means, what to do and the correction. The explanation is a chain of cause and effect from the plates to the lava. Sentences vary: some open with a connective (“Although…”, “Unless…”), one uses a semicolon before “therefore”, and “This was wrong.” is short for emphasis. The correction is open, not hidden. Evidences criteria 1, 2 and 5.

Step 7: the emergency text alert

Volcano erupting near Eldvík. Leave now by the coast road east. Do not use the north road: it is closed. Go to Sandvellir sports hall. Call 112 for help.

Characters: 153 / 160. Command verbs: Leave, Do not use, Go, Call.

(b) The text alert must be understood in seconds on a small screen, by people who may not read Icelandic well, so short commands tell them exactly what to do. The website has room to explain why, and people trust advice more when they understand the reason, so it needs longer sentences linked with connectives.

Under the limit, with what, what to do, where to go and who to call. Every sentence after the first is a short command, and there are no web addresses, slang or abbreviations. Evidences criteria 3 and 6.

Step 8: the correction, the rumour and the alt text

(a) Correction: our 05:10 post was wrong. The north road is CLOSED because lava has crossed it. Leave Eldvík by the coast road east only. We are sorry for the mistake. Full update on the town website. (196 characters)

(b) You may have seen a post about a second crack under the harbour. The Icelandic Met Office has reported no second crack. Please share only official updates. Map of the eruption below. Full update on the town website. (215 characters)

(c) Alt text: Map of Eldvík from the Icelandic Met Office. Lava flows south-west from a fissure towards the town and covers the north road. The coast road east is clear.

The correction admits the mistake, gives the right information and says sorry, in public where the error was seen. The rumour reply states the official position without repeating the scary details or attacking the poster. The alt text gives a screen reader user the one thing the map is for: which road is safe. Evidences criteria 2 and 7.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure