Worked example · Design Technology · Year 9

Pricing a product for a school enterprise fair

LNF: Numeracy → Number system → Financial literacy

What this is

A secure Year 9 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key. Key answers: cost per keyring of acrylic A 26p, B 25p, C 22.5p; best buys B for acrylic (£15.00), 3 packs of 25 rings (£5.40), 3 packs of bags (£9.60); total cost £48.00; cost per keyring £0.80; lowest price for the target £1.80; profit at 60, 35 and 20 sold £72.00, £22.00, a loss of £8.00; break-even 24; percentage profit 150%; discount price £1.80; profit per keyring falls 16.7%; forecasts £42.00 and £64.40; money left £2.00. Give credit for correct working even if an earlier slip is carried forward.

Step 1: VAT and unit prices

SupplierPer sheet ex VATPer sheet inc VATPer keyring inc VATWorking
A£2.60£3.12£0.262.60 × 1.2 = 3.12; 3.12 ÷ 12 = 0.26
B£2.50£3.00£0.2515.00 ÷ 5 = 3.00; 3.00 ÷ 1.2 = 2.50; 3.00 ÷ 12 = 0.25
C£2.25£2.70£0.225 (22.5p)22.50 ÷ 10 = 2.25; 2.25 × 1.2 = 2.70; 2.70 ÷ 12 = 0.225

(a) Supplier C, at 22.5p per keyring.

(b) 15.00 ÷ 1.2 = 12.50 ex VAT, so the VAT is 15.00 − 12.50 = £2.50.

VAT is added with × 1.2 and removed with ÷ 1.2, not by taking 20% off the inc VAT price (which would wrongly give £3.00 of VAT). All three prices are compared on the same basis, inc VAT per keyring. Evidences criteria 1 and 2.

Step 2: the best buy for this batch

OptionWorkingCost inc VAT
5 sheets from A5 × 3.12£15.60
5 sheets from B1 pack£15.00
5 sheets from Cmust buy 1 pack of 10: 22.50 × 1.2£27.00
60 rings in packs of 25need 3 packs (75 rings): 3 × 1.80£5.40
60 rings in a pack of 1001 pack£6.00
60 gift bags in packs of 203 packs: 3 × 3.20£9.60

(a) One ring costs 1.80 ÷ 25 = 7.2p in a pack of 25, and 6.00 ÷ 100 = 6p in a pack of 100. For exactly 60 rings, 3 packs of 25 are cheaper (£5.40, not £6.00), even though the price per ring is higher. The pack of 100 leaves 40 rings unused.

(b) No. C has the cheapest sheet (£2.70), but you must buy 10 sheets for £27.00 when only 5 are needed. B costs £15.00 for exactly 5 sheets, so B saves £12.00 on this batch.

The pupil sees that best value depends on how much you need: the best unit price is only the best buy if you will use the whole pack. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 3: the total cost of the batch

Cost£
Acrylic, 1 pack from B15.00
Split rings, 3 packs of 255.40
Gift bags, 3 packs of 209.60
Stall fee15.00
Price sign and display card3.00
Total cost of the batch of 6048.00
Cost per keyring48.00 ÷ 60 = 0.80

The fixed costs are shared across all 60 keyrings, not forgotten. Materials alone come to £30.00, or 50p a keyring; the fixed costs add another 30p each. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 4: set the selling price

(a) Money needed = total cost + target profit = 48.00 + 60.00 = £108.00. Lowest price = 108.00 ÷ 60 = £1.80.

(b) £2.00 is one coin, so giving change at a busy stall is quick and mistakes are less likely. It also gives some room: if a few keyrings do not sell, the team can still get close to the £60 target.

The price is built from the costs and the target, then rounded up for a practical reason. Evidences criterion 4.

Step 5: profit, loss and break-even

SoldMoney takenTotal costProfit or loss
6060 × 2.00 = £120.00£48.00profit £72.00
3535 × 2.00 = £70.00£48.00profit £22.00
2020 × 2.00 = £40.00£48.00loss £8.00

(a) 48.00 ÷ 2.00 = 24 keyrings. Check: 24 × 2.00 = 48.00.

(b) 72.00 ÷ 48.00 × 100 = 150%.

The total cost stays at £48.00 in every row, because the keyrings are made before the fair; this is why selling only 20 makes a loss. The break-even answer is checked with an inverse. Evidences criteria 4 and 5.

Step 6: test the 10% discount

(a) 2.00 × 0.9 = £1.80. Profit per keyring: full price 2.00 − 0.80 = £1.20; discount price 1.80 − 0.80 = £1.00.

(b) Profit falls by 1.20 − 1.00 = 20p. 0.20 ÷ 1.20 × 100 = 16.7% (1 decimal place). Ifan is wrong: the 20p comes off a smaller amount, the profit, so the percentage fall in profit is bigger than 10%.

(c) Forecast 1: 45 × 2.00 = 90.00; 90.00 − 48.00 = £42.00. Forecast 2: 40 × 2.00 = 80.00 and 18 × 1.80 = 32.40, so 80.00 + 32.40 = 112.40; 112.40 − 48.00 = £64.40. Forecast 2 is better by £22.40, because the 18 discounted sales bring in £32.40, far more than the £10.00 from the 5 full-price sales they replace.

A multiplier of 0.9 is used for the discount, and the pupil explains why a percentage cut in price is not the same percentage cut in profit. Evidences criterion 5.

Step 7: budget plan and recommendation

ItemWhat we will buyCost
Acrylic1 pack of 5 sheets from B, Laser Llŷn£15.00
Split rings3 packs of 25£5.40
Gift bags3 packs of 20£9.60
Fixed costsstall fee, price sign and display card£18.00
Total spend£48.00
Money left from the £50 loan£2.00

(a) No. 48.00 − 15.00 + 27.00 = £60.00, which is £10.00 over the £50 budget.

(b) We recommend buying the acrylic from Laser Llŷn and the split rings in packs of 25, so the batch costs £48.00 and stays £2.00 inside the loan. Selling at £2.00 gives £1.20 profit on each keyring. We must sell 24 keyrings to break even and repay the loan; after that every sale helps the food bank. Use Seren’s discount in the last hour, because our forecast shows £22.40 more profit. (70 words)

The plan is within budget, and the recommendation uses 5 numbers from the working to justify each choice. It links break-even to the real question: how many sales before the charity gets anything. Evidences criterion 6.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure