Worked example · Science · Year 7

Punctuating a chromatography write-up

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Punctuation

What this is

A secure Year 7 response, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key. Quick answers: Step 2 (b) 12 sentences, (c) 6 times, and 14 letters should be circled (the first letter of all 12 sentences, plus the “i” in “first i drew” and in “then i put”). Step 3 (c) C. Step 4 reasons, top to bottom: O, O, O, M, P, L. The key idea: punctuation shows the reader where each idea starts and stops, so a scientist can follow the method and trust the results.

Gwen’s write-up, fully punctuated

Title: Separating the dyes in felt-tip pens

Aim: To find out which pen’s ink is a mixture of dyes and which is a single pure dye.

Equipment: I used this equipment: chromatography paper, a pencil, a ruler, 4 felt-tip pens, a beaker, water, a glass rod and a paper clip.

Method: First, I drew a line 2 cm from the bottom of the paper. This is called the base line. I drew it in pencil because pen ink would dissolve in the water. Then I put a small dot of each pen’s ink on the line. The dots were 2 cm apart. I poured water into the beaker until it was about 1 cm deep, so the water’s surface was below the base line. I hung the paper from the glass rod with a paper clip. I left it for 10 minutes. The water moved up the paper and carried the dyes with it.

Results: Pen 1 (Gwen’s black pen) made 3 spots: purple, blue and yellow. Pen 2 (green) made 2 spots: blue and yellow. Pen 3 (orange) made 2 spots: red and yellow. Pen 4 (yellow) made only 1 spot. The yellow spot travelled 6.1 cm from the base line in all 4 pens’ inks. The purple spot moved only 1.5 cm. The water (the solvent) travelled 8.0 cm.

Conclusion: My conclusion is that pen 4 is pure because it only made 1 spot. The other pens are not pure. They are mixtures. I wonder if the yellow dye is the same in every pen. Would I get the same results with a different solvent?

Step 2: sentences and comma splices

(a) With a full stop at every sentence ending, the method has these sentences:

  1. First, I drew a line 2 cm from the bottom of the paper.
  2. This is called the base line.
  3. I drew it in pencil.
  4. Pen ink would dissolve in the water.
  5. Then I put a small dot of each pen’s ink on the line.
  6. The dots were 2 cm apart.
  7. I poured water into the beaker until it was about 1 cm deep.
  8. The water’s surface was below the base line.
  9. I hung the paper from the glass rod with a paper clip.
  10. I left it for 10 minutes.
  11. The water moved up the paper.
  12. It carried the dyes with it.

(b) 12 sentences. (c) 6 times.

Gwen wroteFixed with a full stopFixed with a joining word
i drew it in pencil, pen ink would dissolve in the waterI drew it in pencil. Pen ink would dissolve in the water.I drew it in pencil because pen ink would dissolve in the water.
i poured water into the beaker until it was about 1 cm deep, the waters surface was below the base lineI poured water into the beaker until it was about 1 cm deep. The water’s surface was below the base line.I poured water into the beaker until it was about 1 cm deep, so the water’s surface was below the base line.
the water moved up the paper, it carried the dye’s with itThe water moved up the paper. It carried the dyes with it.The water moved up the paper and carried the dyes with it.

Every sentence has 1 main idea, a capital letter and a full stop, and “I” is always a capital. Each comma splice is fixed in 2 correct ways, and the joining word matches the meaning (because gives a reason, so gives a result, and adds an action). Evidences criteria 1 and 2.

Step 3: lists and colons

(a) I used this equipment: chromatography paper, a pencil, a ruler, 4 felt-tip pens, a beaker, water, a glass rod and a paper clip.

(b) The ink in pen 1 contained 3 dyes: purple, blue and yellow.

(c) C. The words before the colon, “You need 3 things”, make a complete sentence that introduces the list. In A, “You need” is not complete on its own. In B, the colon comes after the list instead of before it.

The colon comes after a complete sentence, commas separate the items, and “and” comes before the last item with no comma. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 4: apostrophes

Gwen wroteCorrect versionReason
gwens black penGwen’s black penO
each pens inkeach pen’s inkO
the waters surfacethe water’s surfaceO
in all 4 pens inksin all 4 pens’ inksM
it carried the dye’s with itit carried the dyes with itP
the other pens arent purethe other pens aren’t pureL

(b) The other pens are not pure.

The pupil decides how many owners there are before placing the apostrophe, removes the wrong apostrophe from the plural “dyes” and leaves “pens” alone when it is just a plural. The formal version uses the full words. Evidences criterion 4.

Step 5: brackets, units and question marks

Gwen wroteCorrected sentence
pen 2 green made 2 spots blue and yellowPen 2 (green) made 2 spots: blue and yellow.
the water solvent travelled 8.0 cmThe water (the solvent) travelled 8.0 cm. Also accept: The solvent (water) travelled 8.0 cm.
the yellow spot travelled 6.1 from the base lineThe yellow spot travelled 6.1 cm from the base line.
the purple spot moved only 1.5cmsThe purple spot moved only 1.5 cm.
i wonder if the yellow dye is the same in every pen?I wonder if the yellow dye is the same in every pen.
would i get the same results with a different solventWould I get the same results with a different solvent?

Each sentence still makes sense if the words in brackets are removed. Every number has its unit, with a space and no s. The pupil spots that “I wonder if” only reports a question, so it ends with a full stop, while the direct question gets a question mark. Evidences criterion 5.

Step 6: a model conclusion

My conclusion is that pen 4 (the yellow pen) is the only pen whose ink contains just 1 dye, because it made only 1 spot. The other 3 pens’ inks are mixtures of dyes: pen 1 (black), pen 2 (green) and pen 3 (orange). The yellow dye is the most soluble in water because it travelled the furthest, 6.1 cm from the base line. The purple dye in Gwen’s pen is the least soluble because it moved only 1.5 cm. All 4 pens probably share the yellow dye, because every yellow spot travelled 6.1 cm, and pens 1 and 2 probably share the blue dye, because both blue spots travelled 3.8 cm. Would the dyes separate in the same way if I used a different solvent, such as ethanol?

The conclusion answers every question with evidence from the results table, and every sentence is correctly punctuated. It uses a colon and commas for a list, brackets for extra information, apostrophes for one owner (Gwen’s) and more than one owner (pens’), a unit with every measurement and a question mark on a direct question. Evidences criteria 3, 4, 5 and 6.

Step 7: partner check and improvement

Sentence my partner flagged: “The purple dye in Gwens pen moved 1.5, it is the least soluble.”

Improved: “The purple dye in Gwen’s pen is the least soluble because it moved only 1.5 cm.”

The improved sentence adds the missing apostrophe and unit, and replaces the comma splice with “because”. Evidences criterion 6.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure