Worked example · Art · Year 8

Punctuating quotations in writing about art

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Punctuation

What this is

A secure Year 8 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key and a model answer. Pupils write by hand, so titles appear here in single quotation marks. Key answers: titles go in single quotation marks by hand and in italics when typed; a comma goes before the opening mark or inside the closing mark when there is a reporting clause; the full stop of an embedded quotation goes after the closing mark; the artist’s palette (one artist), the artists’ exhibition (2 artists), Kyffin Williams’s (accept Kyffin Williams’). Step 3 needs 19 marks. Accept other sensible wordings in Steps 4 to 6 if the punctuation is correct.

Step 2: correct 10 sentences

 CorrectedRule
1Eirlys Morgan said, “I have never painted a sunny day.”2
2“Clay remembers every touch,” said Huw Teifi Jones.2
3Eirlys Morgan loved storms, and the artist’s palette was full of greys and purples.5
4Huw and Nia shared a show; the artists’ exhibition at Oriel y Graig was called ‘Salt and Iron’.5, 1
5Huw Teifi Jones works in clay, slate, driftwood and copper wire.6
6Eirlys Morgan painted the weather; the hills were less important to her.7
7Huw Teifi Jones (born 1968) made ‘The Salmon Gate’ in 1999.8, 1
8We compared Kyffin Williams’s landscapes with Eirlys Morgan’s storms.5
9Huw Teifi Jones explains how he works: “Every piece of driftwood has already had a life before it reaches me.”3
10Nia Bevan-Lloyd wants people to “feel the weight of the iron”.4

(b) In italics, with no quotation marks: The Salmon Gate.

Sentence 3 has one artist, so ’s; sentence 4 has 2 artists, so s’. In sentence 10 the comma and capital letter go, because the quotation is now part of the pupil’s own sentence, and the full stop moves outside. Evidences criteria 1 to 5.

Step 3: punctuate a paragraph

Nia Bevan-Lloyd (born 1985) is a printmaker who works in Merthyr Tydfil; her studio is in an old chapel. She uses ink, paper, thread and rusted iron. In ‘Iron Daughters’ (2016) the rust makes orange-brown marks across the paper. The artist’s great-grandmother carried coal and water up the hill every morning. Nia Bevan-Lloyd says, “When I print with rusted iron, I am printing her story as much as my own.”

The 19 marks: 2 pairs of brackets (4) · 1 semicolon · 5 full stops · 4 commas (2 in the list, 1 after says, 1 after iron inside the quotation) · 2 title marks · 1 apostrophe · 2 quotation marks. Also accept a comma after (2016), or a full stop instead of the semicolon only if the pupil changes her to Her.

Every rule from the box appears once in a real paragraph, and the comma inside the quotation is copied from the fact card. Evidences criteria 1 to 5.

Step 4: reported speech and quotation

1. Eirlys Morgan said, “My studio is a shed full of weather.”

2. Eirlys Morgan admitted, “My students taught me more than I taught them.”

3. Nia Bevan-Lloyd said, “I want people to feel the weight of the iron.”

4. Nia Bevan-Lloyd said that rust was just iron telling its story.

5. Huw Teifi Jones said that clay remembered every touch.

6. Eirlys Morgan said that she had never painted a sunny day.

Quotations use the exact words from the cards, with I and my restored. Reported speech drops the marks, adds that, changes the pronouns and moves the verb back a step. In 4 and 5, also accept the present tense (is, remembers), because the statements are still true. Evidences criteria 2 and 6.

Step 5: model paragraph (126 words)

Eirlys Morgan (1931 to 2004) was a painter who lived on a farm near Tregaron, and the Welsh weather is the real subject of her work. She used oil paint, charcoal, graphite and gouache. In paintings such as ‘Rain over Pumlumon’ (1962), rain is shown as long dragged brushstrokes, and tiny figures are dwarfed by the hills. Morgan said that she painted “the weather, not the hills”; for her, the sky mattered more than the land. The artist’s palette is full of stormy greys and purples, so her paintings feel cold and wet. She even admitted that she had “never painted a sunny day”. In my view, her work is powerful because it makes the viewer feel the weather instead of just looking at a view.

2 embedded quotations, each copied exactly and closed before the semicolon or full stop; a title in single quotation marks; a possessive apostrophe (artist’s); a semicolon joining 2 related sentences; brackets for dates and commas in a list of media. It ends with a personal view. Evidences criteria 1, 3, 4, 5 and 7.

Step 6: self-check

All 6 boxes ticked. Colour 1: the weather, not the hills and never painted a sunny day. Colour 2: ‘Rain over Pumlumon’, artist’s and the semicolon after hills. My word count: 126.

Sentence I was least sure of: I first wrote Morgan said that she painted, “The weather, not the hills.” Corrected: Morgan said that she painted “the weather, not the hills”.

The pupil proves each feature with a highlight instead of just ticking, and fixes a real mistake using rule 4. Evidences criterion 7.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure