Worked example · English · Year 9

Questioning the narrator of a short story

LNF: Literacy → Speaking → Questioning

What this is

A secure Year 9 response from a pupil who was Pupil 2 (questioner in round 1, narrator in round 2, observer in round 3), annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key. Step 2: closed B, E, I; open D, G, K; probing A, F, J; follow-up C, H, L. Everything the narrator says in role in Steps 3 to 5 is invented by pupils, so their answers will differ from these: accept any answer that fits the hints in the story and stays consistent. Show this after pupils have tried the steps themselves.

Step 1: the gaps

1. Why the narrator bought a single ticket on the last ferry of the season, and lied to Mam about Bangor. 2. What happened at Tad-cu’s house when the narrator was 11: the black marks and the burnt smell suggest a fire. 3. Who lit the lamp in a house where nobody has lived since June.

The pupil spots the three biggest gaps and backs each one with a detail from the story. These gaps become the targets for the questions. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 2: sorting the questions

TypeQuestionsHow I knew
ClosedB, E, IEach one can be answered with yes, no or one fact (16:00).
OpenD, G, KThey ask the narrator to describe or tell, so the answer has to be longer, but they stay on the surface of the story.
ProbingA, F, JEach digs into a gap: the single ticket, “After everything”, and what happened when the narrator was 11.
Follow-upC, H, LEach starts from an answer already given (“You said...”, “You say...”, “You told us...”) and pushes it further.

(b) Question E rewritten: “Why have you carried the envelope all this way without opening it?” (probing)

All 12 types are right, and the pupil explains the difference between an open question (longer answer) and a probing one (aimed at a gap or a hidden feeling). The rewrite turns a yes or no question into one that needs a reason. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 3 and Step 4: my question log (round 1, I was the questioner)

#My questionTypeKey words from the answerFollow-up I asked
1Tell us about your Tad-cu.Openfunny, told stories, lived alone, “only one who listened”You said he lived alone. Why did nobody else visit?
2Why did you tell Mam you were in Bangor?Probing“she’d stop me”, hasn’t been back since the fireWhat would she have said if you told her the truth?
3What happened at the white house when you were 11?Probingparaffin lamp, knocked it over, Tad-cu said he did itWhy did he take the blame for you?
4What did you pack in your bag, and why?Openjumper, Mam’s torch, envelope, tin box: “I’d rather not say”Why don’t you want to talk about the tin box? (answer: “It’s him. I’m bringing him home.”)
5How did you feel when Idris said “Ask him yourself”?Probingangry, then scared, “not a joke to me”(ran out of time)
6Are you going to stay on the island?Closed“yes, until April at least”(not asked)

My narrator notes (round 2): tin box: Tad-cu’s ashes. Age 11: I knocked a paraffin lamp over in the back room; Tad-cu put the fire out and told everyone it was his fault. Single ticket: the house is mine now, and I want to live in it. The lamp: I think Idris lit it, but part of me hopes it was Tad-cu.

The 6 planned questions keep to the rule: 2 open, 3 probing, 1 closed. Every follow-up picks up the exact words of the answer (“You said he lived alone”), and the pupil uses the one extra question allowed after “I’d rather not say” to unlock the biggest secret. The narrator notes answer every gap and fit the hints (the burnt smell, “After everything”, the heavy bag). Evidences criteria 2, 3 and 4.

Step 4: observer tally (round 3)

Question typeTallyTotal
Closed|1
Open|||3
Probing|||3
Follow-up||||4

The narrator said: “Mam never forgave him for the fire, even though it wasn’t really his fault.”

So the questioner asked: “If it wasn’t his fault, whose fault was it?”

Yes, mostly. Pupil 3 stayed in role and used “I” all the way through, but said the tin box held photos, which did not quite fit “Most of the weight was the tin box”, because photos are light.

My feedback: your follow-up about whose fault it was really worked. Use fewer open questions and more probing ones on the lamp.

The tally is complete and adds up to 11 questions in 4 minutes. The follow-up recorded is a good one, because it turns the narrator’s own words back into a question. The consistency comment is precise and checks the answer against a detail in the text. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 5: summary and evaluation

(a) The narrator is 17 and has come to Ynys Brith to live in the house Tad-cu left them in his will. They told Mam a lie because she has not forgiven Tad-cu since the fire six years ago. In two rounds the narrator started the fire by knocking over a lamp, and Tad-cu took the blame to protect them. The rounds did not agree about the tin box: ashes in rounds 1 and 2, photos in round 3. Nobody was sure who lit the lamp.

(b) The most convincing answer was in round 1, when the narrator said the tin box held Tad-cu’s ashes. It fitted the hint that the box made the bag heavy, and it explained why the narrator bought a single ticket: they are bringing him home for good. It also changed how I read Idris’s joke, “Ask him yourself”, which now sounds cruel. It could have been stronger if the narrator had said how they got the ashes without Mam knowing.

The summary is about 80 words and uses both the story and the answers from all 3 rounds, and it says where the rounds disagreed instead of hiding it. The evaluation judges one answer against the hints in the text, explains what it revealed, and suggests an improvement. Evidences criterion 5.

Why this response is secure