Worked example · Design Technology · Year 8

Reading a case study on iterative design

LNF: Literacy → Reading → Understanding, response and analysis

What this is

A secure Year 8 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key and a model answer. Key answers: the cyclone was at a sawmill and cleaned out sawdust; 5,127 prototypes over about 5 years; first sold in Japan as the G-Force; the DC01 was launched in the UK in 1993. The sum in Step 4: 5 × 52 = 260 weeks, and 5,127 ÷ 260 is about 19.7, so roughly 20 a week. Steps 3 to 8 accept other sensible wordings if they match the texts.

Step 1: skim for the main idea

(a) James Dyson made 5,127 prototypes to solve a vacuum cleaner problem, which shows how iterative design works.

(b) Cyclone idea: An idea from a sawmill. UK sale: From Japan to the UK. Lost suction: The problem.

The main idea links the example (the vacuum cleaner) to the topic (iterative design) in under 20 words, and the headings are used to go straight to the right section. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 2: find the facts

QuestionAnswerHeading
2. Where he saw a cycloneat a sawmillAn idea from a sawmill
3. What it cleaned outsawdustAn idea from a sawmill
4. What happens to the dustthe air spins, the dust is flung outwards against the walls and drops downAn idea from a sawmill
5. Number of prototypes5,1275,127 prototypes
6. How longabout 5 years5,127 prototypes
7. First soldJapan, as the G-Force (in the 1980s)From Japan to the UK
8. UK launch in 1993the DC01From Japan to the UK
9. 2 featurescyclones instead of a bag; a see-through binFrom Japan to the UK

Short, exact answers with the heading named show the facts were found, not guessed. Evidences criteria 1 and 2.

Step 3: read between the lines

QuestionWhat I inferQuotation as evidence
(a) Why keep going?He was determined to fix a fault that annoyed him, and every failure showed him how to make the next one better, so he could see he was getting closer.“He wanted a vacuum cleaner that kept its suction all the time.” “each failure taught him something”
(b) Companies not interestedThey made money from selling bags, so a cleaner with no bag could lose them money.“those companies also sold the replacement bags”
(c) See-through binTo prove to buyers that there was no bag and that the cyclones really worked.“so people could watch the dust it collected”

Each answer goes beyond what the text says directly, and a short, exact quotation proves it. Answer (a) gives 2 separate reasons. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 4: how the writer uses numbers

(a) The exact number sounds precise and true, as if every single prototype was counted. It makes the effort feel real instead of just “lots”.

(b) 5 × 52 = 260 weeks; 5,127 ÷ 260 ≈ 20 a week. A huge number like 5,127 is hard to picture, but 20 a week, every week, is easy to imagine and shows how hard he worked.

(c) It turns a success into a list of failures, so the reader is surprised at how often he was wrong, and admires him for not giving up.

(d) It grabs attention straight away and tells the reader what the case study is really about: trying again and again.

Each answer explains the effect on the reader, not just what the number is, and the sum is checked. Evidences criterion 4.

Step 5: structure

(a) “In the late 1970s”, “Over about 5 years”, “In 1993”. (Also accept “Then the real work began”, “in the 1980s”, “Later models”.)

 What it isHeading
The problemthe bag clogged and the cleaner lost suctionThe problem
The ideause a cyclone like the one at the sawmillAn idea from a sawmill
Making it work5,127 prototypes, testing and improving5,127 prototypes
The resultsold as the G-Force in Japan, then the DC01 in the UKFrom Japan to the UK

(c) To turn the story into a lesson for the reader. It links Dyson’s work to designers today and to the pupil’s own Design Technology lessons, so the reader knows why the story matters.

Both structures are identified with evidence, and the final section is explained by its purpose. Evidences criterion 5.

Step 6: language

(a) The short sentences sound like a steady rhythm, so they show the same steps being repeated over and over, just like the prototypes.

(b) Flung makes me picture the dust being thrown hard and fast against the walls. Moved is vague and does not show the speed or force of the spinning air.

(c) A failed prototype is useful because it tells the designer what is wrong, so they know what to change next.

(d) Fact: “In 1993, the DC01 was launched in the UK.” Opinion: “It would have been easy to give up after prototype 50” (also accept “The only real failure is to stop learning.”).

Each language choice is quoted and its effect explained; the fact can be checked, and the opinion is the writer’s own view. Evidences criterion 5.

Step 7: compare the 2 texts

 Text A: case studyText B: Osian’s blog
Main purposeto inform and explain iterative design using a real exampleto share his own experience, entertain and give advice
Audiencepupils studying Design Technology: “including you in your Design Technology lessons”other pupils doing the same project: “Top tip if you’re doing this project”
Formal or informal?formal: full sentences and technical words such as “industrial cyclone”informal: contractions, jokes and exclamations, such as “Literally.” and “Progress!”
View of failureuseful: “A prototype that fails has still done its job if it teaches you something.”useful: “Every version that failed showed me exactly what to fix next.”

(e) Both are in chronological order, and both move from a problem to a solution, one version at a time.

Purpose, audience and tone are compared with an example from each text, and a similarity is found as well as differences. Evidences criterion 6.

Step 8: model response (145 words)

Failure is an important part of designing, because each failure shows a designer what to improve. In Text A, Dyson built “5,127 prototypes”, which means 5,126 were not quite right. This shows that even a famous product only succeeded after thousands of failures. The writer says “each failure taught him something that made the next prototype a little better”, which suggests that failing was how he made progress. Text B shows the same thing on a smaller scale. Osian’s first stand “fell flat on its face”, but this led him to make a wider base, and later a gap for the cable. He says “Every version that failed showed me exactly what to fix next.” However, failure only helps if you test carefully and learn from it. In my view, failure is essential, because without it designers would never find the faults in their ideas.

Evidence from both texts, each followed by an explanation (“This shows”, “which suggests”), a balancing point (“However”) and a clear personal view. Evidences criteria 3 and 7.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure