Worked example · Health and Well-being · Year 5

Reading a story about friendship worries

LNF: Literacy → Reading → Reading strategies

What this is

A secure Year 5 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key for Steps 2, 4 and 5. Inference answers in Step 3 can be worded differently: accept any feeling that is backed by evidence from the story.

Step 1: skim

Megan feels left out when her best friend Tia looks after a new girl, but she gets to know the new girl and the three of them become friends.

Gets the whole story in one sentence, beginning to end, without small details. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 2: scan for details

QuestionAnswerParagraph
(a) Where did Zara move from?Birmingham2
(b) Why did Zara’s family move?Her mum had a new job at the hospital in Bangor.2
(c) Who asked Tia to look after Zara?Mrs Rowlands2
(d) On which day was Tia off sick?Thursday6
(e) What were Megan and Zara drawing on Friday?a plan for a den big enough for three8

All details correct, with paragraph numbers showing the pupil scanned for key words. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 3: read between the lines

(a) Megan was upset and jealous, maybe worried. She was watching Tia laugh with Zara, and picking at her jumper shows she was fidgeting because she felt bad.

(b) No. The words “although she was holding nothing at all” show she was not doing anything. I think she said it because she was hurt and wanted Tia to know she was upset, or she felt too proud to join in.

(c) Tia felt disappointed and a bit hurt, because she had asked her best friend to play and Megan said no.

(d) She knew how lonely it felt to be on your own. “Then she remembered how it felt to wait on the bench by herself.”

(e) She was embarrassed, because she found out Tia had not forgotten her at all, and she had been unkind to Tia for nothing.

Every inference is backed by a quotation or clue, and the pupil explains how the clue shows the feeling. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 4: cause and effect

1Zara arrives in Class 5 and Mrs Rowlands asks Tia to look after her.
2Tia spends break with Zara, so Megan waits on the bench on her own and feels left out.
3Megan tells Tia she is busy, so Tia runs back to Zara.
4Tia is off sick, and Zara is alone at lunch, so Megan sits with her.
5Zara tells Megan that Tia talks about her all the time, so Megan realises Tia has not forgotten her.
6The three girls share the bench and plan a den for three.

Each box links to the next with “so”, showing how one event leads to another. Accept Dad’s advice in box 4 if the chain still makes sense. Evidences criterion 4.

Step 5: work out the words

WordParagraphMeaning
faded4slowly went away
shrugged4lifted her shoulders to show “I don’t know” or “never mind”
Shove up8move along to make room (an informal way of saying it)

Uses the situation around each word to find a meaning that fits. Evidences criterion 5.

Step 6: think about the story

(a) You can have more than one friend. Making a new friend does not mean you stop being friends with your old one.

(b) She could have joined in the game of tag, or told Tia, “I miss you at break. Can we all play together?”

(c) Tell your friend how you feel, kindly, or talk to an adult you trust. Try being friendly to the new person too.

Explains the message of the story and gives realistic, kind advice.

If you finish early: answers

The writer uses “on the first Monday”, “On Tuesday”, “On Wednesday”, “On Thursday” and “On Friday”. They help the reader follow the week in order and see how long Megan felt left out.

Why this response is secure