Worked example · PSE / Well-being · Year 8
LNF: Numeracy → Learning that statistics represent data and that probability models chance helps us make informed inferences and decisions → Interpreting data
A secure Year 8 response, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key. The key ideas: Year 7 and Year 9 are different sizes (160 and 125 diaries), so counts mislead and percentages must be used. 55% of Year 7 and 60% of Year 9 did not meet the 60-minute average: a difference of 5 percentage points, not “twice”. The newsletter chart looks twice as tall only because its axis starts at 50%. Accept percentages rounded sensibly (for example 42.8% or 43%).
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| a. Year 9 pupils who returned a diary | 125 pupils |
| b. Year 7 pupils who met the average | 72 pupils |
| c. Pupils altogether who did not meet it | 163 pupils (88 + 75) |
| d. Most common main way of being active | Walking or cycling to school, 80 pupils |
| e. How many more chose team sport than swimming | 65 − 25 = 40 pupils |
| f. Where the axis of Chart C starts | 50% |
Values are read from the right row and column, bar heights are read against the gridlines (Chart B goes up in 10s, so 65 and 25 sit halfway between lines), and every answer has a unit. Evidences criterion 1.
| Group | Met | Total | % who met it | % who did not meet it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year 7 | 72 | 160 | 45% | 55% |
| Year 9 | 50 | 125 | 40% | 60% |
| Both year groups | 122 | 285 | 42.8% | 57.2% |
(a) Year 9: 50 ÷ 125 × 100 = 40% met it. 75 ÷ 125 × 100 = 60% did not (or 100 − 40 = 60).
(b) Each row should add up to 100%, because every pupil either met the average or did not. 45 + 55 = 100; 40 + 60 = 100; 42.8 + 57.2 = 100. All correct.
(c) Walking or cycling: 80 ÷ 285 × 100 = 28.07... = 28.1%. Team sport: 65 ÷ 285 × 100 = 22.80... = 22.8%.
The pupil divides by the size of each group, not by a single total, rounds to 1 decimal place and checks that each pair of percentages makes 100%. Evidences criterion 2.
(a) Sam is unfair because more Year 7 pupils returned a diary (160) than Year 9 pupils (125). A bigger group will usually have bigger counts in every column, so 88 and 75 cannot be compared directly. Sam needs to compare the share of each group, as a percentage.
(b) Year 9 had the bigger share: 60% did not meet the average, compared with 55% of Year 7. That is 5 percentage points more.
(c) 55% of Year 7 pupils and 60% of Year 9 pupils who returned a diary did not reach the 60-minute average, so a slightly larger share of Year 9 fell short, by 5 percentage points.
The pupil explains why counts mislead when groups differ in size, then compares like with like using percentages and a difference in percentage points. The answer to Sam is the opposite of his claim. Evidences criteria 2 and 3.
(a) The axis starts at 50%, not 0. The bottom 50% of each bar has been cut off, so we only see the small part above 50, and the difference between the bars looks much bigger than it really is.
(b) Year 7 reaches 55%, which is 5 points above 50. Year 9 reaches 60%, which is 10 points above 50. 10 ÷ 5 = 2, so the Year 9 bar looks 2 times as tall.
(c) 60 ÷ 55 = 1.0909... = 1.09. The Year 9 figure is only about 1.1 times the Year 7 figure, so “twice” is false. The real gap is 5 percentage points.
(d) 1. The survey measured pupils’ own estimates of minutes, not effort or character, so it cannot show anyone is lazy. 2. It rained on 2 of the 5 school days and some PE lessons and clubs were cancelled, so pupils had fewer chances to be active that week. (Also acceptable: 40% of Year 9 did meet the guideline; there may be other reasons such as more homework, travel or caring at home; a 5-point gap is small; “lazy” is an insult, not a measurement.)
(e) Title: Percentage of pupils who did not meet the 60-minute average, Ysgol Bro Tawel (invented data)
(f) With the axis starting at 0, the two bars are almost the same height: 11 squares and 12 squares. My chart shows the difference is small, and it also shows something the newsletter hid: more than half of both year groups did not meet the average, so it is not just a Year 9 issue.
The pupil names the trick (a cut-off axis), measures how big it makes the gap look (2 times) against the real ratio (1.09), challenges the loaded word “lazy” with evidence, and redraws the chart from 0 with a steady scale, labelled axes, accurate bars (Year 7 at 11 squares, Year 9 at 12 squares) and a title. Evidences criterion 4.
| Reason | How it could make the results different from all pupils in Wales |
|---|---|
| The minutes are self-reported estimates. | Nobody measured them. Some pupils may guess too high or too low, or forget a day, so the numbers may not be accurate. |
| It is one school. | Pupils in other parts of Wales may have different sports facilities, journeys to school or clubs, so one school may not be typical. |
| It is one week, in February, with 2 very wet days. | Clubs and outdoor PE were cancelled, so pupils were probably less active than in a normal week or in summer. |
Also acceptable: not every pupil returned a diary (50 of 175 in Year 9 did not), and the pupils who did not return one might be more or less active than those who did; only Years 7 and 9 were asked, not Years 8, 10 and 11.
Each reason comes from the survey details and is linked to how it could change the results, not just listed. A national survey such as SHRN’s, with many schools, would be more representative. Evidences criterion 5.
Headline: Most Year 7 and Year 9 pupils fell short of 60 active minutes a day in a wet February week
In our invented school survey, 55% of Year 7 pupils and 60% of Year 9 pupils who returned a diary did not reach an average of 60 minutes a day, a difference of only 5 percentage points. Altogether, 42.8% of the 285 pupils met the guideline, and the most common way of being active was walking or cycling to school, chosen by 28.1% of pupils. However, the minutes were pupils’ own estimates from one school in one rainy week, and 28.6% of Year 9 pupils (50 out of 175) did not return a diary, so the survey cannot tell us how active all pupils in Wales are.
The headline is accurate and does not blame one year group. Each of the 3 sentences uses at least one correct percentage, the comparison uses percentage points, and the last sentence states the limits of the survey. 50 ÷ 175 × 100 = 28.57... = 28.6%. Evidences criteria 3, 5 and 6.