Worked example · PSE / Well-being · Year 8

Reading a survey on physical activity

LNF: Numeracy → Learning that statistics represent data and that probability models chance helps us make informed inferences and decisions → Interpreting data

What this is

A secure Year 8 response, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key. The key ideas: Year 7 and Year 9 are different sizes (160 and 125 diaries), so counts mislead and percentages must be used. 55% of Year 7 and 60% of Year 9 did not meet the 60-minute average: a difference of 5 percentage points, not “twice”. The newsletter chart looks twice as tall only because its axis starts at 50%. Accept percentages rounded sensibly (for example 42.8% or 43%).

Step 2: read the values

QuestionAnswer
a. Year 9 pupils who returned a diary125 pupils
b. Year 7 pupils who met the average72 pupils
c. Pupils altogether who did not meet it163 pupils (88 + 75)
d. Most common main way of being activeWalking or cycling to school, 80 pupils
e. How many more chose team sport than swimming65 − 25 = 40 pupils
f. Where the axis of Chart C starts50%

Values are read from the right row and column, bar heights are read against the gridlines (Chart B goes up in 10s, so 65 and 25 sit halfway between lines), and every answer has a unit. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 3: percentages

GroupMetTotal% who met it% who did not meet it
Year 77216045%55%
Year 95012540%60%
Both year groups12228542.8%57.2%

(a) Year 9: 50 ÷ 125 × 100 = 40% met it. 75 ÷ 125 × 100 = 60% did not (or 100 − 40 = 60).

(b) Each row should add up to 100%, because every pupil either met the average or did not. 45 + 55 = 100; 40 + 60 = 100; 42.8 + 57.2 = 100. All correct.

(c) Walking or cycling: 80 ÷ 285 × 100 = 28.07... = 28.1%. Team sport: 65 ÷ 285 × 100 = 22.80... = 22.8%.

The pupil divides by the size of each group, not by a single total, rounds to 1 decimal place and checks that each pair of percentages makes 100%. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 4: comparing fairly

(a) Sam is unfair because more Year 7 pupils returned a diary (160) than Year 9 pupils (125). A bigger group will usually have bigger counts in every column, so 88 and 75 cannot be compared directly. Sam needs to compare the share of each group, as a percentage.

(b) Year 9 had the bigger share: 60% did not meet the average, compared with 55% of Year 7. That is 5 percentage points more.

(c) 55% of Year 7 pupils and 60% of Year 9 pupils who returned a diary did not reach the 60-minute average, so a slightly larger share of Year 9 fell short, by 5 percentage points.

The pupil explains why counts mislead when groups differ in size, then compares like with like using percentages and a difference in percentage points. The answer to Sam is the opposite of his claim. Evidences criteria 2 and 3.

Step 5: the newsletter

(a) The axis starts at 50%, not 0. The bottom 50% of each bar has been cut off, so we only see the small part above 50, and the difference between the bars looks much bigger than it really is.

(b) Year 7 reaches 55%, which is 5 points above 50. Year 9 reaches 60%, which is 10 points above 50. 10 ÷ 5 = 2, so the Year 9 bar looks 2 times as tall.

(c) 60 ÷ 55 = 1.0909... = 1.09. The Year 9 figure is only about 1.1 times the Year 7 figure, so “twice” is false. The real gap is 5 percentage points.

(d) 1. The survey measured pupils’ own estimates of minutes, not effort or character, so it cannot show anyone is lazy. 2. It rained on 2 of the 5 school days and some PE lessons and clubs were cancelled, so pupils had fewer chances to be active that week. (Also acceptable: 40% of Year 9 did meet the guideline; there may be other reasons such as more homework, travel or caring at home; a 5-point gap is small; “lazy” is an insult, not a measurement.)

(e) Title: Percentage of pupils who did not meet the 60-minute average, Ysgol Bro Tawel (invented data)

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% 55% Year 7 60% Year 9 Year group Percentage who did not meet the average Scale: 1 square = 5%

(f) With the axis starting at 0, the two bars are almost the same height: 11 squares and 12 squares. My chart shows the difference is small, and it also shows something the newsletter hid: more than half of both year groups did not meet the average, so it is not just a Year 9 issue.

The pupil names the trick (a cut-off axis), measures how big it makes the gap look (2 times) against the real ratio (1.09), challenges the loaded word “lazy” with evidence, and redraws the chart from 0 with a steady scale, labelled axes, accurate bars (Year 7 at 11 squares, Year 9 at 12 squares) and a title. Evidences criterion 4.

Step 6: can we trust this survey?

ReasonHow it could make the results different from all pupils in Wales
The minutes are self-reported estimates.Nobody measured them. Some pupils may guess too high or too low, or forget a day, so the numbers may not be accurate.
It is one school.Pupils in other parts of Wales may have different sports facilities, journeys to school or clubs, so one school may not be typical.
It is one week, in February, with 2 very wet days.Clubs and outdoor PE were cancelled, so pupils were probably less active than in a normal week or in summer.

Also acceptable: not every pupil returned a diary (50 of 175 in Year 9 did not), and the pupils who did not return one might be more or less active than those who did; only Years 7 and 9 were asked, not Years 8, 10 and 11.

Each reason comes from the survey details and is linked to how it could change the results, not just listed. A national survey such as SHRN’s, with many schools, would be more representative. Evidences criterion 5.

Step 7: a fair headline

Headline: Most Year 7 and Year 9 pupils fell short of 60 active minutes a day in a wet February week

In our invented school survey, 55% of Year 7 pupils and 60% of Year 9 pupils who returned a diary did not reach an average of 60 minutes a day, a difference of only 5 percentage points. Altogether, 42.8% of the 285 pupils met the guideline, and the most common way of being active was walking or cycling to school, chosen by 28.1% of pupils. However, the minutes were pupils’ own estimates from one school in one rainy week, and 28.6% of Year 9 pupils (50 out of 175) did not return a diary, so the survey cannot tell us how active all pupils in Wales are.

The headline is accurate and does not blame one year group. Each of the 3 sentences uses at least one correct percentage, the comparison uses percentage points, and the last sentence states the limits of the survey. 50 ÷ 175 × 100 = 28.57... = 28.6%. Evidences criteria 3, 5 and 6.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure