Worked example · Design Technology · Year 11

Reading a technical data sheet to choose a material

LNF: Literacy → Reading → Reading strategies

What this is

A secure Year 11 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key. Only sheet B, Cragen HD-5, black grade HD-5B, bought through a distributor meets all 8 points of the specification. Sheet A fails S2 (8 kJ/m² at −20 °C) and needs the dearer UV grade (£2.69 per kg). Sheet C fails S3, S5 and S7, gives no data at −20 °C, and its UV coating is only guaranteed for 12 months. Unsupported claims: A’s “tough in every weather” and C’s “stays tough through the hardest Welsh winter”.

Step 1: skim for gist

SheetMaterialMain selling pointSelling or technical?
APolypropyleneTough in all weathers, lightSelling first, then a table
BHDPENone: just dataTechnical
CABSPremium, glossy, tough in winterMostly selling

Predict: A or C looked best at first because of their bold claims, but B may be more useful because it gives the most data.

The skim picks up purpose and layout, not detail, and the prediction is open to change. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 2: text features

(a) A: a row in the “Typical properties” table. B: section 4.1 of the table. C: only in the small print at the bottom.

(b) They tell the reader to look for a note lower down that adds a condition or limit to the value.

(c) Numbered sections let an engineer find a value fast and quote it exactly (“see 3.2”). Sheet C is written like an advert, in questions and answers, so it reads smoothly but hides its limits in small print.

Explains what each feature does for the reader and notices that layout matches purpose. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 3: scan against the specification

SpecABC
S1code 5 ✓code 2 ✓>ABS< ✓
S28 kJ/m² ✗18 kJ/m² ✓no data ? (11 at 0 °C)
S3−20 to +100 ✓−40 to +80 ✓−10 to +80 ✗
S4UV grade only ?HD-5B only ✓coating, 12 months ✗
S50.90 ✓0.95 ✓1.05 ✗
S6✓HD-5B ✓✓
S7£2.69 (UV) ✓about £2.52 ✓£3.40 ✗
S8250 kg ✓100 kg via distributor ✓25 kg ✓

Values are copied exactly with units, and “?” is used honestly where the sheet gives no data or a condition applies. Evidences criteria 1 and 3.

Step 4: the small print

(a) A mudguard is used outdoors, so they must order Tarian PP-18 UV. 12% of £2.40 is about 29p, so the price is about £2.69 per kg (2.40 × 1.12 = 2.688), still under £3.00.

(b) Only the black grade is UV-stabilised. A red mudguard would be an HD-5C grade, which is for indoor use, so it would not last outdoors.

(c) Yes, through a distributor (from 100 kg), at about 2.10 × 1.2 = £2.52 per kg. “Typically” means the price is not guaranteed, so the company must get a written quote.

(d) A mudguard is hit by stones and grit, so its coating will be scratched, and it sits in sunlight. The exposed ABS could yellow and become brittle. A television case is indoors and rarely scratched.

Close reading turns each note into a consequence for the decision, using the context of how a mudguard is used. Evidences criteria 3 and 4.

Step 5: claims and reliability

(a) Sheet A says “tough in every weather”, but its own table gives only 8 kJ/m² at −20 °C, and footnote 2 says the standard grade is not recommended for long outdoor exposure. Sheet C says it “stays tough through the hardest Welsh winter”, but it gives no impact data below 0 °C and its own small print sets the lowest service temperature at −10 °C.

(b) The suppliers wrote them to sell their products, so they lead with strengths and put limits in small print. Question: “Can you send test data at −20 °C, and say how the samples were tested?”

Tests each claim against the sheet’s own data and infers the writer’s purpose. Evidences criterion 4.

Step 6: model recommendation (170 words)

I recommend Cragen HD-5 from Plastigau Hafod, in the black grade HD-5B. It is the only material that meets all 8 points of the specification. Its notched impact strength at −20 °C is 18 kJ/m² (section 3.2), well above our minimum of 10, and it works from −40 °C to +80 °C (4.1). The black grade is UV-stabilised with carbon black (4.2), and its density of 0.95 g/cm³ (2.1) keeps the mudguard light.

We cannot buy 1000 kg direct (5.3), but note † lets us order from 100 kg through a distributor at about £2.52 per kg, within our £3.00 limit.

I rejected Tarian PP-18 because it gives only 8 kJ/m² at −20 °C, despite claiming to be “tough in every weather”. I rejected Ffenics ABS-UV because it is too dense (1.05 g/cm³), costs £3.40 per kg and is only recommended down to −10 °C.

Before ordering, we should get a written price from a distributor, because “typically” is not a promise, and we must not use coloured grades outdoors.

Clear recommendation first, well over 4 values quoted, with sections for the chosen material, rejections justified with data, and a mature point about reliability. Evidences criteria 3, 4 and 5.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure