Worked example · Music · Year 7
LNF: Literacy → Reading → Understanding, response and analysis
A secure Year 7 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key and a model answer. Key answers: the 2 outer rows play the same notes; Welsh harpers took it up in London; it was called “the Welsh harp” by the middle of the 1700s; the maker from Llanrwst was John Richards; Bassett Jones made harps in Cardiff; Abram Wood; Telynores Maldwyn. History order: Italy, London, “the Welsh harp”, Great Exhibition, Nansi Richards born, very few players. Steps 4 to 8 accept other sensible wordings if they match the article.
(a) How the strings are arranged · From Italy to Wales · Keepers of the tradition · The triple harp today
(b) Pedals: fact box. Chromatic: glossary. Pedal harp: Keepers of the tradition. First played: fact box (also “From Italy to Wales”).
The reader goes straight to the right part of the text instead of reading everything again. Evidences criterion 1.
| Question | Answer | Where I found it |
|---|---|---|
| 2. Same notes | the 2 outer rows | How the strings are arranged |
| 3. Where first taken up | London | From Italy to Wales |
| 4. Name by the mid 1700s | “the Welsh harp” | From Italy to Wales |
| 5. Where heard | any 3 of: grand houses, cottages, inns, fairs, weddings, eisteddfodau | From Italy to Wales |
| 6. Llanrwst maker | John Richards | From Italy to Wales |
| 7. Bassett Jones’s city | Cardiff | From Italy to Wales |
| 8. Romani harpers | Abram Wood’s descendants | Keepers of the tradition |
| 9. Bardic name | Telynores Maldwyn | Keepers of the tradition |
Short, accurate answers with the section named show the information was found, not guessed. Evidences criteria 1 and 2.
1 first triple harp played in Italy, early 1600s · 2 Welsh harpers in London take it up, later in the 1600s · 3 called “the Welsh harp”, middle of the 1700s · 4 Bassett Jones’s harp for the Great Exhibition, 1851 · 5 Nansi Richards born, 1888 · 6 very few harpers can still play it, 1900
Highlighting the dates first made this quick. Note that Nansi Richards was born (1888) before 1900. Evidences criterion 2.
(a) diatonic: the 7 notes of a normal scale, with no extra notes squeezed in between.
(b) chromatic: every note there is, including all the in-between notes, so 12 in each octave.
(c) sharps and flats: the in-between notes; a sharp is the next note up, and a flat is the next note down.
(d) To play a sharp, the harpist reaches between the strings of an outer row and plucks a string in the middle row. The outer rows only have the notes of a normal scale, so the middle row is needed to add the in-between notes and make every note possible.
Each word is explained in everyday language, not copied, and (d) links the words to how the harp is built. Evidences criterion 3.
| Question | What I infer | Quotation as evidence |
|---|---|---|
| (a) Only rich people? | No: rich and poor people both enjoyed it. | “heard in grand houses and in humble cottages” |
| (b) Without Nansi Richards? | The tradition might have died out, because almost nobody else could pass it on. | “By 1900, very few harpers could still play the triple harp.” “so it was not lost” |
| (c) Seen as foreign? | No: although it came from Italy, Welsh people made it their own. | “people called it simply ‘the Welsh harp’” |
Each inference goes beyond what the text says directly, and a short, exact quotation proves it. Evidences criterion 4.
(a) To inform: it gives facts, dates and explanations and does not try to sell anything.
(b) Young people or general readers who are new to music, because the glossary explains simple words such as sharp and compares notes to “the white notes of a piano”.
(c) Headings split the article into topics, so you can find a section quickly. The fact box gives the key facts at a glance without reading the whole article.
(d) Both are in time order (chronological), from the 1600s to 1900, so the reader can follow how the story of the harp unfolded.
Purpose and audience are backed by clues from the text, and each layout feature is linked to how it helps the reader. Evidences criterion 5.
| Article | Leaflet | |
|---|---|---|
| Main purpose | to inform readers about the triple harp | to persuade people to buy tickets |
| Audience | readers who want to learn, such as pupils | local families who might go to a concert |
| Language feature | dates and technical words: “diatonic”, “1851” | a question and commands to the reader: “Have you ever heard a harp shimmer?”, “Book now” |
| Facts or opinions? | mostly facts that can be checked | mostly opinions: “unforgettable night”; the only facts are the time and prices |
The same topic is written differently because the purpose is different, and each difference has an example. Evidences criterion 6.
The triple harp matters to Welsh music because Wales took a foreign instrument and made it its own. It came from Italy, yet by the middle of the 1700s “people called it simply ‘the Welsh harp’”. This shows how proud Welsh people were of it. It also belonged to everyone, since it was heard “in grand houses and in humble cottages”, so it was music for all, not only for the rich. The tradition nearly disappeared: “By 1900, very few harpers could still play the triple harp.” This suggests that Romani families and teachers such as Nansi Richards saved it by passing it on. In my view, the triple harp matters because its shimmering sound is part of Welsh history that people still choose to keep alive.
Three quotations, each followed by an explanation (“This shows”, “so”, “This suggests”), build to a clear personal view. Evidences criteria 4 and 7.