Worked example · Humanities · Year 5
LNF: Literacy → Reading → Reading strategies
A secure Year 5 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key. It uses the stimulus sheet “Billy’s diary: a Liverpool evacuee in North Wales, 1939”, which was invented for this lesson. Headline answers: the farm is Bryn Farm; Billy ate 2 bowls of cawl; Mr Chamberlain spoke on the wireless; Huw is away in the navy. Event order E, C, F, A, B, D. Cause and effect 1Q, 2S, 3R, 4P. Steps 4, 5 and 6 have no single right answer: accept any sensible answer backed by an exact quote or a clear reason.
| Entry | What it is mostly about (one sentence) |
|---|---|
| 1 | Billy and Ted leave Liverpool by train as evacuees, and Billy is sad to leave Mum. |
| 2 | Mrs Pritchard chooses both boys in the village hall and takes them to live at her farm. |
| 3 | The family hears on the wireless that Britain is at war, and that night they do the blackout. |
| 4 | Billy starts at the village school and Megan teaches him his first Welsh words. |
| 5 | A letter comes from Mum and Billy starts to feel at home on the farm. |
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| What is the name of the farm? | Bryn Farm (Entry 2) |
| How many bowls of cawl did Billy eat? | 2 bowls (Entry 2) |
| Who spoke on the wireless on 3 September? | Mr Chamberlain, the Prime Minister (Entry 3) |
| Where is Mrs Pritchard’s son Huw? | Away in the navy (Entry 5) |
Each gist sentence sums up the whole entry, not just one detail. The scan answers are found quickly and the entry number is noted. Evidences criterion 1.
| Word | Entry | I think it means | The clue that helped me |
|---|---|---|---|
| evacuee | 1 | A child sent away from a city to somewhere safer during the war. | Reading ahead: the next sentence says “We are being sent away from Liverpool to the countryside, where it will be safer if bombs fall.” |
| billet | 2 | The home where an evacuee was sent to live and sleep. | Reading ahead: “Ted and I share a bed in the little room under the roof.” So the billet is where they live. |
| wireless | 3 | A radio. | Re-reading: everyone “listened to the wireless” and Mr Pritchard “switched it off”. What I already know: people heard news on the radio. |
| blackout | 3 | Covering every window at night so no light shows, so enemy planes cannot find the houses. | Reading ahead: “We pinned thick dark cloth over every window so that not one chink of light could get out.” |
Every meaning fits the sentence, and each clue names a strategy (reading ahead, re-reading, prior knowledge) and quotes the words that helped. Evidences criterion 2.
(a)
| Order | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th | 5th | 6th |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Letter | E | C | F | A | B | D |
(b) 1 → Q, 2 → S, 3 → R, 4 → P.
(c) Billy was not scared of the cows any more because he had been living on a farm for more than 3 weeks.
The order uses the dates and the order inside each entry (C comes before F because the boys were picked before they reached the farm). The pupil’s own sentence links two facts from different places: the dates 1 September and 24 September, and the cows in Entry 5. Other good answers: “Ted put the letter under his pillow because he missed Mum.” Evidences criterion 3.
(a) In Entry 1, Billy feels sad and worried, but he tries to be brave for Ted. I know because he writes “I did not look back because I did not want Ted to see my face.” and also “I kept my eyes on the window.” He is hiding that he is upset, maybe crying, so that Ted does not get more scared.
(b) In Entry 5, Billy feels happier, braver and more settled, although he still misses Mum. I know because he writes “I was not even scared of them any more.” and also “I think we will be all right here.” He still misses Mum because he “read the letter out loud to Ted three times”.
(c) I think Mrs Pritchard wanted the boys to feel at home and part of her family. Putting Mum next to Huw shows that the boys’ family matters to her as much as her own. Her son is away in the navy, so she knows what it is like to miss someone you love.
(d) A label like the one in the drawing is tied on, just like an address label on a parcel. Billy means he was being sent off somewhere without any choice, as if he was a thing being posted, not a boy.
Each feeling is backed by quotes copied exactly from the diary. Part (c) gives a reason the diary never states and links it to the clue about Huw. Part (d) uses the picture and the text together. Evidences criterion 4. Other good feelings for Entry 1: scared, lonely, upset. Other good evidence: “I felt like a parcel.” or “On the train, nobody sang for long.”
I predict that Mum will come to Bryn Farm at Christmas and meet Mrs Pritchard.
I think this because in Entry 5 it says “She is going to save up the train fare so she can visit at Christmas.” Mrs Pritchard put Mum’s photo on the dresser, so I think she would make Mum welcome too.
Something that could make my prediction wrong is that Mum might not save enough money for the train fare, or the war might make the trains hard to use.
The prediction is backed by an exact quote and a second clue, and the pupil thinks about what could change it. Evidences criterion 5. Other good predictions: Billy learns more Welsh (“I am going to learn one new Welsh word every day.”), or Billy and Megan become good friends.
| Can the diary tell us... | Yes, no or partly? | Why? |
|---|---|---|
| the date Britain declared war on Germany? | Partly | The date, 3 September 1939, matches the real facts on the sheet, but the diary is invented, so we should check it in another source. |
| how every evacuee in Wales felt? | No | It is only one child’s view. Other evacuees may have had a very different time. |
| what Mrs Pritchard was really thinking? | No | We only see what Billy noticed. We have to guess her thoughts. |
| what being an evacuee might have been like? | Partly | It is based on real events, so it gives us an idea, but it was made up for this lesson, so it is not real evidence. |
(b) A real diary is a primary source because a real evacuee wrote it at the time, so it tells us what really happened to that person and how they felt. A historian should still check it against other sources because it is only one person’s view. A child might not understand everything, might forget things or might leave things out.
The pupil knows the difference between an invented diary and a real primary source, and sees that even a real diary is one person’s view. Evidences criterion 6.
Croeso means welcome. Clue: Mrs Pritchard says it “at the door” and “she was smiling”. Nos da means good night. Clue: Ted says it “At bedtime”.
Chink: a tiny gap or crack that light could shine through. Clue: the cloth was pinned “so that not one chink of light could get out”, so a chink must be a very small bit.
Mrs Pritchard’s diary (sample answer): Two little boys from Liverpool were left at the end in the hall today. The small one was trying so hard not to cry. I could not let them be split up, so I took them both. I hope their mother knows they are safe and warm with us.