Worked example · Health and Social Care, and Childcare · Year 11
LNF: Literacy → Reading → Reading strategies
A secure Year 11 response, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key. The key idea: Glenys says she is “fine”, but the evidence shows she may not be eating enough, is missing her diabetes tablets, is avoiding the stairs, is cold, and is lonely and grieving. Good answers infer these needs from clues and still respect what she wants most: to stay in her own home. Other reasonable suggestions for support are fine if they are backed by evidence from the case study.
Glenys, 79, lives alone and had a fall 3 weeks ago; she says she is fine but may be struggling to cope at home since her husband died.
One sentence that catches the main problem and the tension in the case. Evidences criterion 1.
| Question | Answer | Paragraph |
|---|---|---|
| When did she fall? | 3 weeks ago | 2 |
| Health condition | Type 2 diabetes | 2 |
| How often Sian visits | Every other Sunday | 3 |
| Who shops | Mr Harjit Singh, her neighbour | 6 |
| Years in the choir | 40 years | 7 |
Evidences criterion 1.
| Need | Stated, with evidence | Inferred, with the clue |
|---|---|---|
| Physical | Mobility after the fall: she walks with a stick and has a bruised hip (paragraph 2). | Nutrition and diabetes control: nearly empty fridge, loose cardigan and untaken tablets in the dosette box (6). Warmth: cold room, heater only on for Sian (5). |
| Intellectual | To understand and manage her own affairs: unopened bank letters (6). | Possible memory problems or low motivation: missed tablets and unopened post (6). Needs information in Welsh to follow it fully (4). |
| Emotional | Grief: Ifor died 18 months ago after 52 years (1). | Loneliness and low mood: “nobody to listen to anyway” (7). Fear of falling again: goes upstairs “only when I have to” (5). Pride: does not want to be “a nuisance” (5). |
| Social | Stopped going to chapel and choir after Ifor died (7). | Isolated: only contact is Sian every other Sunday and Mr Singh for shopping (3, 6). Transport: Ifor always drove (7). |
Each need has a paragraph number, and the inferred needs rest on specific clues rather than guesses. Evidences criteria 2 and 3.
| Quotation | What it suggests |
|---|---|
| “I’m fine, really...” | She is proud and afraid of being a burden, so she may play down her problems. Her words do not match the evidence in paragraph 6, so practitioners should not take them at face value. |
| Armchair “because it’s comfier” | More likely she is afraid of the stairs after the fall. It also means she may not be getting to the upstairs toilet at night safely, and sleeping in a chair can cause stiffness and more falls. |
| “Nobody to listen to anyway” | Loneliness. Leaving the hearing aid out will also cut her off further, and may make her seem more confused than she is. |
| More freely in Welsh | She is more comfortable in her first language, so she will explain her needs better in Welsh. An English-only service would miss things. |
The pupil sees that what Glenys says and what the evidence shows are different, and judges which to trust. Evidences criteria 3 and 4.
Evidences criterion 3.
First, an occupational therapist could fit a second stair rail and a bed or commode downstairs if needed, and teach Glenys safe ways to get up after a fall. This meets her physical need for safe mobility, shown by her avoiding the stairs, and it helps her stay in her own home, which is what matters most to her.
Second, a volunteer driver or a choir friend could take her back to the chapel choir each week. This meets her social and emotional needs, because she has been isolated since Ifor died and she “sat up” when the choir was mentioned. It is person-centred because it builds on her own interests rather than on a service she has not chosen. All support should come with an active offer of Welsh, so she can say what she really needs.
138 words. Each suggestion names the need it meets, gives evidence from the case study, links to what matters to Glenys, and uses the terms person-centred and active offer correctly. Evidences criterion 5.