Worked example · Maths · Year 11

Reading an unstructured solar roof problem

LNF: Literacy → Reading → Reading strategies

What this is

A complete, secure Year 11 answer, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key. The numbers: 24 × 400 W = 9.6 kW; 9.6 × 900 = 8,640 kWh a year; savings £1,451.52 + export £518.40 = £1,969.92 a year; the hall pays £14,500 − £3,625 = £10,875; payback = 10,875 ÷ 1,969.92 = 5.5 years. The most common reading errors are treating all the electricity as saved at 28p, forgetting the grant, and using irrelevant facts such as the standing charge or the panel size.

Step 1: skim for gist

(a) A village hall is deciding whether to buy solar panels to cut its electricity bill.

(b) Paragraph 7. “After the grant, will the panels save and earn enough money to cover what the hall pays within 10 years, and about how many years will that take?”

The pupil spots that the question has two parts (yes or no, and how long). Evidences criterion 1.

Step 2: scan for detail

FindNumber and unitParagraph
Panels24 panels2
Power of one panel400 W2
Generation per kW900 kWh a year3
Share used in the hall60%4
Price paid28p per kWh5
Price for selling15p per kWh5
Installation cost£14,5002
Grant25% of the cost6

Each number is recorded with its unit, which matters later: W and kW, pence and pounds. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 3: close reading

FactNeed it?
214 eventsDo not need
Standing charge 53p a dayDo not need
1,000 W in 1 kWNeed
Panel size 1.7 m by 1.1 mDo not need (the installer already says 24 fit)
Gas 7p per kWhDo not need
Savings £16,800Do not need for the question (it only shows the hall can afford it)
Assume prices stay the sameNeed: it lets us use the same saving every year

(b) Paragraph 5 says the standing charge is paid “whatever we use”. The panels cannot reduce it, so it does not change the saving.

(c) Hidden steps: (1) change 400 W panels into kW, because the generation figure is per kW; (2) split the electricity into 60% used and the rest, 40%, sold; (3) value the two parts at different prices, 28p and 15p; (4) change pence into pounds; (5) take the 25% grant off the cost before comparing.

“The rest” is inferred to mean 100% − 60% = 40%. The pupil explains why a fact is not needed, using the text’s own words. Evidences criteria 3 and 4.

Step 4: plan (model)

  1. Find the total power of the panels in kW.
  2. Find the electricity made in a year in kWh.
  3. Split it into the 60% used and the 40% sold.
  4. Find the money saved on the part used, at 28p.
  5. Find the money earned on the part sold, at 15p.
  6. Add them to get the benefit each year.
  7. Find what the hall pays after the 25% grant.
  8. Divide the cost by the yearly benefit to get the payback time, and compare with 10 years.

Step 5: solve and conclude (model)

1. Total power: 24 × 400 W = 9,600 W = 9,600 ÷ 1,000 = 9.6 kW.

2. Electricity a year: 9.6 × 900 = 8,640 kWh.

3. Used: 60% of 8,640 = 0.6 × 8,640 = 5,184 kWh. Sold: 40% of 8,640 = 3,456 kWh. Check: 5,184 + 3,456 = 8,640.

4. Saved: 5,184 × 28p = 145,152p = £1,451.52.

5. Earned: 3,456 × 15p = 51,840p = £518.40.

6. Benefit each year: £1,451.52 + £518.40 = £1,969.92.

7. Grant: 25% of £14,500 = £3,625. The hall pays £14,500 − £3,625 = £10,875.

8. Payback: £10,875 ÷ £1,969.92 = 5.52… years. Check: 5.5 × 2,000 = 11,000, close to 10,875.

Conclusion: Yes. After the grant the hall pays £10,875, and the panels save and earn about £1,970 a year, so they pay for themselves in about 5.5 years, well within 10 years. This assumes, as Ruth asked, that electricity prices stay the same.

The plan in words comes first, so every calculation has a purpose. The conclusion answers both parts of the question and states the assumption. Evidences criterion 5.

Step 6: reflect (model)

“Close reading with annotation helped most. Marking the standing charge and the panel size with X stopped me using them, and marking ‘the rest’ with ! made me see that 40% is sold at a lower price.”

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure