Worked example · IT · Year 8
DCF: Citizenship → Digital rights, licensing and ownership
A secure Year 8 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key. The two questions to ask of every job are: does it change the photo? (ND forbids sharing a changed version; SA makes you share it under the same licence) and does it make money? (NC forbids it). Photo 6 needs written permission for everything.
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Attribution (BY) | You must name the person who made it, link to the licence and say what you changed. |
| Commercial | Using it mainly to make money, such as on something you sell or in an advert. |
| Derivative | A new version made by changing the original, for example by cropping it and adding words, or using it in a collage. |
| ShareAlike (SA) | If you make a changed version, you have to let other people use your version on the same terms. |
| Public domain (CC0) | Nobody owns the rights any more, so anyone can use it for anything without asking. |
| All rights reserved | The owner keeps every right. You must ask them and get permission first. |
Meanings are in the pupil’s own words, with an example where it helps. Evidences criterion 1.
| Photo and licence | Job A: banner (changed) | Job B: hoodies (sold) | Job C: news story (unchanged) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 CC BY | Yes: credit, and say it was cropped and words added | Yes: credit | Yes: credit |
| 2 CC BY-NC | Yes: the school website is not commercial; credit and say what changed | No: selling hoodies is commercial | Yes: credit |
| 3 CC BY-ND | No: cropping and adding words makes a changed version | Yes, if printed exactly as it is: credit | Yes: credit |
| 4 CC0 | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| 5 CC BY-SA | Yes: credit, say what changed, and share the banner under CC BY-SA | Yes: credit | Yes: credit |
| 6 All rights reserved | No, not without written permission | No | No |
Every decision follows from the two questions, and the conditions that come with each Yes are written down, not just the Yes. Evidences criterion 2.
(a) The NC condition says you may “not use the work for commercial purposes: anything mainly meant to make money”. The hoodies are sold to parents for £25 to raise money for the trip, so making money is the main point, even though it is for a good cause.
(b) The ND condition says that if you “change, remix or build on the work, you may not share the changed version”. Job A changes the photo in two ways: it is cropped into a thin strip, and words are written across it. Putting it on a public website is sharing it.
(c) Mr Pugh writes that the photos “are on the internet and free to use”. This is wrong because section 4 says being easy to find online does not make a photo free, and copyright protects a photo automatically as soon as it is taken. He also writes “if we give credit we can use anything”. This is wrong because giving credit is not the same as having permission: photo 6 is all rights reserved, so even with the photographer’s name under it, using it would break copyright.
(d) By choosing NC, Mari shows she does not want other people to make money from her work. Because she did not choose ND, I can infer she does not mind people cropping or changing her photo, as long as they give her credit and are not making money from it.
Quotations are exact and short, and each is followed by an explanation that links the words to the job. In (c) the pupil retrieves the phrases and counters each with a fact; in (d) they read between the lines, using what the licence leaves out as well as what it says. Evidences criteria 3 and 4.
(a) “Pen y Fan at sunrise” by Tomos Rees, from LluniauAgored, CC BY 4.0. Cropped and text added by Ysgol Bryn Alaw.
(b) “Llyn Padarn in autumn” by Siân Morgan, from LluniauAgored, CC BY-SA 4.0. Cropped and text added by Ysgol Bryn Alaw. This banner is shared under CC BY-SA 4.0. The extra condition is that our banner must go out under the same licence, so other people may reuse our banner on the same terms.
All four TASL parts in order, plus the changes. Evidences criterion 5.
Dear Mr Pugh,
For the banner, I recommend photo 1, because CC BY lets us crop it and add words as long as we credit Tomos Rees and say what we changed. For the hoodies, I recommend photo 4, because CC0 means anyone can use it, even to make money. Photo 2 cannot be used on the hoodies because its NC licence forbids commercial use. For the news story, any of photos 1 to 5 would work, but photo 3 suits it best because ND only allows it unchanged. However, photo 6 is all rights reserved, so giving credit is not enough. If you want it, you need to email Bae Photos Ltd and get written permission first.
Diolch, Cerys
115 words, not counting the greeting and sign-off. One photo per job, each with a reason drawn from the licence, a clear warning about photo 6 and a practical next step. Polite and formal for an adult reader. Evidences criteria 3 and 5.
Any licence with a reason: for example CC BY-NC, because I am happy for other schools to use it but I do not want a company to sell it.
Credit for photo 4: it shows the school respects creators and sets a good example to pupils, and it records where the photo came from in case anyone asks later.