Worked example · Computer Science · Year 9

Reading the privacy notice for a revision app

LNF: Literacy → Reading → Understanding, response and analysis

What this is

A complete, secure Year 9 answer, annotated against the success criteria. It is also the answer key. Steps 1 and 2 have fixed answers. Steps 3 to 6 show strong answers: pupils’ wording will differ, but good answers use short, accurate quotations and explain them. The strongest pupils notice that the notice is not all bad: it is honest in places, and the problem is mostly what the app store page leaves out.

Step 1: skim

QuestionSection
Can I make them delete everything about me?6
Does the app know where I live?2
Can my friend who is 12 sign up by herself?7
Does anyone else get my quiz scores?4
Will they tell me if the rules change?8

Headings are used to locate information quickly before reading closely. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 2: find the facts

QuestionAnswerSection
(a) Company and baseCwis Cyf, Aberystwyth1
(b) 3 things always collectedAny 3 of: name, email address, school, year group, quiz scores, topics revised, time spent in the app, device type, approximate location from the IP address2
(c) CountriesThe UK and the USA4
(d) Voice recordings30 days5
(e) After you stop using itUp to 3 years after your last log-in5
(f) Partner offersOn. Switch off in Settings > Privacy > Partner offers.3
(g) Copy of your dataWithin 1 month6
(h) ComplaintsThe Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO)6

Answer (b) is the one pupils most often get wrong: precise location, contacts and voice recordings only apply “if you choose to turn them on”, but approximate location is always collected. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 3: words in context

WordMeaningClue
personalisechange something to suit one particular person“for example by showing you the topics you get wrong most often”
by defaultalready set that way before you change anything“You can switch them off”, so they start switched on
legitimate interestsa reason the company says is fair for its own business, without asking your permission first“as a free app”: it needs money from adverts
pseudonymisedyour name is replaced with a code, but the information is still about you and could be linked back“information about your interests and revision habits” is still shared
transferredhanded over or moved to someone else“bought by another company”, so the data moves to the new owner

Meanings are given in the pupil’s own words and tied to a clue, not copied from a dictionary. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 4: claim against detail

PromiseSupports or challenges?Quotation and sectionWhat this shows
“We never sell your data.”Supports in words, but challenges in effect“We may share pseudonymised information about your interests and revision habits with selected advertising partners” (4)They may not be paid for the data directly, but they still give information about you to advertisers. “Never sell” makes it sound as if nobody else gets it.
“Only you can see your results.”Challenges“Your teacher can then see your scores” (4)A teacher in a class group sees scores, and the analytics company sees how you use the app. The promise is not true.
“Your privacy is our top priority.”Challenges“Partner offers are switched on by default” (3)If privacy came first, the setting that shares your interests with advertisers would start switched off.
“100% safe for young people.”Challenges“servers in the UK and the USA” (4); “up to 3 years after you last log in” (5)No app can promise to be 100% safe. Data kept for years and in 2 countries is more data that could be lost or misused.

Quotations are short and exact, and the explanation says what the evidence shows rather than repeating it. The first row recognises that a claim can be true in its exact words and still mislead. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 5: word choices

(a) They are all vague: they avoid saying exactly what will happen, how often or who is involved. “May” means something might happen without promising it will not, “selected” sounds careful but does not name a single partner, and “from time to time” gives no dates. The effect is to make the notice sound calm and controlled while leaving the company free to do more than the reader expects.

(b) The company’s interests come first. The reason given is “as a free app”, which is about how Cwis Cyf makes money, not about helping pupils revise. The words “our legitimate interests” use “our”, not “your”.

(c) Text A is an advert: short bold promises are quick to read and persuade people to download the app. Text B is a legal document that has to be accurate, so it uses conditions such as “if you choose” and long lists. The company may expect most people to read only Text A.

Words are grouped by their effect and the analysis links the language to the writer’s purpose. Evidences criterion 4.

Step 6: model response

The CofioCwis privacy notice is mostly honest, but it is not clear enough for a 13-year-old, and its app store page makes promises that the notice itself does not support.

To be fair, the notice does tell users their rights in plain words. It says you can “ask us to delete your information” and explains exactly where to do it, so a pupil could act on it.

However, important choices are hidden in long lists. Partner offers are “switched on by default”, which means a pupil shares their “interests and revision habits” with advertisers unless they find a setting three menus deep. Most 13-year-olds would never know.

The notice also uses vague words that sound reassuring but promise little. “Selected advertising partners” are never named, and the notice “may” change “from time to time”, with no promise to tell users. This leaves the company in control rather than the reader.

Finally, the notice contradicts the app page. The page says “Only you can see your results”, but section 4 admits “Your teacher can then see your scores”. A pupil who trusted the advert would be misled.

Overall, the notice is truthful in its details but written in a way that protects the company more than the user. Cwis Cyf should switch partner offers off by default and add a 5-line summary at the top in plain English.

227 words. A clear opening judgement, one strength, three developed points each with a short quotation and an explanation, and a conclusion with a judgement and a specific improvement. Connectives (“To be fair”, “However”, “Finally”, “Overall”) guide the reader through the argument. Evidences criteria 3, 4 and 5.

If you finish early: example answers

Why this response is secure