Worked example · Science · Year 9

Reading two articles about a tidal lagoon

LNF: Literacy → Reading → Reading strategies

What this is

A secure Year 9 response, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key. Scanning answers: 7 km, 14 turbines, about 120,000 homes, 4 years, up to 3,000 birds, 9 metres. Facts: sentences 1, 3 and 5. Opinions: 2 and 4. The key idea: Text A explains the science in a balanced way, while Text B reports people who each have a reason to see the lagoon differently.

Step 1: skimming

TextGistPurpose
Text AHow a tidal lagoon uses the rising and falling tide to turn turbines, and its benefits and problems.To inform or explain.
Text BA planned lagoon in Bae Gwenith has split the town, with a developer for it and local people worried about jobs, fish and birds.To report (with different views).

Both gists capture the whole text in one sentence, not one detail. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 2: scanning

1. 7 km · 2. 14 · 3. about 120,000 · 4. 4 years · 5. up to 3,000 · 6. 9 metres

All 6 are correct and include units. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 3: new words

WordStrategyMeaning
predictableRoot: predict + -ableCan be known in advance. The tide times can be worked out years ahead.
sluiceContext: “gates stay closed until ... then water is let in”A gate that controls when water flows in or out.
bidirectionalRoot: bi- (two) + directionWorks in two directions: the turbines turn as water flows in and as it flows out.
intertidalRoot: inter- (between) + tide. The text also explains it.The area of mud and sand between the high tide and low tide lines.
sedimentContext: “may settle in the calmer water”Fine bits of mud and sand carried by water that sink when the water slows down.
megawattsRoot: mega- (a million) + wattMillions of watts. A unit of power, how fast electricity is produced.

Each meaning fits this text, and the pupil names the strategy that got them there. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 4: viewpoints and facts

PersonWhat they thinkWords that show it
Rhian OwenStrongly for it. She is also the project director, so she wants it built.“most exciting thing ... in a century”, “never let us down”
Dafydd MorganAgainst it or doubtful. He thinks the jobs claim is misleading and fears for fish.“most of those last only for the 4 years”, “What about the fish?”
Carys JenkinsWorried about the birds losing their feeding ground.“Where will they go?”

(b) 1 F · 2 O · 3 F · 4 O · 5 F

(c) “A lagoon produces most power when the difference in water height is greatest, so its output rises and falls during the day and there are short times when it produces none.” The tide is predictable, but the power is not there all the time.

The pupil reads beyond the words: Rhian’s job gives her a reason to exaggerate, and Dafydd’s question shows doubt without saying “I am against it”. Evidences criterion 4.

Step 5: reliability

(a) Text A. It comes from a science centre that is not trying to sell the lagoon, and it gives the problems as well as the benefits in calm, neutral language. Text B is mostly quotes from people who have a reason to be for or against it.

(b) Any 2 of: 210 megawatts, about 120,000 homes, 120 years, 400 jobs. The developer wants permission to build, so it may give the best possible figures. They should be checked by someone independent.

Reliability is judged from who wrote the text, why, and how balanced it is. Evidences criterion 5.

Step 6: a model summary (60 words)

A tidal lagoon is a sea wall that traps water in part of a bay. When the tide rises or falls, a height difference builds up. Water then rushes through tunnels in the wall and spins turbines that generate electricity both ways. One advantage is that tides are predictable. One concern is that wading birds may lose their feeding ground.

The summary is in the pupil’s own words, keeps the science in the right order and gives one advantage and one concern. Evidences criterion 6.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure