Worked example · RE · Year 8
LNF: Numeracy → Developing mathematical proficiency → Logical reasoning
A secure Year 8 response and full answer key, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. The key idea: the Islamic year is 11 days shorter (365 − 354), so Ramadan starts 11 days earlier each solar year and moves through every season in about 33 years. The start dates in the model are 1 March, 18 February, 7 February, 27 January, 16 January, then 5 January and 25 December in Year 5.
(a) 365 − 354 = 11 days.
| Year | 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ramadan starts | 1 March | 18 February | 7 February | 27 January | 16 January |
Working for Year 1: 1 March minus 1 day is 28 February; minus 10 more days is 18 February.
Predictions follow a stated rule, and the step across the end of February (28 days) is shown. Evidences criterion 1.
414 − 365 = day 49. Day 32 is 1 February, so day 49 is 18 February. This matches.
(a) Year 2: 49 + 354 = 403, and 403 − 365 = day 38 = 7 February. This matches too.
(b) Adding 354 and then taking away 365 is the same as adding 354 − 365, which is −11. So both methods always give the same day.
The pupil verifies with a second, independent method and then proves in general why the two methods must agree. Evidences criteria 2 and 4.
(a) Year 5: 16 January − 11 days = 5 January (day 5). Next: 5 + 354 = day 359, which is less than 365, so it is still Year 5. Day 335 is 1 December, so day 359 is 25 December, Year 5.
(b) In Year 5, Ramadan starts on 5 January and again on 25 December, so it starts twice in one solar year. One example is enough to prove that something can happen.
(c) The next start is the day number + 354. For it to be in the same year, day + 354 ≤ 365, so day ≤ 11. Ramadan must start on or before day 11 (11 January).
An example proves the claim, and an inequality gives the general condition. Evidences criteria 3 and 4.
(a) 365 ÷ 11 = 33.18…, so about 33 years.
(b) 33 × 365 = 12,045 days. 12,045 ÷ 354 = 34.03…, so there are about 34 Islamic years. The claim is true.
(c) From age 15 to 50 is 36 years, so at least 36 Ramadans. Between the first and the last of these, Ramadan moves back at least 35 × 11 = 385 days. That is more than a whole year of 365 days, so yes, they will have fasted in every season.
Each answer is justified with a calculation, and the answer to (c) links back to the cycle in (a). Evidences criteria 1 and 3.
| Claim | Verdict and proof |
|---|---|
| 1 | False. It moves 11 days earlier each year, so over about 33 years it passes through every season, including summer. |
| 2 | True. June: 02:50 to 21:35 = 18 h 45 min. December: 06:20 to 16:05 = 9 h 45 min. Difference: 9 hours. |
| 3 | False. The Jewish calendar adds an extra month in 7 years out of 19, so Passover stays in spring. |
| 4 | True. 19 × 11 = 209 days short; 7 × 30 = 210 days added. These are almost equal, so over 19 years the calendar catches up. |
Every verdict comes with a calculation or a fact from the stimulus. Evidences criterion 3.
The Islamic calendar follows the Moon, so its year is 354 days. Our calendar follows the Sun and has 365 days. Because the Islamic year is 11 days shorter, Ramadan starts 11 days earlier every year. Therefore it slowly moves through all the seasons, taking about 33 years (365 ÷ 11) to go all the way round. The Jewish calendar adds an extra month 7 times in 19 years, so Passover stays in spring, and Christmas has a fixed date. (80 words)
The explanation is a chain of reasons with numbers, using precise words (lunar year, 11 days shorter, 33 years). Evidences criterion 4.