Worked example · The Sciences · Year 11

Redrafting a practical write-up

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Proofreading, editing and improving

What this is

A complete, secure Year 11 answer, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key. Key points: the 7 misspelt words; the anomaly is +2.1 at 0.6 mol/dm3; the corrected mean is −9.6; the change in mass crosses zero between 0.2 and 0.4 mol/dm3, at about 0.36 mol/dm3. This is practice on an invented pupil’s work, not NEA. The most common weakness in pupils’ redrafts is a conclusion that still has no numbers in it.

Step 1: read and review

Checklist pointScoreThe biggest problem
1. Accuracy07 key words misspelt, including the title.
2. Vocabulary0Everyday words such as “sugar water”, “sucked” and “weird”.
3. Method0One long run-on sentence with no quantities, so nobody could repeat it.
4. Results1Good repeats, but no units and the anomaly is included in the mean.
5. Conclusion1Right pattern, but no data and a wrong explanation (“sucked”).
6. Evaluation0Vague improvements and a claim of accuracy with no evidence.

Each score comes with a specific reason, so Cai knows what to fix first. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 2: proofread for spelling

Cai wroteCorrect spelling
Osmossis (twice)osmosis
wieghedweighed
Concentraitionconcentration
reusltsresults
partialypartially
permablepermeable
seperateseparate

Cai spells “weighed” correctly once and wrongly once, which shows why a slow final read matters. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 3: upgrade the vocabulary

Cai wroteBetter scientific wording
sugar watersucrose solution (with its concentration in mol/dm3)
the potato got biggerthe mass of the potato cylinder increased
the sugar sucked the water outwater moved out of the cells by osmosis, into the more concentrated solution
left them for a dayleft them for 24 hours
one weird resultone anomalous result
better scalesa balance with a higher resolution, for example 0.001 g

(b) Repeatable. His 3 results at each concentration are close together (except the anomaly), so his method gives similar results when repeated. That does not prove they are accurate, which means close to the true value.

Sucrose does not “suck”: water moves by osmosis. Replacing that phrase fixes the science as well as the style. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 4: rewrite the method (model)

  1. Cut 18 potato cylinders with a cork borer and trim each one to 4 cm with a ruler.
  2. Blot each cylinder dry with paper towel and measure its starting mass on a balance that reads to 0.01 g. Record it.
  3. Pour 20 cm3 of sucrose solution into each of 18 boiling tubes: 3 tubes each of 0.0, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8 and 1.0 mol/dm3. Label them.
  4. Place one cylinder in each tube and leave for 24 hours.
  5. Remove each cylinder, blot it dry in the same way and measure its final mass.
  6. Calculate the percentage change in mass for each cylinder.

The independent variable is the concentration of sucrose. The dependent variable is the percentage change in mass. The control variables are the cylinder length, the volume of solution, the time and the blotting.

Each step starts with a command word and gives a quantity, so another pupil could follow it exactly. The variables are named with the correct terms. Evidences criterion 4.

Step 5: fix the results

(a) “Concentration of sucrose solution (mol/dm3)” and “Mean percentage change in mass (%)”.

(b) +2.1, repeat 2 at 0.6 mol/dm3. The other two repeats are −9.8 and −9.4, and the pattern says the mass should fall at this concentration, but this cylinder gained mass.

(c) (−9.8 + −9.4) ÷ 2 = −19.2 ÷ 2 = −9.6.

(d) Between 0.2 (+7.9) and 0.4 (−1.8) mol/dm3. At the point where the mass does not change, the solution has the same concentration as the inside of the potato cells, so no overall water moves. That point is closer to 0.4, at about 0.36 mol/dm3 if you draw a straight line between the two points.

The anomaly is identified with a reason and left out of the mean, not deleted from the table. Check: with the anomaly the mean was (−9.8 + 2.1 − 9.4) ÷ 3 = −5.7, which is why Cai’s mean did not fit the pattern.

Step 6: the redraft (model)

Conclusion. As the concentration of sucrose increased, the percentage change in mass decreased. In distilled water the cylinders gained 18.2%, at 0.4 mol/dm3 they lost 1.8%, and at 1.0 mol/dm3 they lost 16.0%. In dilute solutions, water moved into the cells by osmosis through the partially permeable membrane, because the concentration of water was higher outside. In concentrated solutions, water moved out. There was no change at about 0.36 mol/dm3, so this is probably the concentration inside the potato cells.

Evaluation. One result, +2.1% at 0.6 mol/dm3, was anomalous, possibly because that cylinder was not blotted dry before the final weighing. Blotting every cylinder for the same time would make the final masses more consistent. Adding tubes at 0.25, 0.30 and 0.35 mol/dm3 would show more precisely where the change in mass is zero.

The conclusion describes the pattern with 3 numbers before explaining it, and uses all three required terms. The evaluation names a specific problem with a likely cause and gives two specific improvements, each with its benefit. The conclusion is 79 words and the evaluation 53. Evidences criteria 5 and 6.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure