Worked example · Art · Year 11

Redrafting an artist statement for an exhibition

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Proofreading, editing and improving

What this is

A secure Year 11 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key. Step 1: exactly 12 errors, 7 spelling (releif, peice, alot, atmosphear, seperate, beleive, definately) and 5 punctuation (i, wennol, its, the comma splice in paragraph 3, the missing final full stop). Step 2: really 6 times, I used 6 times. Step 3: best order 5 (first sentence only), 3, 4, 2, cutting paragraph 1. Other precise replacements and cuts are fine if they fit Lowri’s notes. Practice only, not NEA work.

Step 1: proofread

 ParaErrorCorrectionS or P?
11i thinkI think (the pronoun I is always a capital)P
22releifrelief (i before e except after c)S
33peicepiece (a piece of pie)S
43Porth wennolPorth Wennol (both words of a place name)P
53its really niceit’s (it is) really niceP
63alota lot (always 2 words)S
73atmosphearatmosphere (atmo + sphere)S
83really big, it is A1.really big: it is A1. (or a full stop; a comma cannot join 2 sentences)P
94seperateseparate (there is “a rat” in separate)S
104beleivebelieve (never believe a lie)S
115definatelydefinitely (it contains “finite”)S
125my workmy work. (full stop at the end)P

All 12 are found, sorted correctly and fixed, with a memory aid for the spellings. The comma splice and the missing full stop are the hardest to see: reading aloud catches them. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 2: precision and repetition

(a) really: 6 times. I used: 6 times.

ParaVague phrasePrecise replacement
1I have done lots of stuff this yearMy series of 3 pieces, Olion y Llanw, …
3really nice and darkgives a wide tonal range, from soft willow greys to the dense black of compressed charcoal
3to make the stones look old and wetlifted out highlights with a putty rubber so the worn stones look wet
4They came out really niceThe exposed paper turned Prussian blue, leaving crisp white negative shapes
2it goes with the cyanotypesthe blue-grey glaze continues the palette of the cyanotypes
2Some of the shells broke off in the kiln, which was annoying.3 shells fell out in the kiln, but I kept the hollows because they are traces too.

(c) Cut: “Hi, my name is Lowri and I am in Year 11.” (the brief says no greetings, and her name is on the card); “Art is my favourite subject.” (tells the visitor nothing about the work); “It took ages.” (vague, and time spent is not meaning); “Thank you for looking at my work” (the brief says no thanks). “I hope you like my stuff” and “I definitely think the exhibition will be really good” are also correct answers.

Each replacement comes from Lowri’s notes, so it is accurate as well as technical. The shells sentence is turned from a complaint into a decision, which is what an evaluative statement needs. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 3: structure and intention

(a) Order: 5 (only its first sentence, as the start of the intention), 3 (drawing, displayed first), 4 (cyanotypes), 2 (relief, displayed last). Cut paragraph 1 and the rest of paragraph 5.

(b) “My series explores what the tide leaves behind at Porth Wennol harbour, where my nain grew up. She told me that the harbour looks different twice a day, so I set out to record its changing surfaces in 3 pieces linked by a palette of blues and greys.”

(c) “As you move from left to right, look for the blue that repeats across all 3 pieces, like water moving from one to the next.”

The stranded sentence about nain becomes the reason for the whole series, and the pieces now follow the display order the visitor sees. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 4: model redraft

Olion y Llanw (Traces of the Tide)

My series explores what the tide leaves behind at Porth Wennol harbour, where my nain grew up. She told me that the harbour looks different twice a day, so I set out to record its changing surfaces in 3 pieces linked by a palette of blues and greys.

The first piece is an A1 charcoal drawing of the harbour wall. I built a wide tonal range with willow and compressed charcoal, then lifted out highlights with a putty rubber so the stones look wet.

Next are 3 cyanotypes. I laid seaweed, rope and fishing net on coated paper, exposed it to sunlight for 10 minutes and washed it. The Prussian blue records every separate strand of the net, as if the tide had printed its own picture.

The final piece is a clay relief of the harbour steps with a blue-grey glaze. Some shells fell out in the kiln, but I kept the hollows because they are traces too.

As you move from left to right, look for the blue that repeats across all 3 pieces, like water moving from one to the next.

Word count: about 185.

Intention first, pieces in display order, a clear ending for the viewer. Art terms: series, palette, tonal range, willow charcoal, compressed charcoal, highlights, putty rubber, cyanotype, exposed, Prussian blue, relief, glaze. No errors, no “really”, and “I used” is replaced by varied verbs: built, lifted out, laid, exposed, kept. Evidences criteria 2, 3 and 4.

Step 5: partner checklist

All 6 boxes ticked for the model. Strength: “Your opening makes me want to look, because it links the work to your nain straight away.” Improvement: “Say the relief is 30 cm square, so visitors can picture its size next to the A1 drawing.”

Feedback is specific and actionable, and the writer can act on it in one sentence. Evidences criterion 5.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure