Worked example · English · Year 11
DCF: Producing → Sourcing, searching and planning digital content
A secure Year 11 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key for Step 3: 251 of 612 = 41.0% plan to leave, so “most” is not valid; the population fell by 1,540, which is 13.5%, and halving would have left 5,710; four of nine is 44.4%; 146 of 251 (58%) of those planning to leave would like to come back. The best sources are B, then C and E; A and F should not be used as evidence. Show this after pupils have tried the steps themselves.
(a) I would open B first: it is a PDF report from an organisation’s own site, dated December 2025, and the snippet names a survey of 612 young people, so it has real evidence. Then C: a local newspaper, dated January 2026, which seems to report the same survey and may have first-hand quotations. I would skip A because it is labelled Sponsored and comes from a housing developer, so it is an advert. I would skip F because “you won’t believe” and “will shock you” are clickbait, and no date is shown.
(b)
| Search | What it will find or remove | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | aberderwen "young people" survey filetype:pdf | Keeps “young people” together as a phrase and returns only PDFs, where research reports are usually published. |
| 2 | aberderwen belonging OR cynefin OR perthyn -homes -sale | Finds pages in English or Welsh about belonging, and removes the estate agent pages. |
| 3 | aberderwen population census site:ons.gov.uk | Only official census figures from the Office for National Statistics, to check the population claim in Source F. |
(c) The results are not ranked by reliability. The top result is there because the developer paid for it, and a clickbait blog comes second because lots of people click on it. Results can also be different for different people and places, so a search engine’s order is a starting point, not a judgement.
Choices are justified from the evidence on the page (label, address, date, snippet). Each search uses a technique for a stated purpose, one of them bilingual, and one is aimed at checking a specific claim. Part (c) names a limitation of the tool itself. Evidences criteria 1 and 4.
| Who made it, and why? | Evidence and date | /5 | Will you use it? How? | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | A housing developer, no author named. Purpose: to sell homes (“Book your viewing today”). | March 2026. One figure, 40 buyers under 30, with nothing to compare it to, and one hand-picked customer. “Flocking back” is not supported. | 2 | Not as evidence. At most as an example of how the town is sold to young people. |
| B | Two named researchers at an independent research charity. Purpose: to inform. The funder did not see the results first. | December 2025. 612 people, method explained, full tables, and it states its own limits. | 5 | Yes: my main source for every figure. |
| C | A named reporter on the local paper. Purpose: to inform, but also to attract readers. | January 2026. Reports Source B accurately in the text (“four in ten”) but the headline exaggerates. Two first-hand quotations. | 3 | Yes, for the quotations from Rhodri and Mali. Figures from B instead. |
| D | Anonymous forum users. Purpose: to vent and chat. | Two years old. No evidence beyond one person’s year group; “literally EVERYONE” is exaggeration. The reply disagrees. | 1 | Only as a voice, clearly labelled as one person’s feeling, alongside the reply. |
| E | A named youth worker with 12 years’ experience. Purpose: to share his view, and to raise money for the club. | June 2025. First-hand, but only 30 young leaders from his own club. Automatic captions may contain errors. | 3 | Yes, as a first-hand example, not as proof about the whole town. |
| F | “admin” on a clickbait blog. Purpose: to get clicks for the adverts. | Last updated 2014. No sources. The population claim is false when checked against B. | 1 | No. |
Every score is justified with evidence from the source itself: who made it, their purpose, their method and their date. The grid also decides how each source can be used, which is more useful than simply accepting or rejecting it. Evidences criterion 2.
(a) Not valid. Table 1 shows 251 of 612 plan to leave: 251 ÷ 612 × 100 = 41.0%. “Most” means more than half. More plan to leave (41%) than to stay (38%), but 21% are not sure. Accurate: “Four in ten young people plan to leave Aberderwen”, which is what the article itself says in its first line.
(b) 11,420 − 9,880 = 1,540. 1,540 ÷ 11,420 × 100 = 13.5%. If it had halved, the 2021 population would have been 11,420 ÷ 2 = 5,710. The claim is false.
(c) 4 ÷ 9 × 100 = 44.4%. It is weaker than it sounds because (1) it is only 30 young leaders from one club, and nine people is a tiny sample; (2) young leaders are the most involved young people in the town, the ones most likely to feel they belong, so they are not typical; and it comes from Rhodri’s memory in a video that also asks for donations. Source B says 146 of the 251 who plan to leave (58%) would like to come back one day. That is a wish, not a fact. Together they suggest that leaving is often not for ever, but neither proves how many actually return.
(d) About four in ten young people in Aberderwen (41%) plan to leave, but mostly to study (48%) or to work (36%), not because they do not belong. Family (72%) and friends (64%) make most of them feel they belong, and 58% of those leaving would like to come back one day. No source can tell me how many of the young people who have already left have really come back, or how they feel about the town now, because the survey only asked people who still live there.
All figures are correct, with working shown. The pupil tests each weak claim against the strongest source, spots the sampling problem in Source E, and rewrites the original belief because the evidence contradicts it. Naming a question that no source can answer uses Source B’s own limits. Evidences criteria 3 and 4.
Rowlands, E. and Price, O. (2025) Stay or go? Young people and belonging in Aberderwen. Canolfan Ymchwil Derwen. Available at: https://www.ymchwilderwen.org.uk/reports/stay-or-go.pdf (Accessed: 12 October 2026).
Pugh, S. (2026) ‘Most young people plan to quit Aberderwen, survey finds’, Aberderwen Courier, 14 January. Available at: https://www.aberderwencourier.co.uk/news/young-people-survey (Accessed: 12 October 2026).
Bevan, R. (2025) Why I stayed (and why some come back). Aberderwen Youth Club [video]. Available at: https://www.aberderwenyouthclub.org.uk/videos/why-i-stayed (Accessed: 12 October 2026).
The references follow one consistent format, with the date viewed (use the date of your own lesson). The spoken sentences tell the listener who the source is, how big the evidence is and where its limits are, in a sentence or two, so reliability comes through naturally instead of taking over the talk. Evidences criterion 5.
Stay or go? Belonging in Aberderwen (4 to 6 min)
Short bullets with figures, quotations and a source letter on every point, a view that disagrees, and a strong closing line. Nothing is written out to be read aloud, which is what the notes rules for the researched presentation require. Evidences criterion 6.