Worked example · Maths · Year 9

Reviewing a Pythagoras revision slideshow

DCF: Producing → Evaluating and improving digital content

What this is

A complete, secure Year 9 answer, annotated against the success criteria. It is also the answer key. Headline answers: slide 3 should give 13 cm and slide 4 8 cm; the biggest design problems are the red-on-green title, the mislabelled diagram and the wall of text on slide 4; the 17 text errors are listed in Step 3. The proofreading in Step 3 and the redrafted slide in Step 5 are where you can judge how well a pupil proofreads, edits and improves writing.

Step 1: check the maths

(a) a² + b² = c². 5² + 12² = 25 + 144 = 169. c = √169 = 13 cm. Ffion added the sides without squaring them.

(b) To find a shorter side, subtract: 10² − 6² = 100 − 36 = 64. Side = √64 = 8 cm.

(c) The hypotenuse is always the longest side. 11.66 cm is longer than the 10 cm hypotenuse, so it cannot be a shorter side.

(d) Slide 2 words: the theorem works only on right-angled triangles, not “all triangles”. Slide 2 diagram: the sloping side opposite the right angle is the hypotenuse, so it should be labelled c, but Ffion has labelled it b and put c on a shorter side; there is also no right-angle mark. Slide 4 last sentence: you do not “always add the squares”; you subtract when you are finding a shorter side.

Both examples are reworked with every step shown, and the pupil uses a sense check (the hypotenuse is the longest side) as well as calculation. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 2: judge the design

SlideChecklist numberWhy it matters for this audience
12 (also 3 and 4)Red writing on dark green has very little contrast, so it is hard to read on a small phone screen, and impossible for many people with red-green colour blindness. 4 fonts look messy, and the pyramid does not help explain the maths (Pythagoras was a Greek mathematician, not Egyptian).
24The diagram labels the wrong side as c and has no right-angle mark. A Year 8 pupil who has just started will learn the wrong side as the hypotenuse.
34 (also 5)There is no diagram, so a beginner cannot see which sides are 5 cm and 12 cm, and the working skips the squaring.
41About 60 words in a small font is too much to read on a phone, and it mixes the method with a wrong “rule”.

(b) The order is good: the rule first, then an example finding the hypotenuse, then an example finding a shorter side. That is the order a beginner needs.

Each problem is linked to the audience (Year 8 beginners) and the device (a phone), not just called “bad”. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 3: proofread

No.SlideErrorCorrection
11TheromTheorem
21Every thingEverything
31noknow
41!!!! (one is enough) or a full stop
52pythagoras (no capital)Pythagoras (a name)
62pythagoras theorem (no apostrophe)Pythagoras’ theorem
72a2 + b2 = c2a² + b² = c²
82werewhere
92hypotenuesehypotenuse
102the other (start of sentence)The other
112sides issides are
123c = 17cm (no full stop)full stop at the end
134ItsIt’s
144tooto
154you’reyour
164hypotenuesehypotenuse
174thatsthat’s

Also accept, as extras: a space between number and unit (5 cm, 12 cm, 17 cm), and “shorter sides” instead of “short sides”.

(b) It is easy to get the method right if you check which side you are finding. To find the hypotenuse, add the squares. To find a shorter side, subtract the smaller square from the bigger one.

Every error is found and corrected, including the less obvious ones (the apostrophe in Pythagoras’, the verb “is” with a plural subject, and maths notation). The comma splice is broken into separate sentences and the content is corrected at the same time. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 4: feedback for Ffion

TypeSlideComment
Praise3Slide 3 is short and uses easy numbers (5 and 12 give a whole-number answer), which is perfect for beginners.
Question4Your answer is 11.66 cm but the hypotenuse is 10 cm. Which side should always be the longest?
Suggestion1Try dark text on a white background and just 1 font, so the title is easy to read on a phone.

Each comment names a slide, says exactly what to look at and is something Ffion can act on. The question helps her find the mistake herself. Evidences criterion 4.

Step 5: redesigned slide 3 (model)

Finding the hypotenuse

5 cm 12 cm c

a² + b² = c² 5² + 12² = 25 + 144 = 169 c = √169 = 13 cm

Check: 13 cm is the longest side.

Colours and fonts: black text on a white background, one clear font such as Arial, the answer in bold, and the hypotenuse c in the same colour on the diagram and in the working.

About 25 words. The diagram is labelled correctly with the right-angle mark, the notation is correct, and the answer has a unit and a check. All text is accurately spelt and punctuated. Evidences criteria 3 and 5.

Step 6: justify your choices (model)

I added a labelled diagram with a right-angle mark because a Year 8 beginner needs to see which side is the hypotenuse before the numbers make sense. I wrote each step of the working on its own line because pupils revising on a phone can follow one short line at a time, and it shows the squaring Ffion missed. I used black text on white in one font because it is the easiest to read on a small screen and on the classroom board, including for pupils who are colour blind.

Each change is linked to the audience and the device, using “because”. Evidences criterion 5.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure