Worked example · Design Technology · Year 10
LNF: Literacy → Speaking → Collaborative talk
A secure Year 10 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. There is no single right decision: a group is secure if it checks every proposal against the brief, lists at least 3 options and gives reasons with evidence. Against the brief: A fails point 3 (only 5 of 8 children opened it); B fails points 2 and 6 (2 leaks, £5.20); C fails points 2 and 7 (1 leak, not accepted kerbside). The best-supported round 1 decision is A with 2 large lever clips, £4.05. In round 2 that is 5p over the new £4.00 limit, so a good group drops the printed logo (£3.90) and tells the client honestly that the seal cannot go in the kerbside collection, because A leaks 6 times out of 10 without it.
Inviting: “Before we decide, could the Client voice tell us what matters most?” Building: “That links to the Engineer’s point, because …” Challenging: “I understand, but is there evidence that children will use a heavier box?” Offering an option: “Could we combine the lever clips with the logo left off?” Summarising: “So we have 3 options on the table: …”
“Can I check: are we saying the budget matters more than the logo?” is summarising (checking what the group agrees).
Each phrase is polite and formal, and names a role or refers to evidence. Evidences criterion 2.
Top priority: children open the box alone.
| Proposal | For | Against |
|---|---|---|
| A | 0 leaks out of 10; £3.80, well under budget | 3 of the 7-year-olds could not open it; “The clips hurt my fingers” |
| B | 8 of 8 opened it; strong | £5.20 is £0.70 over budget; 320 g is heavy for a 7-year-old |
| C | 8 of 8 opened it; light | Leaked once; stains; not accepted kerbside |
Question for the Engineer: “Can A be made easier to open without going over £4.50?”
Every note is evidence from the pack, and the question targets the weakness that matters most to this role. Evidences criteria 1 and 3.
Chair: “We’ve looked at all 3. Before we vote on anything, what are our options?”
Engineer: “A with 2 lever clips costs £4.05 and all 4 of the 7-year-olds opened it.”
Sustainability lead: “To build on that, A’s box and lid are recyclable. C isn’t, so I’d rather change A than choose C.”
Client voice: “I like that, but I’d want to see it tested with more children.”
Chair: “So the options are A as it is, A with lever clips, or C with thicker walls at £4.60, which is over budget. Is everyone happy with A with lever clips, plus a bigger test?”
The Chair asks for options before a decision and then summarises them; others build and challenge politely with evidence. Evidences criteria 1, 2, 3 and 4.
Present: Chair (Ffion), Client voice (Jac), Engineer (Mali), Sustainability lead (Osian), Minute-taker (Seren).
Proposals: A fails point 3 (5 of 8). B fails points 2 and 6 (2 leaks, £5.20). C fails points 2 and 7 (1 leak, not kerbside) and stains.
Options: A as it is; A with lever clips (£4.05); B in thinner steel (£4.60, still over); C with thicker walls (£4.60, over).
Decision: recommend A with 2 large lever clips.
Reasons: it is the only option with 0 leaks that is under £4.50; the lever clips solve the opening problem (all 4 of the 7-year-old testers opened it).
Disagreement: Client voice wants a bigger test before ordering 500.
Actions: Engineer to test the lever clips with 10 more 7-year-olds by next Friday.
The decision is linked to the brief with figures, disagreement is recorded fairly and there is a clear action. Evidences criteria 3 and 4.
Options: A with lever clips (£4.05, 5p over); A with lever clips and no printed logo (£3.90); A without the seal (leaks 6 of 10); A with small clips (£3.80, but children cannot open it).
Revised recommendation: A with lever clips and no printed logo, £3.90. It is under £4.00, does not leak and children can open it.
What we tell the client: the silicone seal cannot go in the kerbside collection, but without it the box leaks 6 times out of 10. We will ask the maker whether a recyclable seal exists.
The group adapts to new information, compares several options and gives up the logo (a lower priority) to protect the most important points. Honesty about a point it cannot meet is a strength. Evidences criteria 3 and 4.
(a) When Osian and Jac disagreed about the logo, I said, “Can we rank the brief? Leaks and opening affect children every day; the logo does not.” That gave us a way to compare and we agreed in 2 minutes.
(b) A compromise. It was fair because every role spoke in item 2 and the disagreement was minuted.
(c) Chair was harder: I wanted to give my opinion. Next time I will ask for all options first and give my view last.
Quotes an exact contribution and explains its effect on the group. Evidences criteria 4 and 5.