Worked example · Drama · Year 10
LNF: Literacy → Speaking → Collaborative talk
A secure Year 10 group: Nia (chair), Harri (note-taker), Lowri (timekeeper) and Dylan (challenger). It shows part of their meeting written out, Harri’s minutes, Dylan’s role log and Nia’s reflection, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. There is no single right plan: groups can choose any starting idea or a mix. What to look for is a decision on all 4 items, a clear record of how each was agreed, and reflections that quote real words. This is practice only, not NEA work. Show this after pupils have held their own meeting.
NIA (chair): Item 1, the concept. Let’s go round first, so everyone speaks. Lowri?
LOWRI: Idea A. The last day in the chapel is really emotional, and there are parts for all of us.
HARRI: I’d go for B. Mair on the bridge is the strongest image in the whole article.
DYLAN (challenger): Can I challenge A? If it’s all 1961, the audience just watches a sad scene from a long time ago. Why would they care now? I’d still pick C.
LOWRI: The link to now could be Mair. She’s in both times.
HARRI: Building on that, what if we combine A and B? The bridge today, with flashbacks to the last day.
NIA: So we have A, B, or a mix of the two. Dylan, is there anything from C we must keep?
DYLAN: The question of who pays the price. One moment where someone talks straight to the audience.
LOWRI (timekeeper): We’re at 6 minutes on this item. That’s 1 over.
NIA: Let me sum up. Fist to five on this: the concept is Mair going back to the bridge, with flashbacks to 1961, and we look at Dylan’s direct address in Item 2. (Four hands: 5, 4, 5, 3.) Dylan, you’re on 3. What would get you higher?
DYLAN: If Osian gets the direct address, not a narrator. Then I’m a 4.
NIA: Agreed. Harri, can you minute that? Lowri, how long was that?
LOWRI: 7 minutes. We’re 2 over, so let’s keep Item 2 short.
Every role is working. The chair goes round, names the options and checks the challenger is on board instead of outvoting him. The challenger questions the idea, not the person, and offers something constructive. The note-taker builds on Lowri’s point to combine ideas. The timekeeper reports the time and suggests how to catch up. Evidences criteria 1, 2 and 3.
| Item | Options discussed | Decision | How we agreed | Time taken |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Concept | A (Lowri), B (Harri), C (Dylan), A and B mixed. | Our piece is about Mair going back to the bridge today, told through flashbacks to the last day in Llanfeuno in 1961. | Went round, combined A and B, fist to five (5, 4, 5, 4 after change). | 7 min (2 over) |
| 2. Style | Naturalism; physical theatre; epic theatre. | Naturalism for the family scenes, physical theatre for the water. Techniques: flashback and split stage. The chorus becomes the water. | Vote after going round: 3 for the mix, 1 for epic. Dylan agreed as long as Osian’s direct address stays. | 3 min |
| 3. Audience message | “Places matter”; “someone always pays the price”. | For audiences our age: when a community loses its home for other people’s good, the loss lasts a lifetime, so we should listen to the people who remember. | Each finished the sentence “At the end, the audience should feel...”; chair combined the two best. | 3 min |
| 4. Key moment 1: opening image | The crowd of visitors; Mair alone. | Today. Old Mair stands alone on the bridge in silence. The chorus lie on the floor as the cracked mud. | Chair’s summary, all agreed. | 5 min |
| Key moment 2: turning point | Leaving the house; the last chapel service. | 1961, after the last service. Mair’s father gives her his fishing rod: “We can’t take the river with us.” The chorus slowly rise as the water. | Vote, 4 to 0. | |
| Key moment 3: final image | Rain falling; the two Mairs. | Split stage: young Mair and old Mair reach out from each end of the bridge. Osian turns to the audience: “Next week it rains.” Blackout. | Combined Lowri’s and Dylan’s ideas. |
Parked ideas: visitors taking stones from the chapel as souvenirs (Dylan). Try it in rehearsal as a short physical theatre sequence.
Agreed by: N.J., H.P., L.E., D.M.
Short, clear minutes. Every item has the options, one decision and how it was reached, with a range of agreement tools. The 3 key moments are specific enough to rehearse. The group caught up after Item 1 ran over: 1 + 7 + 3 + 3 + 5 + 1 = 20 minutes. Evidences criteria 1 and 3.
| Item | What I did in my role (exact words) | Did it help the group move on? How? |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Concept | “Can I challenge A? If it’s all 1961... why would they care now?” | Yes. It made Lowri and Harri find the link to today, which led to the mix of A and B. |
| 2. Style | “What would the audience actually see when the valley floods?” | Yes. It gave us the idea of the chorus becoming the water. |
| 3. Audience message | “How would that feel for someone like Mair? Is ‘places matter’ too obvious?” | Partly. We made the message sharper, but it took a minute longer. |
| 4. Key moments | “What if the ending isn’t sad but a warning?” | Yes. It became Osian’s line “Next week it rains.” |
The challenger questions ideas in every item, thinks about the audience and about respect for Mair, and records the effect of each challenge honestly. Evidences criteria 2 and 4.
We had 3 options for the concept: Lowri wanted A, Harri wanted B and Dylan wanted C. I went round first so everyone spoke, then Harri suggested combining A and B, which gave us a link to today. The main disagreement was Dylan, who felt a 1961 scene would be “just a sad scene from a long time ago”. Instead of outvoting him, I used fist to five and asked, “What would get you higher?” His answer, giving Osian a line to the audience, made our ending stronger. My summaries (“So we agree that...”) stopped us going round in circles, but I let Item 1 run 2 minutes over. Next time I will sum up as soon as the timekeeper says 1 minute left.
About 120 words. The pupil names the options, 3 agreement strategies (going round, combining, fist to five), quotes real words, explains how a disagreement was settled so that everyone could accept the result, and sets a realistic target for the role. Evidences criteria 1, 3 and 5.