Worked example · PSE / Well-being · Year 7
DCF: Interacting and collaborating → Communication
A secure Year 7 response, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key for every step. The key ideas: in a message there is no tone of voice, so punctuation, capital letters and emoji carry the tone; a missing question mark turns a question into a decision, and caps lock or a row of exclamation marks reads as cross. Some things (a private worry, an argument, a stranger) should not be sorted out in a group chat at all. Where more than one answer is sensible, the box says what else to accept.
Marking the punctuation (Steps 3 and 6): check that each sentence starts with a capital letter and ends with a full stop, a question mark or one exclamation mark; that names, days and “I” have capitals; that there is a comma before a name when talking to someone; and that apostrophes are in the right place (I’m, let’s, it’s, don’t, he’s, Jac’s).
| Message no. | What the writer meant | How it was read (clue) | Why it went wrong |
|---|---|---|---|
| 9 (Tomos) | A calm question: who is bringing the tables? | As shouting at everyone. Clue: message 10, “no need to shout at us”. | Capitals: caps lock was on, and capitals read as shouting. There was no question mark either. |
| 13 (Osian) | He was asking whether they were selling at break. | As a decision. Clue: message 14, Ffion replies “Great, break it is!” | Punctuation: there was no question mark, so the question looked like a statement. |
| 19 (Ffion) | “OK, no problem.” She was not upset. | As annoyed. Clue: message 20, “are you annoyed with me”, and Ffion explains in message 28. | Punctuation: one word and a full stop looks short and cold. There were no friendly words or emoji to show her tone. |
| 22 (Tomos) | He was excited that the hall was booked. | As cross. Clue: message 23, Mia asks “Why are you cross, Tomos?” | Punctuation: 15 exclamation marks look angry or panicky. One in each sentence would have been enough. |
| 32 and 33 (Leah) | She thought the joke was funny and did not mean to hurt Mia. | As making fun of Mia and telling everyone her worry. Clue: message 34, “That was a private message.” 😞 | Sharing: Leah posted a private message without asking Mia. The “lol” and laughing emoji made it look like mocking. |
Also accept: 29 (Jac, no comma before “Mia”, so he seems to want to eat her; clue 30); 25 (Osian, timing: sent at 23:40 and woke Amira’s brother; clue 26); 2 (Ffion said “That’s everyone in now” but Dylan had been left out; clue 36); 5 or 6 (Amira’s blunt reply and Jac’s “fine whatever” read as rude and sulky; clue 8, where Amira apologises).
Each row names a real message, quotes the later message that proves how it was read, and names one cause from the list: capitals, punctuation, emoji, timing or sharing. The 5 rows cover 3 different causes, not the same one 5 times. Evidences criterion 1.
| Message as it was sent | Rewrite | |
|---|---|---|
| A | im starving lets eat Mia | I’m starving. Let’s eat, Mia! |
| B | WHO IS BRINGING THE TABLES | Who is bringing the tables? |
| C | so we’re selling at break | So we’re selling at break? |
| D | ok. | OK! |
| E | its on friday in the hall its going to be great | It’s on Friday in the hall. It’s going to be great! |
| F | the hall is booked!!!!!!!! dont be late!!!!!!! | The hall is booked! Don’t be late! |
| G | jacs mum can bring the tables in her van | Jac’s mum can bring the tables in her van. |
| H | is dylan in here hes not answering | Is Dylan in here? He’s not answering. |
Also accept: A “I’m starving! Let’s eat, Mia.” (the comma before Mia is the part that must be there); D “Ok!” (an added 🙂 is fine as a tone clue, but the words must stay the same); E a full stop instead of the final exclamation mark; F “Don’t be late.” Do not accept “its” without an apostrophe in E, or “Jacs” in G.
The writer’s words are kept and only punctuation and capitals change. Every sentence starts with a capital letter and ends with one mark; names and days have capitals (Mia, Dylan, Friday); there is a comma before the name in A; apostrophes show missing letters (I’m, let’s, we’re, it’s, don’t, he’s) and belonging (Jac’s mum). Questions B, C and H end with question marks, so they can no longer be read as orders or decisions. Evidences criterion 2.
| The words | Meaning 1 | Meaning 2 |
|---|---|---|
| thanks for helping Ffion | “Thanks for helping, Ffion.” Ffion is being thanked, because she helped. | “Thanks for helping Ffion.” Someone else is being thanked, because they helped Ffion. |
| Mia said Jac is late | Mia said, “Jac is late.” Mia is talking, and Jac is the one who is late. | “Mia,” said Jac, “is late.” Jac is talking, and Mia is the one who is late. |
| the pupils who brought cakes got a sticker | “The pupils who brought cakes got a sticker.” Only the pupils who brought cakes got a sticker; the others did not. | “The pupils, who brought cakes, got a sticker.” All the pupils brought cakes, and all of them got a sticker. |
Also accept for row 2: “Mia said Jac is late.” with no speech marks for meaning 1.
Each pair uses exactly the same words in the same order. The pupil shows how a comma before a name changes who is being spoken to, how speech marks change who is speaking, and how a pair of commas changes whether a sentence is about some pupils or all of them. Each meaning is explained in a full sentence. Evidences criteria 2 and 3.
| Situation | Best channel | Why? |
|---|---|---|
| 1. The stall now starts at 10:45, not 10:30. | Group chat | All 8 helpers need the same fact at the same time, and one clear message reaches everyone. A private message would mean 8 separate messages and someone could be missed. Face to face is slow if they are not all together. No adult is needed because nothing is wrong. |
| 2. You think Leah’s screenshot was unkind. | Face to face (or a private message) | Leah can hear your tone of voice, so she is less likely to feel attacked. Saying it in the group chat would embarrass her in front of everyone, which is the same mistake she made with Mia. A private message is fine if you cannot see her soon. |
| 3. Jac and Amira have sent 15 angry messages. | Face to face | Arguments get worse in text, because each message is read in the worst tone and everyone else has to watch. Someone could post once, calmly, “Let’s sort out prices at break tomorrow,” as Ffion did in message 40. Tell a teacher if it turns into name-calling. |
| 4. An unknown account asks where everyone lives. | Tell a teacher or parent | Nobody knows who this really is, and where you live is private information. Do not reply or argue with it in the chat. A trusted adult can help the admin remove and report the account, and can check that nobody has shared anything. |
| 5. Dylan was never added to the chat. | Face to face with Dylan, and tell the admin | Dylan cannot see the group chat, so he needs to be told in person (or by private message) what he has missed. Only Ffion, the admin, can add him, so she needs to know too. This is what Amira did in message 36. |
Each choice is explained by thinking about who needs to know, how private the information is and whether tone of voice will help. The pupil also says why the other channels are worse, and recognises that a stranger asking for personal information is a safety issue for a trusted adult, not something to handle alone. Evidences criterion 4.
| Rule (one sentence) | Why it matters | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Read your message again before you send it, and check that the punctuation shows what you mean. | Osian forgot a question mark, so his question in message 13 looked like a decision. Would you want your question to be read as a decision? |
| 2 | Don’t type in caps lock or put lots of exclamation marks at the end of a sentence. | Tomos was excited, but Leah and Mia thought he was cross (messages 9 and 22). One exclamation mark is enough. |
| 3 | We won’t send messages to the group after 9 o’clock at night. | Osian’s message at 23:40 woke Amira’s little brother (message 26). How would you feel if a message woke your family? |
| 4 | Never share a screenshot of someone’s private message without asking them first. | Mia told Leah a worry in private, and then the whole chat saw it (messages 32 to 34). If something in the chat worries you, tell a teacher or parent. |
| 5 | If you disagree with someone, say what you think politely and give a reason. | Amira’s blunt reply in message 5 upset Jac, but Ffion disagreed kindly in message 7 and gave a reason. Long arguments are better sorted out face to face. |
| 6 | The admin should check that everyone who is helping has been added to the chat. | Dylan missed 2 days of planning because nobody noticed he was not there (messages 36 to 38). |
Checklist: every sentence starts with a capital letter and ends with a full stop or a question mark; names have capitals (Osian, Tomos, Leah, Mia, Amira, Jac, Ffion, Dylan); the apostrophe in “Don’t” is underlined and correct (others: won’t, o’clock, someone’s, Osian’s, Amira’s); 2 questions are circled; there is no caps lock and no “!!!”.
There are 6 rules, each one sentence, and each “Why it matters” is linked to a numbered message from 7D’s chat. The rules cover 6 different things from the list (punctuation, tone, timing, screenshots, disagreeing and leaving people out), and rule 4 adds telling an adult, so the “at least 4” condition is met. Apostrophes for missing letters (don’t, won’t) and for belonging (someone’s, Osian’s) are correct, and both questions end with a question mark. Evidences criteria 2 and 5.
The mistakes Year 7 pupils most often miss when checking: “its” where “it’s” (it is) is needed; a lower-case “i” for “I”; no comma before a name (“Thanks Ffion”); “dont” or “cant” with no apostrophe; a question with no question mark; and a rule that runs on into 2 sentences joined by a comma. A dot in the margin is enough: the writer finds and fixes the mistake.