Worked example · Humanities · Year 5
DCF: Producing → Sourcing, searching and planning digital content
A secure Year 5 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key, and it uses the stimulus sheet “Roman Caerleon: pretend search results and web pages”. Headline answers: the strongest searches are caerleon amphitheatre seats, caerleon roman legion and caerleon roman museum free entry. Result 1 is an advert, Result 2 is check it, Result 4 is not useful, and Results 3, 5 and 6 are useful. The 5 facts are Isca, around AD 90, up to 6,000 people, about 5,000 soldiers and free entry. In Step 5, a and c are wrong, b is a legend, and d and e are facts.
Big question: What was Roman Caerleon like?
My 3 smaller questions: 1. When was the fortress built, and who lived there? 2. How many people could sit in the amphitheatre? 3. What Roman buildings can you still visit today?
Success criteria for my research:
The smaller questions break the big question into parts that a search can answer, and each success criterion is something the pupil can check off later. Any sensible questions are fine. Evidences criterion 1.
| Question | Search | Rank |
|---|---|---|
| A. How many people could sit in the Caerleon amphitheatre? | caerleon romans | 2 |
| romans | 3 | |
| caerleon amphitheatre seats | 1 | |
| B. Which legion was based at Caerleon? | caerleon roman legion | 1 |
| soldiers | 3 | |
| roman soldiers wales | 2 | |
| C. Is the Roman museum in Caerleon free to visit? | museum | 3 |
| caerleon roman museum free entry | 1 | |
| caerleon museum | 2 |
(a) romans is too general. It would find pages about Romans everywhere, like Rome or Roman food, not about Caerleon or the amphitheatre seats.
(b) caerleon roman baths visit
The strongest search in each group has the place name plus the exact topic words. Accept the middle and weakest swapped only if the pupil gives a sensible reason; the strongest choice should not change. Any search in (b) with “caerleon” and “baths” is strong. Evidences criterion 2.
| Result | Group | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Advert | It says Sponsored and it is a shop trying to sell helmets. |
| 2 | Check it | Anyone can post on a forum, there is no date, and “trust me lol” is not proof. |
| 3 | Useful | It is made by the museum in Caerleon, and it is about the fortress and the legion. |
| 4 | Not useful | It is about a family’s rainy weekend and chips, not facts about the Romans. |
| 5 | Useful | Cadw looks after historic places for the Welsh Government, and it is about the amphitheatre. |
| 6 | Useful | It is a history site made for children and it was updated this year. |
Bookmark it: Results 3 and 5.
Every group has a reason that uses the Who made it line or the purpose of the page. Accept Result 6 as “check it” if the pupil explains that it is not an official site; accept 6 as one of the bookmarks. Evidences criteria 3 and 5.
| Page | This page is mostly about… |
|---|---|
| A | The museum in Caerleon, the Roman fortress and the legion based there, and visiting for free. |
| B | The Roman amphitheatre: when it was built and how many people could sit in it. |
| C | Life for soldiers at Isca, the barracks and baths, and a legend about King Arthur. |
| Question | Answer | Page | Feature |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. What did the Romans call their fortress at Caerleon? | Isca | A | Caption (also Page C title or fact box) |
| 2. Around what year was the amphitheatre built? | Around AD 90 | B | Table (also main text) |
| 3. How many people could sit in the amphitheatre? | Up to 6,000 | B | Table |
| 4. About how many soldiers lived in the fortress? | About 5,000 | C | Fact box (also Page A main text) |
| 5. How much does it cost to visit the museum? | Nothing, it is free | A | Fact box |
Each gist line is one short sentence that sums up the whole page, not one detail copied out. Every fact is exact and the pupil names the feature that led to it. Accept any page and feature shown in brackets. This is literacy evidence for skimming and scanning. Evidences criterion 4.
| Sentence | Found in | Fact, wrong or legend? | Which page helped me check? |
|---|---|---|---|
| a. Julius Caesar built Caerleon. | Result 2 | Wrong | Pages A and C: it was founded around AD 75 as the base of the Second Augustan Legion. No good page says Julius Caesar. |
| b. King Arthur was crowned at Caerleon. | Result 2 | Legend | Page C, Legend corner: Geoffrey of Monmouth wrote it in the 12th century, and it is a legend, not history. |
| c. The amphitheatre had stone seats for 50,000 people. | Result 2 | Wrong | Page B: wooden benches for up to 6,000 people. |
| d. About 5,000 soldiers lived in the fortress. | Page A | Fact | Page C fact box says the same. |
| e. The museum is free to visit. | Page A | Fact | Result 3 says entry is free, and it is the museum’s own page. |
(f) No, I cannot trust it. Anyone can write on a forum, and castlefan_22 gives no proof. Also, all 3 of its claims disagree with the museum and Cadw pages, which are made by experts.
The pupil checks each claim against a named page and explains how, using who made the page and whether 2 pages agree. They see that b is not simply wrong: it is an old story that is still told. This is literacy evidence for judging reliability. Evidences criterion 5.
Fact file: Roman Caerleon
Around AD 75, the Romans started a fortress at Caerleon and called it Isca. It was home to about 5,000 soldiers from the Second Augustan Legion. Around AD 90 an amphitheatre was built, where up to 6,000 people sat on wooden benches. Today you can still see the baths and the barracks, and the National Roman Legion Museum is free to visit.
| Page | Page title | Who made it |
|---|---|---|
| A | National Roman Legion Museum, Caerleon | The National Roman Legion Museum |
| B | Caerleon Roman Amphitheatre | Cadw |
| C | Life in Roman Isca | History Hoppers (invented) |
4 sentences, each with correct facts from the pages, put together in the pupil’s own words rather than copied. No facts from the forum or the legend are used. The pages are listed with who made them. This is literacy evidence for using information from texts. Evidences criterion 6.
Another question: Where did the soldiers live? Search: caerleon roman barracks. (Any question with a search that includes Caerleon and the topic words.)
“Can I trust it?” card: Who made it? Are they trying to sell me something? Do other good pages say the same thing?
For a Year 3 pupil: Page C, because History Hoppers is made for children, with short sentences, a picture and a quick facts box.