Worked example · Art · Year 9

Sharpening sketchbook annotations: Nia’s cynefin pages

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Vocabulary, spelling, grammar

What this is

A secure Year 9 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key. Step 1: texture, watercolour, composition, perspective, collage, silhouette, technique, shadow, analyse, complementary colours. Step 2 grammar: “I made” (or “I did”), “it’s good”, “too busy”. Other precise words are fine in Step 2 as long as they fit the description of the study. Prepares pupils for annotation in GCSE Art and Design, AO3 and AO4.

Step 1: spell the language of art

 WrongCorrectStrategy
1texuretextureSyllables: tex-ture. Same ending as picture and mixture.
2watercolorwatercolourTwo words joined: water + colour. British spelling ends in -our.
3compasitioncompositionRoot word: compose. com-po-si-tion.
4perspectveperspectiveSyllables: per-spec-tive. Spect means look, as in inspect.
5colagecollageFrom French coller, to glue: double l, like the glue that holds it.
6silouettesilhouetteSilent h after the l. Ends in -ette.
7tecniquetechniqueTech, as in technology, then -nique, like unique.
8shaddowshadowOne d: sha-dow, like window.
9analiseanalyseSame letters as analysis. British spelling ends in -yse.
10complimentary colourscomplementary coloursComplement, with an e, like complete: the colours complete each other.

The difference: complementary colours are opposite each other on the colour wheel and make each other look stronger, while a complimentary ticket is free and a complimentary remark praises someone.

Every strategy is a real memory aid: syllables, a root word, a silent letter or a spelling rule, not “I just know it”. Evidences criteria 1 and 2.

Step 2: swap the vague words

Vague wordStudyPrecise replacement
nice1high contrast; a wide tonal range
the dark bits1the shadows under the door and in the keyhole
ok (the texture)1directional mark making follows the wood grain
messy2expressive; grey smudges where my hand pressed
cool (the lines)2bold, gestural lines
blend3bleed into each other wet-on-wet
look good together4complementary colours make each other look more saturated
a bit too busy4no negative space and no clear focal point

Grammar: “I made a print” (or “I did a print”); “it’s good” (it is); “too busy” (too means more than wanted).

Each replacement fits what the description says about that study; it is not a random word from the bank. Evidences criteria 2 and 3.

Step 3: redrafted annotations

Study 1: the shed door. I made a tonal study of the shed door in 2B and 6B pencil. I used directional mark making, with long wavy lines that follow the wood grain, to build up the texture of the planks. The 6B shadows under the door and in the keyhole against the almost white paint create high contrast, which shows the light source at the top right. Next I will refine the mid tones on the planks so the tonal range is more gradual.

Study 2: runner bean canes. I made a black monoprint of the runner bean canes by rolling ink onto a plastic sheet with a brayer and drawing on the back of the paper with a biro. The bold, gestural lines give the canes energy, and the grey smudges where my hand pressed add an expressive texture. The canes form a tall triangle that is the focal point of the composition. Next I will experiment with controlling the smudges by resting my hand on a scrap of paper.

Study 1 uses tonal study, directional mark making, texture, shadows, high contrast, light source, mid tones and tonal range. Study 2 uses monoprint, brayer, bold, gestural, expressive, texture, focal point, composition and experiment. Both follow What, How, Effect, Next, and the next steps are specific enough to act on. Evidences criteria 1, 3 and 4.

Step 4: annotation for Study 5

I made an A3 charcoal drawing of Taid’s wellington boots by the shed door. I smudged willow charcoal into an even mid tone for the background, used compressed charcoal for the darkest shadows inside the boots and lifted out highlights on the rubber with a putty rubber. The strong light source on the left creates a long cast shadow and a wide tonal range, and the off centre composition leaves negative space on the right for the shadow to fall into. The short, quick marks give the mud an expressive texture. Next I will develop this into a relief print, simplifying the tones into black and white shapes so the silhouette of the boots stays bold.

Uses willow charcoal, mid tone, compressed charcoal, shadows, highlights, putty rubber, light source, cast shadow, tonal range, off centre, composition, negative space, expressive, texture, relief print and silhouette, all spelled correctly. The next step links to Nia’s plan for a print and explains what must change. Evidences criteria 1, 3 and 4.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure