Worked example · Art · Year 7

Skimming and scanning a biography of Kyffin Williams

LNF: Literacy → Reading → Reading strategies

What this is

A secure Year 7 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key. Step 1 headings: 1 B, 2 D, 3 G, 4 A, 5 F, 6 E (C is not needed). Step 2: Llangefni; Royal Welch Fusiliers; Oxford; Highgate School, London; 1968; 1999; 1 September 2006. Step 5: A is least reliable, B most reliable. Steps 3 and 6 can be worded differently: accept any sensible inference that is backed by a quotation from the text.

Step 1: skim for the gist

(a) It is a biography of Sir Kyffin Williams, a Welsh painter from Anglesey, from his birth in 1918 to how he is remembered today.

(b) 1 B · 2 D · 3 G · 4 A · 5 F · 6 E. Heading C is not needed: the text never mentions painting European cities.

The gist names the person, what he did and the time span. Headings were matched from first sentences and key words such as “army”, “Highgate” and “knighted”. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 2: scan for detail

QuestionAnswerParagraph
1. Date born9 May 19181
2. Town bornLlangefni, Anglesey1
3. Regimentthe Royal Welch Fusiliers2
4. City of the Slade in the warOxford2
5. School where he taughtHighgate School, London3
6. Year he went to Patagonia19684
7. Year he was knighted19996
8. Date he died1 September 20066

Each answer is exact and the paragraph is given, so it can be checked. Question 4 needed care: London is mentioned first, but the Slade had moved to Oxford. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 3: close reading and inference

(a) I think he felt shocked and lost, because his plans had collapsed. The writer says “Then everything changed”, which shows how sudden it was, and he “had to leave the army”, so it was not his choice.

(b) I think he enjoyed it because the advice was so unexpected and it turned out to be right. The text calls it “surprising advice”, yet it led to a career that made him famous and “Sir Kyffin Williams”.

(c) First, it was a long way from home: Patagonia is “in Argentina, far from Wales”. Second, it was a big challenge at 50: he “stayed for 4 months” and “had to speak Welsh in public”.

(d) I think he meant that his paintings are Welsh in the way a language is: they show Welsh places and people, such as “the mountains of Eryri” and “farmers and their sheepdogs”. Being Welsh was part of how he saw everything he painted.

Each answer goes beyond what is written, then proves it with a short, accurate quotation in quotation marks. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 4: words from context

WordClue wordsMy meaningGlossary
palette knife“Instead of a brush”, “flat, bendy blade”a flat blade used to spread paintright
impasto“so thickly”, “stood up from the canvas in ridges”very thick paintright; also shows the tool marks
commission“paying him to paint portraits”paid work an artist is asked to doright
retrospective“every part of his career”, “look back”an exhibition looking back at an artist’s liferight

The meaning is built from the words around each term before the glossary is checked, and the pupil adds detail the glossary gives. Evidences criterion 4.

Step 5: how reliable is it?

A: 1. We do not know who wrote it, and it is opinion (“best Welsh artist EVER”). It has 3 facts wrong: he was born in Llangefni, not Cardiff, in 1918, not 1920, and he used a palette knife, not his fingers.

B: 5. It is by a named art historian, it lists its sources, and its facts (1918 to 2006, Highgate School, 29 years) match the biography.

C: 2. Its purpose is to sell holidays, so it exaggerates. “All of his greatest paintings” cannot be true: he also painted in Patagonia and lived in London for 29 years. It gives no evidence.

Each score is justified by author, purpose and checking against the biography. Evidences criterion 5.

Step 6: model summary (5 sentences)

Kyffin Williams was born in Llangefni, Anglesey, in 1918 and grew up near the sea. After he was diagnosed with epilepsy and had to leave the army, a doctor advised him to take up art, so he studied at the Slade. He then taught art at Highgate School in London for 29 years, and in 1968 he painted the Welsh community in Patagonia. Back on Anglesey, he painted mountains, the sea and farmers with thick paint and a palette knife. He was knighted in 1999, died in 2006, and is remembered at Oriel Kyffin Williams in Llangefni.

One sentence per stage, in the pupil’s own words, with more than 3 facts from Step 2. Evidences criterion 6.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure