Worked example · RE · Year 8
LNF: Literacy → Reading → Reading strategies
A secure Year 8 response, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key: every answer below comes from the stimulus sheet “A Pilgrim’s Guide to St Davids”. The key ideas: skimming gives the gist, scanning finds one fact using a key word, and close reading is needed for inference and for working out new words. Accept any sensible prediction in Step 1 and any accurate wording elsewhere; the fact answers in Step 3 must match the guide.
(a) It is an information guide, like a leaflet or a page from a visitor’s booklet. It is written for pilgrims and other visitors who are planning a trip to St Davids, because it has a map, an “at a glance” box and a section called Places to visit.
| Heading | I predict this section will tell me… | Right? |
|---|---|---|
| What is a pilgrimage? | what the word pilgrimage means | ✓ |
| Why St Davids became famous | that St Davids is famous because a saint is buried there | ✓ (partly: it is also about the Pope’s privilege) |
| The shrine of St David | what the shrine looks like | ✗ (it tells the history of the shrine) |
| A pilgrim speaks | a pilgrim describing their journey | ✓ |
The pupil uses the layout (map, fact box, Places to visit) to identify the type of text and its audience, makes a specific prediction for each heading and checks honestly after skimming, explaining where a prediction was only partly right. Evidences criterion 1.
(b) The guide explains who St David was, why Christians have made pilgrimages to St Davids for more than 900 years and what visitors can see there today.
One sentence that covers the whole guide, not just one section: the person (David), the reason (pilgrimage) and the places to visit. It matches the guide’s own purpose in its first paragraph, which a skimmer reads. Evidences criterion 2.
| Question | Key word | Answer | Where it is |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Welsh name for St Davids | Welsh | Tyddewi (“David’s house”) | Welcome; at a glance box |
| 2. Century David lived in | century | the 6th century | Who was St David? |
| 3. Date of St David’s Day | March | 1 March | Who was St David?; at a glance box; timeline |
| 4. The pope who gave the honour | Pope | Pope Callixtus II (in about 1123) | Why St Davids became famous; timeline |
| 5. Pilgrimages to St Davids worth 1 to Jerusalem | Jerusalem | 3 | Why St Davids became famous |
| 6. Year work began on the present cathedral | cathedral / begun | 1181 | at a glance box; timeline |
| 7. Year the stone shrine was built | shrine / 1275 | 1275 | The shrine of St David; timeline |
| 8. Who stripped the shrine in 1538 | 1538 | Bishop William Barlow | The shrine of St David |
| 9. Length of the Wales Coast Path | miles | 870 miles (about 1,400 kilometres) | The Wales Coast Path |
| 10. “Island of 20,000 saints” | island / 20,000 | Bardsey Island (Ynys Enlli) | Other journeys of faith |
Found in 5 minutes: 9 out of 10. Hardest: question 6, because I scanned for “cathedral”, which appears many times. Scanning for the number pattern (a year starting 11) or the word “begun” would have been quicker.
Each key word is short and distinctive: numbers, capital letters and unusual words (Jerusalem, miles, 1538) are fastest to spot. The pupil notices that a common word such as “cathedral” slows scanning down and suggests a better key word. All 10 answers are accurate. Evidences criterion 3.
(a) I think Mererid means that her journey had a religious purpose, while a holiday is for fun and rest. She says “every step felt like a prayer”, which suggests that the walking itself was a way of talking to God, not just a way of getting there. When she reached the shrine she “lit a candle” for her grandmother and “asked God to give her strength”, so she went to ask for help for someone she loves. She also says “My feet ached”; on a holiday people avoid hardship, but she accepted it as part of the journey. This fits the guide’s point that “the journey matters as much as arriving”.
(b) I can infer that people in the Middle Ages valued David’s relics very highly, as something holy and precious. His followers “treasured his bones” and kept them in a “decorated casket”, which suggests they thought the bones were worth as much as treasure. A special stone shrine was built “to hold the casket of relics” in 1275, and Bishop Barlow “stripped it of its jewels”, which shows that people had decorated it with jewels, perhaps given as gifts. Pilgrims “knelt in front of it to pray” “for centuries”, so it stayed important for hundreds of years, because people believed that being near a saint’s remains “brought them closer to God”.
Both answers go beyond what the guide states directly and back each point with short, accurate quotations. In (b) the pupil reads the word “jewels” as a clue: the guide never says pilgrims gave gifts, so the pupil uses “perhaps”, which is a careful way to infer. Also acceptable in (a): Mererid felt closer to God; a holiday is for herself, but this journey was for her grandmother. Evidences criterion 4.
| Word | Clue from the guide | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| penance | “They have done something wrong and are truly sorry, so they make a hard journey to show God their sorrow” | something difficult a person chooses to do to show they are sorry for doing wrong and to ask to be forgiven |
| relics | “his followers treasured his bones. These relics…” and “the remains of a saint” | the remains of a holy person, such as bones, kept and treated as holy |
| privilege | “a special honour, or privilege” | a special right or advantage given to one person or place and not to others |
| shrine | “built in 1275 to hold the casket of relics”, “pilgrims knelt in front of it to pray” | a holy place or structure that holds a saint’s relics, where people come to pray |
| creed | “keep your faith and your creed” | the set of beliefs a religion holds (it is paired with “faith”, so it must be about belief) |
Hardest: creed. The other 4 words are explained in the sentence before or after them, but creed only has the word “faith” next to it, so I had to guess from that one clue.
The pupil copies the exact words that act as a clue, including clues that come after the word (penance, relics), and explains each meaning in their own words. For “creed” the pupil uses the pairing with “faith” as the clue. Accept “beliefs” or “what Christians believe” for creed. Evidences criterion 5.
(a) Plan: David, patron saint of Wales, founded his monastery there · his relics and shrine are there · to pray, give thanks, ask for healing or help, or do penance · Pope: 2 pilgrimages there = 1 to Rome, and Rome was far away.
(b) Christians go to St Davids because David, the patron saint of Wales, founded his monastery there and his shrine is in the cathedral. Pilgrims pray, give thanks, ask God for healing or help, or show they are sorry. In the Middle Ages, 2 pilgrimages there equalled 1 to Rome, so crowds came.
Number of words: 52
The summary keeps within 45 to 55 words and answers the question asked: it gives reasons only, not dates or descriptions of the coast path. It turns the guide’s long explanation of penance into 4 words (“show they are sorry”) and covers 3 kinds of reason: the saint and his shrine, personal prayer, and the medieval privilege. Also acceptable: walking the journey as a picture of faith, or visiting St Non’s holy well. Evidences criterion 6.
| Task | Strategy | Why it suited this task |
|---|---|---|
| Saying what the guide is for | Skimming | I needed the gist of the whole guide, not details, and the headings and first sentences gave me that in 2 minutes. |
| Answering the 10 fact questions | Scanning | Each answer was one name, date or number, so I only needed to find one key word and read the sentence round it. |
| Explaining what Mererid meant | Close reading | Her meaning is not said directly, so I had to read every word slowly and think about phrases such as “every step felt like a prayer”. |
| Writing the summary | Scanning, then close reading | I scanned for the word “pilgrim” to find the reasons, then read those parts closely to put them in my own words. |
In Science, scanning a textbook page for the word “photosynthesis” would help me find a definition without reading the whole chapter.
The pupil matches each task to a strategy and gives a reason linked to the kind of information needed (gist, one fact, hidden meaning). Recognising that a summary uses two strategies together shows secure understanding. Evidences criterion 7.