Worked example · English · Year 8

Spending the library budget

LNF: Numeracy → Understanding the number system helps us to represent and compare relationships between numbers and quantities → Financial literacy

What this is

A secure Year 8 response and a full answer key, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. Key answers: top 5 paperbacks 3, 1, 2, 4, 7; £6.99 + £5.99 = £12.98; Order 1 costs £35.95 at Glan yr Afon and £46.35 at Silff Direct; Order 2 costs £48.96 at Glan yr Afon and £42.30 at Silff Direct; money for paperbacks £97.70; best paperback order £95.86, leaving £1.84. Show this after pupils have tried the tasks themselves.

Step 1: blurbs and votes

SlipBookWords from the blurb that prove it
A4, The Worst Week of Owain Parry“A book that will make you laugh out loud on the bus.”
B7, The Quarry at Nant Oer“A ghost story that is creepy, not gory: perfect for reading with the light on.”
C5, Wild Weather Explained“Find out how weather works”, and it asks about storms and rain.
D6, Nightmoth“A story told mostly in pictures, with very few words on each page.”

(b) 3 (16 votes), 1 (14), 2 (11), 4 (10), 7 (9).

(c) 14 + 11 + 16 + 10 + 5 + 8 + 9 + 2 + 4 + 7 + 1 + 3 = 90. Yes.

Each match is backed by the exact words from the blurb. Also accept book 2 (“sport, funny”) or book 11 (“funny poems”) for slip A if the pupil quotes the blurb. In (b) the pupil leaves out book 6, Nightmoth, because it is a hardback, even though it has 8 votes. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 2: money notation

Her noteWritten correctly
(a)£7.99p£7.99 (or 799p)
(b)£4.5£4.50
(c)599p, so £59.90599p = £5.99
(d)£10.0£10.00
(e)£.75£0.75 (or 75p)
(f)2998£29.98 (2 × £14.99)

(g) £6.99 + £5.99 is 1p less than £7 and 1p less than £6. £7 + £6 = £13, then £13.00 − 2p = £12.98.

The pupil uses either £ or p, never both, always writes 2 digits of pence, and rounds to whole pounds to add in their head, then adjusts. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 3: which bookseller is cheaper?

(a) Order 1

Siop Lyfrau Glan yr Afon£Silff Direct£
3 Dragon Postbag, pay for 2: 2 × 7.9915.983 × 7.4522.35
3 Lighthouse, pay for 2: 2 × 6.9913.983 × 6.2518.75
1 Goalkeeper Gruff5.991 × 5.405.40
Total before discount46.50
10% of 46.504.65
46.50 − 4.6541.85
41.85 + 4.50 delivery46.35
Total to pay35.95Total to pay46.35

Glan yr Afon is cheaper for Order 1 by £46.35 − £35.95 = £10.40.

(b) Order 2

Siop Lyfrau Glan yr Afon£Silff Direct£
12.99 + 9.99 + 14.99 + 10.9948.9611.25 + 8.50 + 12.75 + 9.5042.00
10% of 42.004.20
42.00 − 4.2037.80
37.80 + 4.50 delivery42.30
Total to pay48.96Total to pay42.30

Silff Direct is cheaper for Order 2 by £48.96 − £42.30 = £6.66.

(c) Silff Direct is cheaper book by book, but it charges £4.50 delivery and has no 3 for 2 offer. When you buy 3 copies of the same paperback, Glan yr Afon gives you 1 free, which saves far more than Silff’s 10%. For hardbacks there is no 3 for 2, so Silff’s lower prices and 10% off win, even after delivery.

The pupil follows the order the offer asks for: 10% off first, then delivery. 10% is found by dividing by 10. Without the 3 for 2 offer, Order 1 would cost £50.93 at Glan yr Afon, so the offer is what makes it better value. Evidences criteria 3 and 4.

Step 4: the real order

(a) Hardbacks from Silff Direct (£42.30). Paperbacks from Glan yr Afon. £150.00 − £42.30 − £10.00 = £97.70.

(b) 3 copies of all 8 paperbacks would cost £105.84, which is £8.14 too much. Poems for Shouting had only 1 vote, so I left it out.

BookCopiesCost of this row (£)Running total (£)Money left (£)
Start0.0097.70
3 The Dragon Postbag32 × 7.99 = 15.9815.9881.72
1 The Lighthouse at Ynys Wen32 × 6.99 = 13.9829.9667.74
2 Goalkeeper Gruff32 × 5.99 = 11.9841.9455.76
4 The Worst Week of Owain Parry32 × 6.49 = 12.9854.9242.78
7 The Quarry at Nant Oer32 × 6.99 = 13.9868.9028.80
10 Orbit Station Saith32 × 7.49 = 14.9883.8813.82
9 Run, Alys, Run32 × 5.99 = 11.9895.861.84

(c) £42.30 + £95.86 + £10.00 = £148.16. That is less than £150.00, with £1.84 left over. That buys 21 paperbacks and 4 hardbacks: 25 books.

Each running total is the one above plus the row cost, and each “money left” is £97.70 minus the running total, so the 2 columns always add up to £97.70: a quick check. £95.86 is the most that can be spent within the rules. Other orders are correct if the adding is right and the total stays at or below £97.70. Evidences criterion 5.

Step 5: recommendation

Dear Mrs Prydderch,

I recommend buying the 4 hardbacks from Silff Direct for £42.30, because even with the £4.50 delivery they are £6.66 cheaper than at Glan yr Afon. For the paperbacks, Glan yr Afon is much better value because its 3 for 2 offer gives a free copy: Order 1 was £10.40 cheaper there. I suggest 3 copies each of the 7 most popular paperbacks, including The Dragon Postbag, which had 16 votes. This costs £95.86. I left out Poems for Shouting because only 1 pupil voted for it. The total is £148.16 with covers, which leaves £1.84.

Yours sincerely,
Rhian

96 words in the body. The message is polite and clear, every amount is written correctly, and each choice has a reason: a price comparison, a vote count or a rule. Evidences criteria 2, 4 and 6.

If you finish early: answers

2 copies of a ★ paperback cost the same as 3. For example, 2 copies of Goalkeeper Gruff cost 2 × £5.99 = £11.98, and 3 copies also cost £11.98 because the third is free. Buying 2 wastes a free book.

The model paperback order at Silff Direct: 3 × (7.45 + 6.25 + 5.40 + 5.85 + 6.25 + 6.75 + 5.40) = £130.05; 10% off is £13.01 (to the nearest penny), leaving £117.04; plus £4.50 delivery = £121.54. Glan yr Afon saves £121.54 − £95.86 = £25.68. Accept answers that differ by 1p because of rounding.

Blurb: any 40 to 50 words that says who the main character is, what the problem is, and why a Year 7 pupil would want to read it.

Why this response is secure