Worked example · RE · Year 7

Symmetry in Islamic geometric patterns

LNF: Numeracy → Learning about geometry helps us understand shape, space and position, and learning about measurement helps us quantify in the real world → Shape and space

What this is

A secure Year 7 response, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key. The key facts: a regular polygon with n sides has n lines of symmetry and order of rotational symmetry n. The cards have: A 8 lines, order 8; B 6 lines, order 6; C 6 lines, order 6; D 4 lines, order 4; E 0 lines, order 1. Triangles (60°), squares (90°) and hexagons (120°) tessellate because 360 ÷ 60 = 6, 360 ÷ 90 = 4 and 360 ÷ 120 = 3 are whole numbers. In the diagrams below, black is what was already printed and orange is what the pupil drew. Accept small drawing errors of up to about half a square.

Step 2: why patterns?

QuestionAnswer
a. 3 kinds of designGeometric patterns, calligraphy (Arabic writing, often words from the Qur’an) and arabesque (flowing, plant-like designs).
b. Why no pictures of living beingsIt helps people keep their attention on Allah during prayer. (Also accept: so that nothing in the mosque could be mistaken for something to worship.)
c. TawhidThe belief that God is one.
d. The infiniteA repeating pattern could carry on forever past the edge of the wall, which can remind people that Allah is infinite.

Answers come from the stimulus and use cautious wording (“many Muslims”, “often”) because practice varies. These answers prepare for the explanation in Step 8. Evidences criterion 6.

Step 3: the polygons

PolygonSidesRegular?Lines of symmetryOrder of rotational symmetry
Equilateral triangle3Yes33
Square4Yes44
Regular hexagon6Yes66
Irregular hexagon6No01

(a) For a regular polygon, the number of sides, the number of lines of symmetry and the order of rotational symmetry are all the same number.

(b) It is a square, just turned through 45°. It has 4 equal sides and 4 right angles. Turning a shape does not change what it is.

Every polygon is named correctly with the right number of sides, and the pupil spots the rule for regular polygons. The irregular hexagon shows that 6 sides alone do not give symmetry: sides and angles must also be equal. In (b) the pupil uses properties, not looks, to name the shape. Evidences criteria 1 and 2.

Step 4: the symmetry of each card

(a) Lines of symmetry drawn on Card B and Card D (dashed red lines):

Card B: 6 lines. 3 go through opposite star points and 3 go through the gaps between points.

Card D: 4 lines. 1 vertical, 1 horizontal and 2 diagonals, corner to corner.

(b)

CardLines of symmetryOrder of rotational symmetry
A: 8-point star88
B: 6-point star66
C: hexagon patch66
D: square tile44
E: broken tile01

(c) Order 1 means Card E only looks exactly the same when it has been turned all the way round, through 360°, back to where it started. So it has no rotational symmetry.

Every line of symmetry is found, including the ones through the gaps between star points, which pupils often miss. Card A turns onto itself every 45° (360 ÷ 8), Card B and Card C every 60° (360 ÷ 6) and Card D every 90° (360 ÷ 4). Card D has only 4 lines, not 8, because the square tile and its 4 stars do not match after a 45° turn. Card C has 6 lines because the 6 light hexagons sit evenly around the dark one. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 5: tessellation

Regular polygonInterior angle360 ÷ interior angleWhole number?Tessellates on its own?
Equilateral triangle60°6YesYes
Square90°4YesYes
Regular hexagon120° (2 × 60°)3YesYes
Regular pentagon108°3.33 (3 remainder 36)NoNo
Regular octagon135°2.67 (2 remainder 90)NoNo

(a) 3 hexagons meet at each corner inside the patch: 120° + 120° + 120° = 360°, so there is no gap and no overlap.

(b) 135° + 135° = 270°, so the gap is 360° − 270° = 90°. A square fills it exactly, because its angles are 90°. Octagons and squares together make a pattern often seen in tiling.

The pupil works out the interior angles from the hints (180° ÷ 3 = 60°; 2 × 60° = 120°) and links tessellation to 360°. For pentagons, 3 fit with a 36° gap (3 × 108° = 324°) and 4 would overlap (432°). Accept “between 3 and 4” or “between 2 and 3” for the last 2 rows. Evidences criteria 1 and 3.

Step 6: completing the patterns

Pattern 1 completed:

mirror line

Pattern 2 completed:

(a) The shaded square is 4 squares from the mirror line (its far side is 5 squares away). Its reflection goes 4 squares to the right of the mirror line, in the top row: the second square in from the right-hand edge.

(b) Pattern 1 has 1 line of symmetry and order of rotational symmetry 1. The lines on their own would also match across a horizontal line through the middle, but the shaded squares are only in the top row, so the dashed line is the only line of symmetry.

(c) Pattern 2 has 4 lines of symmetry (the 2 dashed lines and the 2 diagonals) and order of rotational symmetry 4. It is an 8-point star with a square turned 45° inside it and a shaded square in every corner.

Every reflected point is the same distance from the mirror line as the original: in Pattern 1 the point 4 squares left of the mirror line, 2 squares down, is matched by one 4 squares right, 2 squares down. The pupil remembers to reflect the shading as well as the lines and checks the whole pattern, colours included, before counting lines of symmetry. Evidences criteria 2 and 4.

Step 7: the 8-point star

A B C D O E F G H

OA is 3 squares across and 3 squares down, so OA = √(3² + 3²) = 4.24 squares (pupils only need to measure it: “just over 4 squares”). E, F, G and H are each 4.24 squares from O along the grid lines through O.

(a) The star has 8 points, 8 lines of symmetry and order of rotational symmetry 8. It looks the same after every turn of 45°.

(b) The shape in the middle has 8 equal sides: it is a regular octagon.

Both squares are the same size, so all 8 points of the star are the same length, just like Card A. Lines are drawn with a ruler and E, F, G and H are measured, not guessed. Evidences criteria 1, 2 and 5.

Step 8: explanation

Many Muslims decorate mosques with geometric patterns instead of pictures of living beings, and a whole pattern can grow by reflection and rotation from one simple shape, which is often linked to tawhid, the belief that God is one. Because polygons such as hexagons tessellate with no gaps, the pattern could repeat forever past the edge of the wall, which can remind people that Allah is infinite.

Exactly 2 sentences. Maths words used correctly: reflection, rotation, polygons, tessellate. Both beliefs are named and linked to a feature of the pattern, not just listed. Cautious wording (“many Muslims”, “often linked”, “can remind”). Evidences criterion 6.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure