Worked example · Maths · Year 9

Testing claims on the Caerwenlli Maths board

LNF: Numeracy → Developing mathematical proficiency → Logical reasoning

What this is

A complete, secure Year 9 answer, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key. Headline answers: claims 1, 3 and 6 are always true; claim 5 is never true; claims 2, 4, 7 and 8 are sometimes true. Lowri’s claim fails at n = 40: 1,600 + 40 + 41 = 1,681 = 41 × 41. The most common mistake is “proving” an always-true claim by listing examples.

Step 1: the language of proof

QuestionAnswer
Example and proofAn example shows one case works. A proof shows every case works.
Counterexamples neededJust 1.
Even and odd2n and 2n + 1
3 consecutive numbersn, n + 1, n + 2

Step 2: always, sometimes or never?

No.A, S or NEvidence
1A3 + 5 = 8, 7 + 11 = 18. Examples only support it; the proof is in Step 3.
2STrue: 6 × 3 = 18. Counterexample: 6 × 0.5 = 3, which is smaller. Also 6 × 1 = 6 (the same) and 6 × −2 = −12.
3A4 + 5 + 6 = 15 = 3 × 5. Proof in Step 3.
5NTwo obtuse angles add up to more than 180°, which leaves nothing for the third angle. Reason in Step 3.
6AA square has 4 × 90° = 360°. Proof in Step 3.
7STrue: 32 = 9. Counterexample: 0.52 = 0.25, which is smaller. 12 = 1 stays the same.
8STrue: 24 = 4 × 6. Counterexample: 14 ÷ 4 = 3.5, so 14 is not in the 4 times table.

Every “sometimes” has one example and one counterexample. Every “always” is marked as needing a proof, not just examples. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 3: prove it

(a)

Let the two odd numbers be 2a + 1 and 2b + 1. Their sum is (2a + 1) + (2b + 1) = 2a + 2b + 2 = 2(a + b + 1) This is 2 × a whole number, so the sum is always even.

(b) n + (n + 1) + (n + 2) = 3n + 3 = 3(n + 1). Because n + 1 is a whole number, the sum is 3 × a whole number, so it is always a multiple of 3. (It is also 3 times the middle number.)

(c) Draw any quadrilateral ABCD and join A to C with a diagonal. This splits it into two triangles, ABC and ACD. The angles in each triangle add up to 180°. Together the angles of the two triangles make up exactly the four angles of the quadrilateral. So the angles of the quadrilateral add up to 180° + 180° = 360°, whatever its shape.

(d) An obtuse angle is more than 90°. So two obtuse angles add up to more than 90° + 90° = 180°. The angles in a triangle add up to exactly 180°, so the third angle would have to be less than 0°. That is impossible, so a triangle can never have two obtuse angles.

Each proof uses letters for “any number” or a general diagram, so it covers every case. Each ends with a sentence that links back to the claim. Evidences criteria 1, 3 and 4.

Step 4: Lowri’s claim

(a) 52 + 5 + 41 = 25 + 5 + 41 = 71. Lowri is right for n = 5.

(b) 402 + 40 + 41 = 1,600 + 40 + 41 = 1,681.

(c) 41 × 41 = 40 × 41 + 41 = 1,640 + 41 = 1,681. So 1,681 has a factor of 41 and is not prime.

(d) Claim 4 is sometimes true. “Lowri, your 5 results are correct, and in fact the rule gives a prime for every n from 0 to 39. But 5 examples cannot prove something works for every number. When n = 40 the answer is 1,681, which is 41 × 41, so it is not prime. One counterexample is enough to show the claim is not always true.”

The pupil verifies Lowri’s own example before testing a new case, and uses the word counterexample correctly. Checking 41 × 41 by a second method confirms the result. Evidences criteria 3 and 4.

Step 5: your own conjecture (model)

Conjecture: “An odd number times an odd number is always odd.” Tests: 3 × 5 = 15, 7 × 9 = 63, 1 × 11 = 11. All odd. Proof: (2a + 1)(2b + 1) = 4ab + 2a + 2b + 1 = 2(2ab + a + b) + 1, which is 1 more than an even number, so it is always odd.

The pupil tests the conjecture, then moves from examples to a proof. Evidences criterion 1.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure