Worked example · Humanities · Year 4

Using because and so to explain the Rhondda coal boom

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Connectives and syntax

What this is

A secure Year 4 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key. Step 1 matches: A2, B5, C4, D1, E3. In Step 2, so puts the cause first and because puts the effect first, so the halves swap places. In Step 4 every sentence has a comma after the opening part. The Step 6 paragraph uses 4 different connectives: so, and, when, because. Other wording is fine if the facts match the information text and the sentences make sense.

Step 1: match causes to effects

CauseABCDE
Effect number25413

A: lots of steam coal → 2: pits were dug. B: the pits needed workers → 5: families moved to find work. C: families moved in → 4: the number of people grew. D: families needed homes → 1: terraced houses were built. E: trains took coal to the docks → 3: ships carried it around the world.

Every cause is matched to the thing it made happen. Notice the chain: the effect of B is the cause in C. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 2: join with because and so

(a) The pits needed lots of workers, so thousands of families moved to the Rhondda to find work.
Thousands of families moved to the Rhondda to find work because the pits needed lots of workers.

(b) Thousands of families moved to the Rhondda, so the number of people there grew very fast.
The number of people in the Rhondda grew very fast because thousands of families moved there.

(c) The families needed homes, so rows of terraced houses were built along the valley sides.
Rows of terraced houses were built along the valley sides because the families needed homes.

(d) With so, the cause comes first and the effect comes second. With because, the effect comes first and the cause comes second. The two halves swap places, but the meaning stays the same.

Each pair is joined both ways into one sentence with two parts, and there is a comma before so. Part (d) explains that the order flips. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 3: after and when

(a) Thousands of families moved to the Rhondda after the deep pits were dug.

(b) Ships carried the coal around the world when the trains brought it to the docks at Cardiff and Barry.

(c) The families needed somewhere to live when they arrived in the Rhondda.

(d) Visitors can go underground when they go to Big Pit in Blaenavon.

Each ending uses a fact from the information text and shows which thing happened first. When the connective is in the middle of the sentence, no comma is needed. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 4: start your sentences in different ways

(a) After the pits were dug, families moved to the Rhondda.

(b) When the trains reached the docks, ships carried the coal around the world.

(c) In 1851, under 1,000 people lived in the Rhondda.

(d) By 1911, over 150,000 people lived in the Rhondda.

(e) Because the families needed homes, terraced houses were built.

The opening part is moved to the front each time, and the comma goes straight after it, before the main part of the sentence. Every sentence starts with a capital letter and ends with a full stop. Evidences criterion 4.

Step 5: make a dull sentence exciting

(a) The tired young miners walked slowly to the deep, dark pit.

(b) The long, heavy train slowly took the coal to the busy docks.

(a) adds 4 adjectives (tired, young, deep, dark) and 1 adverb (slowly). (b) adds 3 adjectives (long, heavy, busy) and 1 adverb (slowly). The adjectives sit before the nouns they describe, and there is a comma between deep, dark and long, heavy. Evidences criterion 5.

Step 6: write your paragraph

In 1851, under 1,000 people lived in the Rhondda. There was lots of high quality steam coal under the ground, so deep pits were dug from the 1850s onwards. The pits needed lots of workers, so thousands of families moved there from other parts of Wales, from England and from further away. When the families arrived, rows of terraced houses were built along the steep valley sides. Because so many people came to work in the pits, over 150,000 people lived in the Rhondda by 1911.

How many different connectives did you use? 4 (so, and, when, because)

5 sentences that answer the question “why did the Rhondda grow?” with facts from the text. It uses 4 different connectives, all underlined. 3 sentences start in different ways (In 1851, When and Because), each with a comma after the opening part. Evidences criteria 2, 4 and 6.

If you finish early: answers

Joining with but: The pits gave thousands of people jobs, but mining was dangerous.

Starting with When: When visitors go to Big Pit in Blaenavon, they can go underground and see what a coal mine was like.

Drawing: any row of houses on a slope, labelled with 2 adjectives, for example steep hill and long row.

Why this response is secure