Worked example · History · Year 9
LNF: Numeracy → Learning that statistics represent data and that probability models chance helps us make informed inferences and decisions → Interpreting data
A secure Year 9 response, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key. The key idea: a percentage depends on two numbers, the speakers and the whole population. From 1901 to 1911 the speakers grew by 5.1% but the population aged 3 and over grew by 20.5%, so the percentage fell even though the number rose. A fall from 49.9% to 17.8% is 32.1 percentage points, which is a 64.3% fall in the percentage. Pupils who work from unrounded figures may get answers a few hundred people different in Steps 4 and 5; accept these.
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| a. Welsh speakers in 1931 | 909,000 people |
| b. 1981 from the graph | About 19% (the point is just under the 20% line). The table says 18.9%, so the reading is right. |
| c. First census below 30% (graph) | 1951 (28.9%) |
| d. Highest number | 1911, 977,000 people |
| e. Highest percentage | 1901, 49.9% |
| f. Censuses where the number went up | 1911, 1991 and 2001 |
| g. Percentage went up as well | 2001 only (18.7% to 20.8%) |
Values come from the right row and column, the graph is read against its gridlines (each small square is 2%) and checked against the table, and every answer has a unit. Parts d and e already show that the highest number and the highest percentage were in different years. Evidences criterion 1.
| From | To | Change in number of speakers | Change in percentage (percentage points) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2011 | 2021 | −24,000 | −1.2 |
| 1901 | 1911 | 977,000 − 930,000 = +47,000 | 43.5 − 49.9 = −6.4 |
| 1911 | 1921 | 922,000 − 977,000 = −55,000 | 37.1 − 43.5 = −6.4 |
| 1981 | 1991 | 508,000 − 504,000 = +4,000 | 18.7 − 18.9 = −0.2 |
| 1991 | 2001 | 582,000 − 508,000 = +74,000 | 20.8 − 18.7 = +2.1 |
| 2001 | 2011 | 562,000 − 582,000 = −20,000 | 19.0 − 20.8 = −1.8 |
(a) 1901 to 1911 (+47,000 but −6.4 points) and 1981 to 1991 (+4,000 but −0.2 points).
(b) Both decades show a fall of 6.4 percentage points. The numbers changed differently: from 1901 to 1911 the number rose by 47,000, but from 1911 to 1921 it fell by 55,000. The same fall in the percentage can hide very different changes in the number.
The pupil always subtracts earlier from later, so the sign shows the direction, and uses “percentage points” for the difference between 2 percentages. Spotting both pairs where the number and the percentage moved in opposite directions sets up Step 4. Evidences criteria 1 and 2.
| Census | Welsh speakers | Percentage | Everyone aged 3 and over | Could not speak Welsh |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1901 | 930,000 | 49.9% | 1,864,000 | 934,000 |
| 1911 | 977,000 | 43.5% | 2,246,000 | 1,269,000 |
(a) 977,000 ÷ 43.5 × 100 = 2,245,977, which is 2,246,000 to the nearest thousand. 2,246,000 − 977,000 = 1,269,000 could not speak Welsh. (1901: 930,000 ÷ 49.9 × 100 = 1,863,727, so 1,864,000; 1,864,000 − 930,000 = 934,000.)
(b) The population aged 3 and over grew by 2,246,000 − 1,864,000 = 382,000. Welsh speakers grew by only 47,000.
(c) Welsh speakers: 47,000 ÷ 930,000 × 100 = 5.05... = 5.1%. Population aged 3 and over: 382,000 ÷ 1,864,000 × 100 = 20.49... = 20.5%.
(d) The number of Welsh speakers grew by 5.1%, but the whole population grew by 20.5%, about 4 times as fast, so Welsh speakers became a smaller share of a much bigger population. The people who could not speak Welsh grew by 1,269,000 − 934,000 = 335,000, so most of the extra people did not speak Welsh. This fits the context notes: the coal industry was booming in the south Wales valleys and many newcomers came from England and elsewhere, and in the industrial towns English became the language of work and the street.
The pupil finds the hidden whole from a part and a percentage, rounds sensibly, and compares the two growth rates as percentages, not just as counts. The explanation links the numbers (335,000 of the 382,000 extra people, about 9 in 10, could not speak Welsh) to a real historical cause. Evidences criteria 3 and 5.
(a) 1991: 508,000 ÷ 18.7 × 100 = 2,716,578, so 2,717,000. 2001: 582,000 ÷ 20.8 × 100 = 2,798,077, so 2,798,000.
(b) Welsh speakers: 74,000 ÷ 508,000 × 100 = 14.56... = 14.6%. Population aged 3 and over: 81,000 ÷ 2,717,000 × 100 = 2.98... = 3.0%. This time the Welsh speakers grew much faster than the population, so the percentage went up (by 2.1 percentage points). It is the opposite of 1901 to 1911.
(c) Reasons for the rise: by the end of the 1990s all pupils in Wales studied Welsh at school up to 16, so many young people learned Welsh; Welsh-medium schools had been growing since the first council one opened in 1947. (Also acceptable: S4C from 1982 and the Welsh Language Act 1993 gave Welsh a bigger place in public life.) Be careful: the census question changed from whether people do speak Welsh (1991) to whether they can speak Welsh (2001). Some people, including school pupils, who can speak some Welsh but do not use it may have said yes in 2001 but no in 1991, so part of the rise may come from the new wording, not from more speakers.
The pupil repeats the method from Step 4 without help, compares two growth rates to explain why the percentage rose, links the rise to events in the context notes and questions how reliable the source is. Evidences criteria 3 and 5.
(a) 49.9 − 17.8 = 32.1 percentage points.
(b) 32.1 ÷ 49.9 × 100 = 64.32... = 64.3%. The percentage in 2021 is less than half of what it was in 1901: it fell by almost two thirds.
(c) 930,000 − 538,000 = 392,000. 392,000 ÷ 930,000 × 100 = 42.15... = a fall of 42.2%.
| Headline | Accurate? Why? |
|---|---|
| A: “Welsh speakers down by 32% since 1901” | Not accurate. 32 is the fall in percentage points (32.1), not per cent. The number of speakers fell by 42.2%, and the percentage fell by 64.3%. “Down by 32%” makes the fall sound smaller than either of these. |
| B: “Share of people who speak Welsh has fallen by almost two thirds since 1901” | Accurate. The share fell by 64.3% of its 1901 value, and two thirds is 66.7%, so “almost two thirds” is fair. |
My rewritten headline: “Share of Welsh speakers down 32 percentage points since 1901” (also acceptable: “Number of Welsh speakers down by 42% since 1901”).
The pupil uses percentage points for the gap between two percentages and per cent for a change compared with the starting value, and shows how mixing them up changes the message. Evidences criteria 2 and 4.
I partly agree that the Welsh language was strongest in 1911. If “strongest” means the most speakers, the claim is right: 977,000 people aged 3 and over could speak Welsh in 1911, more than in any other census, and 47,000 more than in 1901. However, if “strongest” means the share of the population, 1901 was stronger, because 49.9% could speak Welsh then compared with 43.5% in 1911, a fall of 6.4 percentage points. The number rose only because the population was growing fast: it grew by 20.5% from 1901 to 1911 while Welsh speakers grew by only 5.1%, as many English-speaking people moved to the coal valleys. Almost 9 in every 10 of the extra people (335,000 out of 382,000) could not speak Welsh, so Welsh was already losing ground in the places that were growing fastest. The census also cannot tell us how well or how often people spoke Welsh, so it only measures one kind of strength. Overall, 1911 was the peak for the number of speakers, but the percentage shows the language was already declining, so I think 1901 has a better claim to be the year Welsh was strongest.
The paragraph defines “strongest” in 2 ways, uses the number as evidence for and the percentage as evidence against, includes more than 3 accurate figures, uses “percentage points” correctly, explains the difference with a historical cause, notes a limit of the census, and ends with a clear, justified conclusion. Evidences criteria 4, 5 and 6.