Worked example · RE · Year 9
LNF: Numeracy → Learning about geometry helps us understand shape, space and position, and learning about measurement helps us quantify in the real world → Measurement
A secure Year 9 response, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key. The key ideas: there are 60 minutes in an hour, so pupils must count back to the hour rather than use column subtraction (16:14 take away 18 minutes is 15:56, not 15:96 or 16:−4). Shabbat lasts just over 24 hours: 24 h 58 min in December and 25 h 14 min in June. Sunset is earliest at 16:04 (10 December) and latest at 21:34 (25 June), a difference of 5 h 30 min on the clock, but 1 hour of that is caused by British Summer Time. Accept graph points within about half a square of the correct place.
| Friday | Sunset | Candle-lighting (24-hour clock) | Candle-lighting (12-hour clock) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 January | 16:14 | 15:56 | 3:56 pm |
| 5 February | 17:09 | 16:51 | 4:51 pm |
| 5 March | 18:00 | 17:42 | 5:42 pm |
| 26 March | 18:35 | 18:17 | 6:17 pm |
| 2 April | 19:47 | 19:29 | 7:29 pm |
| 7 May | 20:45 | 20:27 | 8:27 pm |
| 25 June | 21:34 | 21:16 | 9:16 pm |
| 6 August | 20:53 | 20:35 | 8:35 pm |
| 3 September | 19:55 | 19:37 | 7:37 pm |
| 29 October | 17:52 | 17:34 | 5:34 pm |
| 5 November | 16:39 | 16:21 | 4:21 pm |
| 10 December | 16:04 | 15:46 | 3:46 pm |
Working, 1 January: sunset 16:14. 16:14 → 16:00 is 14 minutes. 18 − 14 = 4 more minutes. 16:00 → 15:56. Candle-lighting is 15:56, which is 3:56 pm.
Working, 5 March: sunset 18:00 is exactly on the hour, so all 18 minutes come off the hour before: 18:00 → 17:42. Candle-lighting is 17:42, which is 5:42 pm.
The other 2 that cross the hour: 17:09 → 17:00 is 9 minutes, then 9 more gives 16:51; 16:04 → 16:00 is 4 minutes, then 14 more gives 15:46.
All 12 times are correct, and the 4 sunsets less than 18 minutes past the hour (16:14, 17:09, 18:00 and 16:04) are worked back across the hour, with working shown for 2 of them. Common error to look for: 15:96 or 16:−4 for 1 January. Evidences criteria 1 and 2.
(a) 3:20 pm is after midday, so add 12 to the hour: 3 + 12 = 15. The end of school is 15:20.
(b) 10 December: from 15:20 to candle-lighting at 15:46 is 46 − 20 = 26 minutes.
5 February: from 15:20 to candle-lighting at 16:51. 15:20 → 16:00 is 40 minutes; 16:00 → 16:51 is 51 minutes; 40 + 51 = 91 minutes = 1 h 31 min.
(c) 10:48 pm is after midday, so 10 + 12 = 22: 22:48. Yes, it agrees: the table gives Saturday nightfall after Friday 25 June as 22:48.
Converts both ways between the 12-hour and 24-hour clock and finds a length of time by counting on to the hour. Evidences criteria 2 and 3.
| Week | Shabbat begins | Shabbat ends | Length (working) |
|---|---|---|---|
| (a) Winter: 10 to 11 December | 16:04 | 17:02 | Friday 16:04 → Saturday 16:04 is 24 h. 16:04 → 17:00 is 56 min; 17:00 → 17:02 is 2 min. 56 + 2 = 58 min. Length 24 h 58 min. |
| (b) Summer: 25 to 26 June | 21:34 | 22:48 | Friday 21:34 → Saturday 21:34 is 24 h. 21:34 → 22:00 is 26 min; 22:00 → 22:48 is 48 min. 26 + 48 = 74 min = 1 h 14 min. Length 25 h 14 min. |
(c) The summer Shabbat is longer. 25 h 14 min − 24 h 58 min: 24 h 58 min → 25 h is 2 min, then 14 more minutes, so it is 16 minutes longer.
(d) In a Welsh summer the sun goes down at a slant, not steeply, so it sinks below the horizon slowly and the sky stays light for a long time after sunset (the long summer twilight). It therefore takes longer for the sky to get dark enough to see 3 stars.
Counts on 24 hours first, then the extra minutes, and goes through midnight correctly; converts 74 minutes into 1 h 14 min. Part (d) is a sensible reason linked to light in the sky; accept any answer about it staying light for longer after sunset in summer. Evidences criterion 3.
Earliest: Friday 10 December, 16:04. Latest: Friday 25 June, 21:34.
16:04 → 21:04 is 5 hours; 21:04 → 21:34 is 30 minutes. The difference is 5 h 30 min.
Reads the extremes correctly from the table and finds the difference in hours and minutes. Evidences criterion 3.
(a) 18:35 → 19:35 is 1 hour; 19:35 → 19:47 is 12 minutes. On the clock, sunset is 1 h 12 min later.
(b) 19:47 BST − 1 hour = 18:47 GMT. 18:35 GMT → 18:47 GMT is 12 minutes. The sun really set only 12 minutes later; the other hour is just the clocks going forward.
(c) On the clock: 16:39 → 17:39 is 1 hour, 17:39 → 17:52 is 13 minutes, so sunset is 1 h 13 min earlier. In GMT, 17:52 BST is 16:52 GMT, and 16:52 − 16:39 is 13 minutes. So sunset is really only 13 minutes earlier; the clocks going back on 31 October make it look an hour more.
(d) 21:34 BST is 20:34 GMT. 16:04 → 20:04 is 4 hours, 20:04 → 20:34 is 30 minutes, so the real difference is 4 h 30 min. 1 hour of the 5 h 30 min in Step 5 is caused by the clocks, not by the sun.
Changes BST into GMT by subtracting 1 hour and uses this to separate the real change in sunset from the clock change. Evidences criterion 4.
Title: Friday sunset times in Cardiff, 2027
Sunset gets later every week from January (16:14) until the end of June, when it is latest at 21:34 in week 25. After that it gets earlier again until December, when it is earliest at 16:04 in week 49. The line suddenly jumps up by 1 h 12 min between weeks 12 and 13 because the clocks went forward on 28 March, and it suddenly drops by 1 h 13 min between weeks 43 and 44 because the clocks went back on 31 October.
All 12 points are plotted with crosses and joined with a ruler, and the graph has a title. Check a few points: week 0 (16:14) is just under 1 square up; week 25 (21:34) is between the 21:30 and 21:45 lines, just above 21:30; week 44 (16:39) is between the 16:30 and 16:45 lines. The description gives the latest and earliest sunsets with times and explains both jumps with the clock changes. Evidences criteria 4 and 5.
In Judaism a day begins at sunset, because in Genesis each day of creation is described as “evening and morning”, so the 7th day, Shabbat, begins at sunset on Friday. Sunset in Cardiff changes every week, so the start of Shabbat changes too: candle-lighting is at 21:16 on 25 June but at 15:46 on 10 December. In winter, a Jewish pupil who keeps Shabbat might need to be home only 26 minutes after school ends at 15:20, so they could not stay for a club, a match or a detention on a Friday, and they may need to leave a little early to help the family get ready before candle-lighting. Therefore a school could avoid putting tests, matches or detentions after school on winter Fridays, and it could allow the pupil to leave early on Fridays when Shabbat starts very early. It could also avoid setting homework that has to be done online over the weekend or on a Saturday.
Explains why Shabbat begins on Friday evening with a reason from Jewish teaching (a day begins at sunset; the 7th day of creation), uses times from the pupil’s own work, uses “because”, “so” and “therefore”, and suggests 2 practical ways a school could help. It treats keeping Shabbat as something that varies between families (“who keeps Shabbat”). Evidences criterion 6.