Worked example · RE · Year 10

Working out zakat, tithes and dasvandh

LNF: Numeracy → Understanding the number system helps us to represent and compare relationships between numbers and quantities → Relationships within the number system

What this is

A secure Year 10 response and full answer key, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. The key idea: 2.5% = 0.025 = 1/40 and 10% = 0.1 = 1/10, so zakat is “divide by 40” and tithes and dasvandh are “divide by 10”. Zakat: Aisha £160, Yusuf £0, Mariam £300, Idris £100.

Step 2: equivalences

FractionDecimalPercentage
1/100.110%
1/400.0252.5%
1/200.055%
1/80.12512.5%
3/50.660%
1/30.333…33.3% (to 1 decimal place)

1/3 is a recurring decimal: 0.333… goes on for ever. It is written 0.3 with a dot over the 3.

2.5/100 = 25/1000 = 1/40 is simplified fully, and the recurring decimal is identified and written correctly. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 3: zakat

PersonAt or above nisab?Zakat
Aisha, £6,400Yes6,400 ÷ 4 = 1,600; 1,600 ÷ 10 = £160
Yusuf, £3,200No, below £4,000£0
Mariam, £12,000Yes12,000 ÷ 4 = 3,000; ÷ 10 = £300
Idris, £4,000Yes, equal to the nisab4,000 ÷ 4 = 1,000; ÷ 10 = £100

Check for Aisha: 10% of £6,400 = £640, and a quarter of £640 = £160. This matches, because 2.5% is a quarter of 10%.

The pupil chooses the fraction form (1/40) because dividing by 4 and then 10 is easier than multiplying by 0.025, and checks with a second equivalent method. Idris is correctly included, because “equal to” counts. Evidences criteria 2 and 4.

Step 4: tithes and dasvandh

PersonEach monthEach yearFraction
Gareth2,400 ÷ 10 = £240240 × 12 = £2,8801/10
Harpreet1,850 ÷ 10 = £185185 × 12 = £2,2201/10

One tenth is found by dividing by 10, the quickest equivalent of 10%. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 5: fair comparisons

(a) First, the time periods are different: £240 a month is £2,880 a year, so it must be compared with £160 a year. Second, they are fractions of different things: Gareth gives 1/10 of his income, while Aisha gives 1/40 of her savings. We do not know Aisha’s income, or whether she also gives sadaqah, so we cannot say who is more generous. It is also unfair to judge a whole religion from one person.

(b) £160 + £40 = £200. 200 ÷ 6,400 × 100 = 3.125%. This is more than 1/40 (2.5%).

(c) Mariam: 300/12,000 = 1/40. Aisha: 160/6,400 = 1/40. They give the same fraction (2.5%) of their savings. Comparing fractions is fairer because it shows the share of what each person has, not just the size of the amount.

The pupil compares proportions, not raw amounts, and spots that the two amounts are measured over different times and against different totals. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 6: charity week

CharityFractionPercentageAmount
Food bank1/250%£620
Wells abroad1/425%£310
Hospice1/425%£310

Equal shares: 1/3 = 0.333… = 33.3% each. £1,240 ÷ 3 = £413.333…, a recurring decimal, so the money cannot be split into exactly equal amounts in pounds and pence: two charities could get £413.33 and one £413.34.

The recurring decimal is linked to a real, practical problem. Evidences criteria 1 and 3.

Step 7: explanation

2.5% means 2.5 out of 100. As a fraction this is 2.5/100, which is equivalent to 25/1000 and simplifies to 1/40. So finding 2.5% of an amount is the same as finding 1/40 of it, which means dividing by 40. The percentage and the fraction are equivalent: they are two ways of writing the same proportion.

A clear chain from percentage to fraction, using the three required words correctly. Evidences criterion 4.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure