Worked example · PSE / Well-being · Year 9

Writing a complaint that gets results

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Planning and organising for different purposes, audiences and context

What this is

A secure Year 9 response, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key. The key ideas: the headphones are not of satisfactory quality; within 30 days Rhys can reject them for a full refund and does not have to accept store credit or a repair; and a formal, organised, polite email is more likely to work than an angry one.

Step 1: fact file

What was boughtTonnau X2 wireless headphones (black)
Price and payment£59.99, paid by card
Date and receipt3 March, receipt number 004417
What went wrongLeft earpiece stopped working after 10 days of normal use; not dropped or wet
Shop’s offerStore credit, or repair by the manufacturer in 6 to 8 weeks; “no refunds on opened electronics”
Days until reply15 March − 3 March = 12 days

Step 2: rights

(a) They are not of satisfactory quality, because new headphones should last much longer than 10 days, and not fit for purpose, because one earpiece does not work.

(b) “We do not give refunds on electronics once they have been opened”: a “no refunds” policy does not remove his rights. Offering only store credit or a repair: within 30 days he can insist on a full refund. (Also: sending him to the manufacturer, when his contract is with the shop.)

(c) A full refund of £59.99. The 30 days start the day after he bought them, so he must reject them by 2 April.

The pupil matches the facts to the law precisely, which gives the complaint its strongest content. Evidences criterion 4.

Step 3: formal or informal

Hiya Dan: I. I am writing about …: F. This is a total joke …: I. I would be grateful …: F. Under the Consumer Rights Act 2015 …: F. Cheers, speak soon: I. I look forward to hearing from you by 20 March: F.

Rewrite: “This is a total joke” becomes “I am disappointed with this response, as it does not reflect my rights.”

Formal does not mean weak: the rewrite is polite but still makes the point firmly. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 5: model email

Subject: Refund request: faulty Tonnau X2 headphones, receipt 004417

Dear Sain Teifi Customer Service,

I am writing about a pair of Tonnau X2 wireless headphones that I bought from your shop on 3 March for £59.99, paid by card (receipt number 004417).

After 10 days of normal use, the left earpiece stopped working completely. The headphones have not been dropped or damaged in any way.

Thank you for your reply of 15 March. However, under the Consumer Rights Act 2015, goods must be of satisfactory quality and fit for purpose. As it is still less than 30 days since I bought them, I am entitled to reject the headphones and receive a full refund. I understand that a “no refunds” policy does not affect these rights, and that my contract is with your shop rather than the manufacturer.

I would therefore be grateful if you could arrange a full refund of £59.99 to my card. I can return the headphones to the shop this week. I look forward to hearing from you by 22 March.

Yours faithfully,
Rhys Morgan

About 180 words. Every paragraph has one job: purchase, problem, rights, request. Facts come first, then the law, then a precise request with a deadline. The tone is formal and polite throughout, with no exclamation marks, and “However” and “therefore” link the paragraphs. “Yours faithfully” matches “Dear Sain Teifi Customer Service”, because no name is used. Evidences criteria 1, 2, 3 and 4.

If you finish early: ideas

Why this response is secure