Worked example · Geography · Year 9

Writing a flood management decision for Pontgwenlas

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Planning and organising for different purposes, audiences and context

What this is

A secure Year 9 response, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key for Step 2. This pupil chose Option C. Pupils who choose A or B can do equally well if they organise their writing the same way and use figures. The key facts: Option A costs £6.5 million, more than twice the £3 million the council can spend, and may make flooding worse in Rhydfelen. Option B keeps only about 70 of the 180 homes dry and takes 10 to 15 years to work fully. Option C costs £2.4 million, works in 1 year, but means 12 families must move.

Step 2: sustainability grid

PillarA: Flood wallsB: Slow the flowC: Protect homes and move
Economic+ Protects all 40 businesses, so no more closures.
− £6.5 million is over the £3 million budget, plus £45,000 a year.
+ Cheapest at £1.8 million; 6 new jobs.
− 3 farms lose grazing land.
+ £2.4 million is within budget; clean-up costs fall by about two thirds.
− Businesses still get some water in a big flood.
Social+ All 180 homes protected.
− Main road closed for 6 months; Rhydfelen may flood more.
+ Helps the whole valley, not just the town.
− Only about 70 homes kept dry, and not for 10 to 15 years.
+ Fast (1 year) and a warning system keeps people safe.
− 12 families lose their homes and neighbours.
Environmental+ Takes up little land.
− Concrete releases carbon dioxide; walls cut people off from the river.
+ New habitats; trees and peat store carbon; cleaner water.
− Changes the look of the open hill.
+ New wetland park gives wildlife space and room for floodwater.
− 138 homes still get some water, so some pollution and waste after floods.

Every box has a point, and most have a figure copied accurately from the stimulus. The evidence is sorted by pillar before any writing starts. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 3: plan

ParagraphNotes
1. Reject A£6.5m, budget £3m; Rhydfelen worse; concrete carbon
2. Reject Bonly 70 of 180 homes; 10 to 15 years; farmers lose grazing
3. Justify Cecon: £2.4m, clean-up costs down two thirds; social: 1 year, warnings; env: wetland park, no harm downstream
4. Conclusionweakness: 12 families move; still best balance

Notes, not sentences, and each paragraph has one job. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 4: the decision

The council should choose Option C to manage flooding in Pontgwenlas. Option A, flood walls, would protect all 180 homes and 40 businesses. However, it costs £6.5 million, more than twice the £3 million the council can spend. Furthermore, the walls would make the river flow faster, so flooding in Rhydfelen could get worse.

On the other hand, Option B is the cheapest at £1.8 million and is good for wildlife. However, it would keep only about 70 homes dry, and it would take 10 to 15 years to work fully. People who were flooded in 2019 and 2024 cannot wait that long.

Option C is the best balance of all three pillars. Economically, it costs £2.4 million, which is within budget, and it cuts clean-up costs by about two thirds. Socially, it can be finished in just 1 year, and the text message warnings will give families time to move to safety. Environmentally, the new wetland park gives wildlife space and room for floodwater, whereas Option A would add concrete.

Overall, Option C has one serious weakness: 12 families on Stryd y Bont will have to move, although they can stay in the town. For these reasons, Option C is the most sustainable choice, because it helps the most people quickly without harming Rhydfelen.

223 words in 4 paragraphs that follow the plan exactly. Paragraphs 2, 3 and 4 open with linking phrases, and 10 different connectives are used (underlined). Each paragraph uses figures. The style is formal and balanced, and the conclusion admits a weakness before a precise final judgement. Evidences criteria 2, 3 and 4.

Step 5: improving one sentence

Before: “Option B is bad because it is slow and not many houses.”

After: “However, Option B would keep only about 70 homes dry, and it would take 10 to 15 years to work fully.”

The rewrite links back to the previous paragraph with “However”, replaces the vague “bad” and “not many” with figures, and is now a complete sentence. Evidences criterion 5.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure