Worked example · Science · Year 7
LNF: Literacy → Writing → Planning and organising for different purposes, audiences and context
A secure Year 7 response, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key. The correct order in Step 4 is C, E, A, F, H, B, G, D. The key idea: a method is organised for a reader who was not there, so it uses commands, numbered steps, exact quantities and correct names, not a story.
| Feature | Example from the model method |
|---|---|
| Aim | To find out which of 3 soils holds the most water. |
| Equipment with a size | 3 measuring cylinders (100 cm3) |
| Command verb | “Pour 50 cm3 of water onto each soil at the same time.” (also Put, Add, Start, Read, Record) |
| Quantity with a unit | 50 cm3 of water |
| A time | After 5 minutes |
| Safety point | Wash your hands after touching soil. |
Each example is copied accurately and matches its feature. Evidences criterion 1.
| Nia wrote | Instruction |
|---|---|
| we smashed it up | Crush 2 spatulas of rock salt with a pestle and mortar. |
| we put the water in the beaker, about 50 of it | Measure 50 cm3 of warm water and pour it into the beaker. |
| we stirred it for a bit | Stir with a glass rod until no more salt dissolves. |
| we did the filter thing | Pour the mixture through a filter paper in a funnel. |
| the water that came through went in the dish | Pour the filtrate into an evaporating basin. |
| we heated it up till it started spitting | Heat the basin gently until about half of the water has evaporated, then stop. |
(b) When the salt solution spits, drops of very hot salt can fly out and burn your skin or eyes. The method should say: heat gently and stop when about half the water has gone, then leave the rest to evaporate slowly.
Every instruction starts with a command verb, uses the correct equipment name (evaporating basin, not dish) and gives a quantity or an end point instead of “a bit”. Evidences criteria 2 and 5.
C → E → A → F → H → B → G → D
(b) F can go anywhere before H. The latest it can go is straight after A, because the filter must be ready before you pour the mixture through it.
The pupil follows the logic of the practical: dissolve, then filter, then evaporate. Evidences criterion 3.
Purifying rock salt
Aim: To separate pure salt from rock salt.
Equipment:
Method:
Safety:
The method is organised in the order a reader needs: title, aim, equipment, numbered steps, safety. One action per step, command verbs throughout, and exact quantities and names. Each safety point names the danger and says what to do. Evidences criteria 4 and 5.
Weakest step (first draft): “Heat it until the water goes.”
Improved step: “Put the basin on the gauze and heat it gently until about half of the water has evaporated.”
The improved step names the equipment, says how to heat and gives a clear point to stop. Evidences criterion 6.