Worked example · PE · Year 9
LNF: Literacy → Writing → Planning and organising for different purposes, audiences and context
A secure Year 9 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. This pupil chose badminton; dance fitness and girls’ tag rugby can be argued just as well. Useful figures: badminton costs 12 × £15 + £40 = £220; dance fitness with an instructor costs £30 × 12 = £360 for a 12-week term (over budget) or nothing with Sports Leaders; tag rugby costs £60 but the field is dark by about 16:30 in December.
(a) Mrs Ellis and the governors. They will want to know that there is a real need, that it is safe, who will run it, what it will cost, and how they will know it has worked.
✓ Headings: busy readers can find each answer. ✗ “Loads of kids ...”: slang and exaggeration make it look unserious. ✓ Exact figures with sources: governors trust evidence they can check. ✓ Recommendation: tells them exactly what to approve. ✗ Ignoring problems: they will spot them anyway, and it looks dishonest.
Every choice is justified by what this particular audience needs. Evidences criterion 1.
| Evidence | Why it persuades |
|---|---|
| 52 of 160 pupils with no club (32.5%) would join badminton, the most popular choice | Shows real demand among exactly the pupils the school wants to reach |
| 71 pupils say clubs are only for people good enough for the teams | A beginners’ club answers the biggest barrier directly |
| 48 pupils say clubs finish after their bus; the late bus runs on Wednesdays only | A Wednesday club removes the second biggest barrier at no cost |
| Sport Wales 2022: 39% of pupils do organised sport 3 or more times a week, down from 48% in 2018 | Shows the problem is national and getting worse, so action is needed |
(c) 12 rackets × £15 = £180, plus £40 of shuttles = £220. This leaves £30 of the £250 budget.
(d) Concern: 52 pupils will not fit on 6 courts. Answer: 6 courts take 24 pupils playing doubles, and others can rotate in, practise skills or umpire; if more than 30 sign up, we will run two groups on alternate weeks.
Evidence is chosen because it answers the governors’ questions, not because it is the biggest number. Evidences criteria 2 and 4.
| No. | Heading | Topic sentence |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Purpose | This proposal asks for approval to start a beginners’ badminton club on Wednesdays. |
| 2 | The need | Many pupils want to do more sport but feel school clubs are not for them. |
| 3 | The plan | The club would run in the sports hall every Wednesday from 15:20 to 16:20. |
| 4 | Cost and concerns | The club can be run within this term’s budget. |
| 5 | Recommendation | We recommend that the governors approve the club for a one-term trial. |
The order follows the reader’s questions: what is this, why, how, how much, what should we decide. Evidences criterion 3.
To: Mrs Ellis and the Governors
From: The School Sport Council
Proposal: a beginners’ badminton club
Purpose
This proposal asks for approval to start a beginners’ badminton club on Wednesdays, for pupils who do not currently attend any school club.
The need
Many pupils want to do more sport but feel school clubs are not for them. The Sport Wales School Sport Survey 2022 found that 93% of pupils in Wales wanted to do more sport, yet only 39% took part three or more times a week, down from 48% in 2018. In our own survey of 160 pupils who attend no club, 52 chose badminton, more than any other option, and 71 said clubs are only for pupils good enough for the teams.
The plan
The club would run in the sports hall every Wednesday from 15:20 to 16:20. Mr Hughes has offered to lead it. Because the late bus leaves at 16:30 on Wednesdays, the 48 pupils who said clubs finish after their bus has gone would be able to attend. Rackets would be provided, so pupils would only need trainers and PE kit.
Cost and concerns
The club can be run within this term’s budget. Twelve extra rackets at £15 each and shuttles at £40 would cost £220 in total. The six courts hold 24 players at once; if more than 30 pupils sign up, two groups would attend on alternate weeks.
Recommendation
We recommend that the governors approve the club for a one-term trial. We will report attendance each week and survey members at the end of term. If the trial succeeds, the club could continue next term and help more pupils become regular members.
263 words, not counting the To, From and title lines. To, From and title; five headed sections in a logical order; each opens with a topic sentence that matches the plan. Two national figures and four school figures, each with its source. The cost is worked out and within budget, and the main concern (numbers on the courts) is raised and answered. Formal register throughout, with no contractions or slang. Evidences criteria 2 to 5.
Weak topic sentence: “Here is some stuff about money.”
Improved: “The club can be run within this term’s budget.” It tells the reader the conclusion straight away, and it is formal.
Newsletter: “Never played badminton? Perfect. Our new beginners’ club starts on Wednesdays at 15:20 in the sports hall, and the late bus gets you home. Just turn up in trainers.” It is shorter, chattier and speaks to pupils directly, because the audience and purpose have changed.
Measure: weekly attendance compared with sign-ups, and how many members had never been to a school club before. A short survey on whether members enjoyed it “a lot” would compare with the Sport Wales figure of 40%.