Worked example · Business · Year 10
LNF: Literacy → Writing → Planning and organising for different purposes, audiences and context
A secure Year 10 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key. Key points: Option A breaks aim 2 (a £20,000 loan against a £10,000 limit) and Option B breaks aim 3 (weekend events that Siân must work herself). Year 1 extra profit is £4,000 for the café and £9,000 for the van; over 3 years it is £28,000 and £27,000. Dylan’s answer is Level 1, 3 marks. Either option can reach Level 3 if it is justified; this model chooses the van.
| Siân’s aim | Option A: second café | ✓ or ✗ | Option B: catering van | ✓ or ✗ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Known across the valley, more profit | New town, 38 of 50 customers would visit, leisure centre nearby. Only £4,000 profit in year 1, £15,000 by year 3. 3 rival cafés. | ✓ | Moving advert at about 30 events. £9,000 profit from year 1. 41 of 50 customers buy from vans. | ✓ |
| 2. Borrow no more than £10,000 | Borrow £20,000, double her limit. | ✗ | Borrow £4,000. | ✓ |
| 3. Keep weekends for family | Manager runs it, so Siân does not have to work there on Saturdays. | ✓ | Most events at weekends and only Siân can drive it at first. | ✗ |
| 4. Welsh cakes baked in her kitchen | Baked in Pontglas and driven over. | ✓ | Baked in Pontglas and sold from the van. | ✓ |
Every box has evidence from the case study, most with a figure. The grid already shows the key trade-off: each option breaks one aim. Evidences criterion 1.
(a) The van costs £16,000, so Siân would only need to borrow £4,000. This means she stays well inside her £10,000 limit, whereas the second café would need a £20,000 loan.
(b) Most of the 30 events are on Saturdays and Sundays, and only Siân is insured to drive. As a result, she would lose the weekends she wants with her children. However, Bethan wants to run the van, so insuring her would solve this.
(c) 38 of the 50 regular customers said they would visit a café in Aberbryn, so there seems to be demand. However, these are Pontglas customers, and there are already 3 cafés on Aberbryn high street, therefore the new café might struggle to win local customers.
Each chain starts with evidence, then uses a connective to show what it leads to. Chain (c) questions the survey instead of just repeating it, which is the kind of analysis Level 3 rewards. Evidences criterion 2.
(a) Level 1, 3 marks. He makes simple points about both options, and uses one figure, but no point is developed and the conclusion (“because it is better”) gives no reason.
(b) The case study says the café makes only £4,000 extra profit in year 1, less than half the van’s £9,000. So his main reason is wrong for the first 2 years, and he has not used the case study to check it.
(c) 1. Link points to Siân’s aims, especially the £10,000 borrowing limit, which the café breaks. 2. Develop each point with “this means that” or “as a result”, and use figures such as the profit forecasts. 3. Write a conclusion that weighs the options and says what the decision depends on. Also: put the paragraphs in order, with the recommendation first and all the points about one option together.
The mark is justified against the mark scheme, and the improvements are specific. Evidences criterion 3.
| Part | Notes |
|---|---|
| Opening sentence | Option B, van. Fits more aims. |
| Paragraph 1 | Borrowing: £4,000 vs £20,000. Limit £10,000. Less risk. |
| Paragraph 2 | Profit sooner: £9,000 vs £4,000 in year 1 (manager £26,000). Moving advert, aim 1. |
| Paragraph 3 | Drawback: weekends, only Siân insured. Rain cancelled 2 festivals. |
| Conclusion | Still better: debt low, £18,000 vs £13,000 over 2 years. Café catches up year 3. Depends on insuring Bethan. |
Notes, not sentences, in a clear order. The drawback has its own paragraph, and the conclusion already has a “depends on”. Evidences criterion 4.
I recommend that Siân chooses Option B, the catering van, because it fits more of her aims.
The main reason is borrowing. Siân wants to borrow no more than £10,000. The van costs £16,000, so she would only need to borrow £4,000. As a result, her repayments would be small and the risk would be low. In contrast, the second café needs a £20,000 loan, which is double her limit.
The van also makes money sooner. It is forecast to make £9,000 extra profit in year 1, whereas the café would make only £4,000, because Siân must pay a manager £26,000 a year. Furthermore, the van would be a moving advert at rugby matches and festivals, so it helps her aim of making Caffi’r Bont known across the valley.
However, the van has a serious drawback. Most events are at weekends and Siân must drive it herself at first, so she would lose the Saturdays she wants to keep for her family. The weather is also a risk, because a wet summer could cancel events.
Overall, the van is the better choice because it keeps her debt low and makes more profit in the first two years, £18,000 against £13,000. The café only catches up in year 3. My recommendation depends on Siân insuring Bethan to drive the van, so that she can keep some weekends free.
227 words. A clear recommendation in the first sentence, two developed reasons linked to aims 1 and 2, an honest drawback linked to aim 3, and a conclusion that weighs the options with figures (£9,000 + £9,000 = £18,000; £4,000 + £9,000 = £13,000) and says what the decision depends on. Connectives used: because, so, as a result, in contrast, whereas, furthermore, however, overall. Level 3, 8 or 9 marks. Evidences criterion 5.
Other option: “I recommend Option A, the second café, because it builds the business for the long term without costing Siân her weekends.” Conclusion: “Overall, the café is the better choice because by year 3 it makes £15,000 a year, against £9,000 for the van, and a manager runs it while Siân is with her family. This depends on Siân being willing to borrow more than her £10,000 limit.”
3-year totals: café £4,000 + £9,000 + £15,000 = £28,000; van 3 × £9,000 = £27,000. They are almost the same, so profit alone does not decide it. The aims about borrowing and weekends matter more.