Worked example · Food and Nutrition · Year 11
LNF: Literacy → Writing → Connectives and syntax
A secure Year 11 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is practice only, not NEA work. Key points: height rises from 18 mm to 41 mm but levels off (+11 mm from 0 g to 6 g, only +3 mm from 12 g to 18 g); the 12 g scones scored highest overall (4.3); the 18 g scones scored 4.2 for soapy aftertaste. The hypothesis is partly supported. Rhys’s draft has comma splices after “rose more” and “was right”, and 3 uses of “and then”.
| Cause and effect | Contrast | Adding or comparing | Pointing to evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| because, therefore, as a result, consequently, so | however, whereas, although, in contrast | furthermore, in addition, similarly | this shows that, for example, this is supported by |
Contrast sentence: The 18 g scones were the tallest; however, they had the lowest overall score of the three batches that contained baking powder.
All 15 connectives are in a sensible column. “So” could also go under adding in some sentences; accept it if the pupil explains. Evidences criterion 1.
Every sentence keeps the facts and figures. Sentences 2 and 7 start with a subordinate clause and use a comma to mark where the main clause begins. Sentence 5 uses a full stop before “However” to avoid a comma splice. Evidences criteria 2 and 4.
Problems: comma splice 1 is “rose more, the 18 g ones”; comma splice 2 is “was right, the tallest scones”. “And then” is used 3 times, which turns the results into a list instead of a comparison. The last sentence is wrong: the tallest scones (18 g) were not the best (12 g). “Because of carbon dioxide” is too vague to explain anything.
Rewrite: The scones with more baking powder rose higher, and the 18 g scones were the tallest. The 0 g scones were flat, while the 6 g scones were better. The 12 g scones were the best overall, whereas the 18 g scones tasted soapy. This is because baking powder releases carbon dioxide, which makes the scones rise, but too much leaves a soapy taste. My hypothesis was only partly right, because the tallest scones were not the best.
Both comma splices are fixed with a connective, the “and then” chain becomes comparisons with “while” and “whereas”, and the conclusion about the hypothesis is corrected. Evidences criterion 3.
Adding more baking powder made the scones rise higher, but the best scones had 12 g, not the most. The mean height rose from 18 mm with no baking powder to 41 mm with 18 g. However, the increase slowed down: the height went up 11 mm from 0 g to 6 g, whereas it went up only 3 mm from 12 g to 18 g. This happened because baking powder releases carbon dioxide when the dough is wet and heated. As a result, the gas bubbles expanded in the oven and the dough rose until the heat set its shape. Although the 18 g scones were the tallest, the tasters liked them least of the three raised batches. They scored 4.2 out of 5 for a soapy aftertaste, because too much alkali was left in them. In contrast, the 12 g scones had the highest overall score, 4.3, and were described as “light and fluffy”. Therefore, the hypothesis is only partly supported. More baking powder did make the scones higher, but it did not make them better once there was more than 12 g.
185 words, in the order the worksheet asks for. Connectives: cause and effect (because, as a result, therefore), contrast (but, however, whereas, although, in contrast). Sentence openings are varied (Adding, The, However, This, As a result, Although, They, In contrast, Therefore, More). Every claim has a figure or a quotation, and the science explains the pattern. Evidences criteria 4 and 5.
Rewritten hypothesis: “Adding baking powder up to 12 g will make scones higher and lighter, but more than 12 g will give only a little more rise and a soapy taste.”
Evaluation: Although Rhys repeated each batch with 3 scones, he only made one batch of each amount. Therefore, one batch that was rolled slightly thicker could have changed the mean, so he should make each batch at least twice.
Affect and effect: “affect” is usually a verb and “effect” is usually a noun. The amount of baking powder affects the height. Too much baking powder has an unpleasant effect on the flavour.