Worked example · Languages, Literacy and Communication · Year 5

Writing kind and useful comments on a class blog

DCF: Citizenship → Online behaviour and online bullying

Also assessed, LNF: Literacy → Writing → Connectives and syntax

What this is

A complete, secure Year 5 answer with the sorting key and model comments. Connectives are underlined, as pupils are asked to do. Pupils’ own comments will be different; look for a kind tone, a reason, a helpful idea and correctly used connectives.

Step 1

Kind and usefulKind but not usefulUnkindNot safe
3, 61, 72, 54

Useful: “It tells the writer exactly what worked and gives one idea to make it better, so they know what to do next time.”

Comment 4 is friendly but shares a home address, which anyone reading the blog could see. Comment 5 is online bullying: it is hurtful and tries to make others join in. Evidences success criterion 1.

Step 2

3 and 6: let it appear. 1 and 7: ask the writer to improve it. 2, 4 and 5: delete it and talk to the writer (for 4, Mr Morgan should also remind Jac never to post his address).

What Elis should do: “Tell a trusted adult, like Mr Morgan or a parent. Do not reply in an angry way. The adult can save it, delete it and report or block the person.”

Telling a trusted adult and not replying are the key strategies at this age. Evidences success criterion 2.

Step 3

“Online you cannot see the person’s face or hear their voice, so a joke can sound mean. A comment can stay online for a long time and lots of people can read it, but something you say face to face is heard once. Some people write things online because they think nobody knows who they are.”

Three real differences: no face or tone, permanence and audience, and anonymity. Evidences success criterion 3.

Step 4: model rewrites

Comment 1: “Your poem is good because the gulls shouting and the boats nodding made me smile.”

Comment 2: “I don’t usually read poems about the sea, but I liked the last line because ‘quiet, sleepy, black’ is a calm way to end.”

Comment 7: “Wow, I loved the galloping horses because they made the waves feel fast and wild!”

Each rewrite keeps the writer’s idea, turns it kind and adds a reason or suggestion with a connective. Comment 2 is a multi-clause sentence that uses but to contrast and because to explain. Evidences success criterion 4.

Step 5: model own comment

“I loved the first two lines because I could see the white waves running like horses. When I read the middle part, I wanted to hear more about the harbour, so maybe you could add the sound of the boats’ ropes clinking.”

Sentence 1 gives a precise reason with because. Sentence 2 starts with a subordinate clause (When I read…) and uses so for a consequence. Accurate punctuation and a kind, helpful tone. Evidences success criteria 4 and 5.

If you finish early: example rules

  1. Say what you liked because it helps the writer know what works.
  2. Give one idea to improve the work, but say it kindly.
  3. Never share where you live or your phone number, because anyone can read the blog.

What to look for