Worked example · Social Studies · Year 11

Writing to a councillor with survey findings

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Planning and organising for different purposes, audiences and context

What this is

A secure Year 11 response, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. It is also your model answer. The key ideas: the reader is a councillor who must save £2.1 million, so the email must respect that problem and ask for something specific. The survey figure most open to challenge is 58% using the club, because 40 of the 150 young people were surveyed at the club itself. Different evidence and a different request (for example, keeping two evenings) are fine if they are well organised and honest.

Step 2: audience and purpose

QuestionAnswer
ReaderCllr Eleri Vaughan, cabinet member for education and youth services. She helps decide the budget.
Her problemThe council must save £2.1 million next year.
What we wantVote to keep the club open three evenings a week, or at least two.
ToneFormal and respectful.

Evidences criterion 1.

Step 3: evidence

EvidenceWhy it persuades
71% of users say the club is the only place they go in the evening (Source 1)Shows there is no other option if it closes.
45% of users got help from a youth worker with a problem (Source 1)Councillors care about wellbeing and education; it shows the club does more than keep young people busy.
Reports at the bus station fell from 48 to 29; police say fewer calls on club nights (Source 3)Links the club to a problem the council must also pay to deal with, and the police are an independent voice.
“The youth worker helps me with maths because we can’t afford a tutor.” (Age 16)A real voice that shows who loses most.

(b) The 58% could be challenged, because 40 of the 150 were asked at the club, so users are over-represented. I will not rely on it, and I will say how the survey was done.

Evidence is chosen for this reader, and a weak figure is spotted and handled honestly. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 5: the email

Subject: Please keep Aberwennol youth club open three evenings a week

Dear Councillor Vaughan,

We are the Aberwennol Youth Forum, and we are writing about the plan to open the youth club on Friday evenings only from April.

In October we surveyed 150 young people aged 11 to 18 at Ysgol Aberwennol, the sixth form college and the club. Of the 87 who had used the club in the last month, 71% said it is the only place they go in the evening apart from home, and 45% had been helped by a youth worker with a problem such as bullying, exams or family worries. One 16-year-old told us: “The youth worker helps me with maths because we can’t afford a tutor.”

The club also helps the wider town. The Aberwennol Echo reported that anti-social behaviour reports at the bus station fell from 48 to 29 this year, and Sergeant Rees said there are fewer calls on club nights.

We understand that the council must save £2.1 million, and that this change would save £14,000. However, only 36% of the young people we asked could afford the leisure centre each week, so it is not a real alternative for most of them.

We ask you to vote to keep the club open three evenings a week. If that is not possible, please keep Wednesday as well as Friday. We would welcome the chance to meet you to discuss this.

Yours sincerely,

Cerys Hughes
Chair, Aberwennol Youth Forum

About 240 words. Five paragraphs follow the plan: purpose, survey, wider evidence, the council’s side, the request. Every figure gives its source. The councillor’s problem is acknowledged before it is answered with a figure. The request is specific and offers a fall-back. The greeting and “Yours sincerely” match because the reader is named. Evidences criteria 3, 4 and 5.

Step 6: improving one sentence

Before: “Loads of people use the club and it would be really bad if it shut!!”

After: “Of the 87 who had used the club in the last month, 71% said it is the only place they go in the evening apart from home.”

Slang and exclamation marks are replaced by a precise, formal sentence with a figure. Evidences criterion 5.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure