Slide 1 of 7 · Settling starter · English · Year 10
3 minutesAnalysing fake news: one story, three reports
Three pieces of writing describe the same event: the closure of the Old Bridge in Llanbedr-ar-Fryn. One is a news report, one is campaigning, one is invented on top of somebody else’s photograph. The town is invented; every trick is real.
While the register is called: write your name, class and date on your worksheet, then start reading Report A on the stimulus sheet. Highlight every number and every named person.
Starter question: According to Report A, how long will the Old Bridge close, and from which date?
Slide 2 of 7 · Today’s brief and key words · English · Year 10
2 minutesYour brief: judge all 3 reports, then rewrite the worst one accurately
You will judge each report against the same 8 questions in the evaluation grid, list 5 things you would check next and where, then rewrite Report C’s headline and opening paragraph so that every claim is supportable. Keep it interesting: “boring but true” is not the lesson.
Evidence
The quoted words and numbers that made you decide. Write evidence in the grid, not verdicts about the writer.
Attributed
A figure is attributed when the text says where it came from, such as a council report or a named person.
Reverse image search
Searching with a picture instead of words to find where else that picture has appeared, and when.
Slide 3 of 7 · Steps 1 and 2: read, then complete the grid · English · Year 10
20 minutesStep 1 & Step 2: read all 3 reports, then complete the evaluation grid
Step 1 (8 min): read Reports A, B and C in pairs. Highlight every number and every named person. Step 2 (15 min): complete the grid. Write evidence, not verdicts: quote the words that made you decide.
| Question | Report A, Chronicle | Report B, Llanbedr Voice | Report C, aggregator |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who wrote it? Named or not? | Nia Hopkin, local democracy reporter: a named person with a named job | “Admin”. No person is accountable for it | “NewsWalesDaily”: an account name, not a journalist |
Slide 4 of 7 · Step 3: five things I would check next · English · Year 10
6 minutesStep 3: five things I would check next, and where
Each check must be something you could actually do, and you must say where you would do it. Think of the council’s published report, a reverse image search, a second news outlet.
| What I would check | Where I would check it |
|---|---|
| Whether the inspection report really says eight weeks and £1.4m | Bryn Hir Council’s website. Report A says it was published on 12 March, so it should be findable |
| Whether the photograph in Report C is of the Old Bridge | A reverse image search; also compare it with any picture on the council’s page |
Slide 5 of 7 · Step 4: rewrite Report C accurately · English · Year 10
13 minutesStep 4: rewrite Report C’s headline and opening paragraph
Write a new headline that is accurate and still worth clicking, then an opening paragraph of about 120 words. Every number attributed. Nothing you cannot support. Finish with 1 sentence saying what you removed from the original and why.
Model headline: Eight-week closure for cracked Llanbedr bridge, but walkers and cyclists can still cross
Model opening: “The Old Bridge over the Afon Wen will shut to vehicles from Monday 25 March for about eight weeks while two cracked arches are repaired, according to a highways report published by Bryn Hir Council on 12 March.”
Slide 6 of 7 · Step 5: self and partner check · English · Year 10
3 minutesStep 5: swap sheets and mark against the criteria
Swap with your partner. Tick each success criterion their sheet meets, then challenge 1 thing they wrote.
- I judge all three reports against the same criteria instead of only attacking the obvious one.
- My grid gives evidence, quoted words and numbers, rather than opinions about the writer.
- I identify at least two specific false claims and say what the accurate version is.
- My checks are things that can actually be done (the council’s published report, a reverse image search, a second outlet), and I say where.
- My rewrite keeps the story readable while attributing every figure to its source.
Slide 7 of 7 · Plenary review · English · Year 10
3 minutesQuick-check answers before handing in
Check your main answers before your worksheets are collected.
| Question | Correct answer |
|---|---|
| What is the pattern in Report C’s 3 figures? | £14m, two years and 40km are each exactly 10 times the published figures (£1.4m, 8 weeks, 4km). |
| Why is “the council refused to comment” in Report B provably false? | Councillor Dafydd Rees gave a quotation to the Chronicle on 13 March. |
| What is wrong with the photograph in Report C? | It is a 2016 stock photograph of a bridge in Yorkshire, captioned “The Old Bridge yesterday”. |