Supply teacher deck · English · Year 9

Debating Online Rights: Paper-Based Arguments

Slide 1 of 7
03:00

Slide 1 of 7 · Settling starter · English · Year 9

3 minutes

Debating online rights: who should own your data?

Every app you use costs money to build and run, yet almost none of them charge you. Instead you pay with information. Today you choose a side and defend it in a structured written argument.

While the register is called: write your name, class and date on your worksheet, then read the title and the 2 headings on the stimulus sheet.

Starter question: What do you pay with when an app is free?

DCF: Citizenship → Digital rights, licensing and ownership No computers needed · paper only

Slide 2 of 7 · Today’s brief and key words · English · Year 9

2 minutes

Your brief: choose one side and defend it

Your stimulus sheet has 2 opposing views about who should control personal data online. Choose one side and write a structured argument of 4 paragraphs and at least 300 words: introduction, 2 developed points with evidence, and a conclusion.

Evidence

A fact or quotation from the stimulus sheet that supports your point, followed by your explanation of why it matters.

Counter-argument

The strongest thing the other side would say. You answer it instead of ignoring it.

ICO

The Information Commissioner’s Office, the UK regulator that investigates misuse of personal data and can issue fines.

UK GDPR

The law that gives you the right to see the data an organisation holds about you, correct it, and in many cases have it deleted.

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Planning and organising for different purposes, audiences and context Marked on structure and evidence, not on which side you pick

Slide 3 of 7 · Step 1: read both perspectives · English · Year 9

5 minutes

Step 1: read both perspectives and underline your evidence

Read Perspective A, Perspective B and the Useful facts you may quote on the stimulus sheet. Underline anything you could use as evidence. Do not decide your side until you have read both.

Perspective A: collecting data is a fair trade Perspective B: personal data should stay personal
Free apps are paid for with your information. Data also makes services better: a map routes you round a jam, a revision app gives you more of what you get wrong, fraud teams spot a stolen bank card. The “choice” is not a real one: Terms of Service run to thousands of words and “reject” is often 2 menus deeper than “accept”. Collected data will eventually leak, and data that was never collected cannot be stolen.
Step 1 on your worksheet · 5 minutes Underline facts, not whole paragraphs

Slide 4 of 7 · Step 2: fill in the planning box · English · Year 9

5 minutes

Step 2: decide your side and fill in the planning box

Fill in all 7 rows of the planning box on your worksheet. Decide your side before you start writing. The first 3 rows below show a plan for Perspective B as a model; your plan can defend either side.

Planning box Model answer (Perspective B)
The side I am defending Perspective B: personal data should stay personal.
Point 1 Consent that is this hard to refuse is not consent at all.
Evidence for point 1 Terms of Service run to thousands of words; “reject” is buried 2 menus below “accept”; refusing often means losing the service.
Step 2 on your worksheet · 5 minutes Every point needs evidence from the stimulus sheet

Slide 5 of 7 · Step 3: write your argument · English · Year 9

25 minutes

Step 3: write your argument in full sentences on lined paper

Aim for 4 paragraphs and at least 300 words: introduction, point 1 with evidence, point 2 with evidence, the counter-argument and your answer, then a conclusion that restates your case without adding new information. Use the sentence starters if you are stuck.

Sentence starters: “In today’s digital world…” · “Whenever we install an app…” · “Firstly… This matters because…” · “Some people argue that… However, this ignores…” · “Under UK data protection law…” · “To conclude, the stronger case is… because…”

Model opening: “Every time we install an app we are asked to agree to something almost nobody reads. Companies call that a fair trade: our data for their free service. I am going to argue the opposite, that personal data should stay personal, because the choice we are offered is not a real choice and the risks land on us, not on the company.”

Step 3 on your worksheet · 25 minutes, in silence Quote the evidence, then explain why it matters

Slide 6 of 7 · Step 4: self and partner check · English · Year 9

3 minutes

Step 4: swap with a partner and check against the success criteria

Swap your argument with a partner. Tick each criterion their work meets and tell them 1 thing to improve. Then correct 1 thing in your own work.

  • I state clearly which side I am defending in my first paragraph.
  • I make 2 separate points, each with evidence from the stimulus sheet.
  • I name at least 1 real right or rule (for example the right to have data erased, or the ICO).
  • I answer the strongest argument from the other side instead of ignoring it.
  • My conclusion restates my case without adding new information.
DCF: Citizenship → Digital rights, licensing and ownership Finished early? Rewrite your introduction for the opposite side

Slide 7 of 7 · Plenary review · English · Year 9

2 minutes

Quick-check answers before handing in

Check these 3 facts against your argument before your work is collected.

Question Correct answer
Which UK regulator investigates misuse of personal data and can issue fines? The Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO).
Name 1 right UK GDPR gives you over your data. The right to see the data an organisation holds about you, correct it, or in many cases have it deleted.
What must services likely to be used by under-18s do under the Age Appropriate Design Code? Default to high privacy settings.
Hand in your worksheet and your written argument together Name and class on both sheets