Supply teacher deck · Maths · Year 10

Misleading Graphs in the Media

Slide 1 of 7
05:00

Slide 1 of 7 · Settling starter · Maths · Year 10

5 minutes

Misleading graphs in the media

A graph can be accurate in every number and still leave you believing something false. The stimulus sheet, Five graphs, five headlines, shows 5 graphs from a council newsletter, a smoothie advert, a swimming club report, a news page poll and a governors’ report. At least 1 of them is fair.

While the register is called: write your name, class and date on your worksheet. Then look at all 5 graphs without writing. For each one read the headline, then the axes, then the source line.

Starter question: In Graph A, what are the 2 recycling rates shown, and what number does the vertical axis start at?

DCF: Data and computational thinking → Data and information literacy No computers needed · calculator, ruler and protractor

Slide 2 of 7 · Today’s brief and key words · Maths · Year 10

3 minutes

Your brief: find the trick, measure it, redraw it honestly

You will find the trick in each graph, measure how big a false impression it creates, redraw Graph A honestly, and write a 5-question checklist you can use on any graph you meet online. Careful: not every graph on the sheet is misleading.

Percentage points

The gap between 2 percentages. From 62% to 64% is a rise of 2 percentage points.

Percentage increase

The change divided by the starting figure, times 100. 2 ÷ 62 × 100 = 3.2%.

Scale factor

How many times bigger a picture is drawn. Scale factor 2 multiplies area by 2² = 4.

Axis break

A zigzag on an axis showing it does not start at zero. Fair if it is labelled and the graph is a line graph.

LNF: Numeracy → Interpreting data Always point to evidence you can see on the graph

Slide 3 of 7 · Steps 1 and 2: spot the trick, then Graph A in numbers · Maths · Year 10

17 minutes

Step 1 & Step 2: fair or misleading, then measure Graph A

Step 1 (10 min): for Graphs A to E write fair or misleading, the trick in a few words, and the evidence you can see on the graph. Step 2 (10 min): count gridlines in Graph A, work out the real change in percentage points and as a percentage increase to 1 decimal place, then redraw Graph A with the axis starting at zero and give it an honest headline.

Graph Fair or misleading? The trick The evidence on the graph
A Misleading Bar chart with a cut-off axis. The axis starts at 61, not 0. The 2023 bar is 1 gridline gap tall and the 2024 bar is 3, so a 2-point rise looks like the rate tripled.
Steps 1 and 2 on your worksheet · 17 minutes Percentage points and percentage increase are different numbers

Slide 4 of 7 · Steps 3 and 4: the bottles and the swimming club · Maths · Year 10

13 minutes

Step 3 & Step 4: Graph B’s bottles, then Graph C’s growth per year

Step 3 (6 min): by what number were sales multiplied? Measure the 2 bottles: how many times as tall, how many times as wide, so how many times the area? What should the advert have drawn instead?

Step 4 (7 min): complete the table for the swimming club, then explain why the line looks straight and write a headline that matches what really happened.

From → to Years Members gained Members gained per year
2004 → 2014 10 15 1.5
2014 → 2019 5 15 3
Steps 3 and 4 on your worksheet · 13 minutes Members gained per year = members gained ÷ years

Slide 5 of 7 · Steps 5 and 6: the pie chart and the attendance line · Maths · Year 10

12 minutes

Step 5 & Step 6: Graph D adds up to too much, is Graph E fair?

Step 5 (7 min): add up the 4 percentages in Graph D. Measure the angle of the Bus slice with a protractor and work out what percentage of the pie it really is (a full turn is 360°). Explain why the percentages add up to more than 100 and say what kind of chart should have been used.

Step 6 (5 min): Graph E’s axis does not start at zero either. Is it misleading? Use the headline, the axis label and the type of graph in your answer. Then work out the fall from September to December in percentage points.

Graph E data (attendance, %): Sep 95.1 · Oct 94.2 · Nov 93.0 · Dec 91.8 · Jan 92.5 · Feb 93.1 · Mar 93.6 · Apr 94.0 · May 94.3 · Jun 93.2 · Jul 92.4

No protractor? The Bus slice measures 135°.

Steps 5 and 6 on your worksheet · 12 minutes The zero rule is for bar charts; a line graph can start higher if it says so

Slide 6 of 7 · Step 7 and self check · Maths · Year 10

3 minutes

Step 7: your 5-question checklist, then check your work

Write 5 questions anyone should ask before they believe or share a graph. Each question must catch at least 1 trick on the stimulus sheet. Then tick each success criterion you have met and correct 1 thing.

  • I can name the technique that makes a graph misleading and point to the evidence on the graph itself.
  • I can calculate the real change, in percentage points and as a percentage, and compare it with the change the picture suggests.
  • I can explain why doubling the height and width of a picture makes it look 4 times as big.
  • I can redraw a misleading graph honestly and write a headline that matches the data.
  • I can recognise a fair graph, including a line graph whose axis clearly does not start at zero.
Step 7 on your worksheet · 3 minutes Finished early? Redraw Graph C with the years to scale on the back

Slide 7 of 7 · Plenary review · Maths · Year 10

2 minutes

Quick-check answers before handing in

Check your main answers before your worksheets are collected.

Question Correct answer
Graph A: what is the real rise, and how many times as tall is the 2024 bar? 2 percentage points, or 3.2%; the bar is drawn 3 times as tall.
Graph B: sales doubled. How many times the area does the 2024 bottle cover? 4 times, because 2 × 2 = 4.
Which graph is fair, and why? Graph E: a line graph, the axis break is drawn and labelled, and the headline says what the line shows.
Check your name and class are on your worksheet Leave stimulus sheets, rulers and protractors neat on the desk