lnf.cymru stimulus sheet · English · Year 11

The Aberllydan bypass: fact sheet, audience profiles and reaction cards

Invented for practice. The town of Aberllydan, Cors Llydan Wetland Reserve, the Cors Llydan Trust, the schools, the survey and every figure on this sheet are invented. Use only these figures in your speech.

The issue

Aberllydan is a small market town in mid Wales with 6,800 people. The main road runs straight down the High Street, past shops, homes and Ysgol Gynradd Aberllydan, the primary school. The county council has proposed the Aberllydan bypass: a new 3.4 km road around the east side of the town, so that through traffic no longer uses the High Street.

The problem is the route. For 0.7 km the new road would cross Cors Llydan Wetland Reserve, a 62 hectare area of bog, reed bed and wet meadow on the edge of the town, run by the Cors Llydan Trust. The road would sit on a raised bank of earth (an embankment) across the reserve.

Before the county council decides, the Aberllydan Town Council Planning Committee will vote on whether to support or oppose the route. The town council has also asked the school council at Ysgol Aberllydan, the secondary school, to send in the views of its pupils.

Fact sheet

The case FOR the bypassThe case AGAINST this route
Traffic: 9,200 vehicles a day use the High Street, including 780 lorries. The bypass would take about 6,500 vehicles a day off the High Street (about 7 in 10).Habitat lost: the embankment would take 9 of the reserve’s 62 hectares and split what is left in two.
Journey times: crossing the town at busy times takes 12 minutes now. The bypass would take 3 minutes.Wildlife: 6 pairs of curlew (large wading birds with long curved beaks) nest in the wet meadow, and otters live along the stream. Curlew need wide, quiet, open fields to nest.
Safety: there were 11 road collisions on the High Street in the last 5 years. 4 of them involved people on foot.Flooding: in heavy rain the reserve soaks up water like a sponge. The Cors Llydan Trust warns that 45 homes on Heol y Felin could flood more often if the embankment is built.
Air quality: last year, fumes from traffic (nitrogen dioxide) were above the council’s target level outside the primary school on 38 days.Carbon: the peat under the route stores about 10,000 tonnes of carbon. Digging and building on it would release some of that carbon into the air.
Jobs: building the road would create 110 jobs for 2 years.More traffic later: the council’s own consultants predict that total traffic in the area will rise by 12% within 10 years of the road opening, because new roads attract extra drivers.
Business: a survey of 70 High Street businesses found 41 support the bypass, 22 oppose it and 7 are undecided. Supporters say a quieter street would bring more shoppers on foot.Cost: the bypass would cost £41 million. The Trust says a £3 million package (a weight limit to ban through lorries, a 20 mph zone, 2 new crossings and air monitoring) could make the High Street safer within a year.
Old buildings: vibration from lorries is blamed for cracks in 3 of the oldest buildings on the High Street.People: the reserve has 14,000 visitors a year, and schools run 25 field trips there each year. Most children in the town have been pond dipping there in primary school.

Audience profile 1: the Town Council Planning Committee

Who7 elected councillors and the Chair. Most are over 50. They have read long reports about the bypass and have heard many speakers already.
Where and whenThe council chamber in Aberllydan Town Hall, Tuesday at 19:00. Members of the public may speak for 90 seconds each, and the Chair stops anyone who runs over.
What they expectFormal language. Speakers begin “Chair, members of the committee”. They want evidence and figures, the effect on the whole town, a clear view on costs, and a clear request at the end.
What turns them offEmotion with no evidence, slang, attacking people who disagree, and speakers who run over time.
What they can doVote to support or oppose the route. Their view goes to the county council.

Audience profile 2: a Year 7 assembly at Ysgol Aberllydan

WhoAbout 120 Year 7 pupils, aged 11 and 12. Many walk to school along the High Street. Most went pond dipping at Cors Llydan in primary school. They know almost nothing about planning, roads or councils.
Where and whenThe school hall, Monday at 08:50. You have 90 seconds before the next notice.
What they expectSomeone who talks to them, not at them. Short sentences, words they know, questions, and examples from their own lives. A story or a picture in words holds their attention better than a list of figures.
What turns them offLong words, lots of numbers, being talked down to, and not knowing why this matters to them.
What they can doYear 7 will vote in form time on Friday: support the bypass, oppose it, or undecided. The school council will send the result to the town council. They can also talk to their families.

Reaction cards

Fold or tear along the lines. The audience member holds these cards face down. During each speech, hold up one card, at any moment between 20 and 60 seconds in. Keep it up until the speaker has responded, then put it down. Use a different card for the second speech.

CONFUSED
I don’t understand what you mean.
BORED
You are losing me.
UNCONVINCED
I don’t believe you yet.

Words that help